Guess I'll put in serious input because you are quite slanderous via text messaging. Some of my favorites at the moment are: regular production: Bolivar Belicosos FInos, H. Upmann Half Corona, PSP2, Partagas 898, Ramon Allones Allones Extra'11 (may be in the minority here), Vegas Robaina Unicos; non-regular production: H. Upmann Mag 48, RA Celestios Finos, SCdlH Oficios.
It's all basically preference so I would say try as many as possible, the hard part is that age changes them all a decent amount. What you don't like fresh might be good in a year and in 4 may be outstanding. Just try and buy multiples at a time and try them with like a month age, 6 mo., year, etc. Box would be ideal, because if they turn out to be really good you have plenty left. However, money and storage come into play in a big way at that point.
In my opinion the Party 898 smoke well young and age really well, same for the H. Upmann Half Corona. Those are two good starters one decently long smoke and one quickish smoke.
We can always do a trade or something!
Edit: Great avatar pic btw