America's #1 Online Cigar Auction
first, best, biggest!

Last post 3 weeks ago by B.harrington.21. 15696 replies replies.
314 Pages«<304305306307308309310311312>»
n00b PIB
jeebling Offline
#15351 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
All of this is Tiver’s fault.
jeebling Offline
#15352 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
JGRAZ wrote:
Got a "Tele"gram today.
4 never hads 5 more that I have including 4 more of my favs

Rojas Bluebonnet Robusto - NH
Rojas Statement Robusto - NH
Room 101 Chief Cool Arrow - Only had one, from you, and liked it
Cigar Paradise Generation No1 - NH
Cigar Paradise Silver Collection - NH
4 x Room101 Master Collection 3 Roxxo - One of my favorites, but I think you know that by now. Luckily I have you supplying me. I think I search every few days hoping some will pop up somewhere.

Thank you as always


Tele always sends interesting smokes. Very nice smack attack. I hope you enjoy those my brother!
corey sellers Offline
#15353 Posted:
Joined: 08-21-2011
Posts: 10,859
The fun and games of this has always been the passing . But the passing to the same person and picking them up multiple times makes no sense . That means you are going to send multiple packages to the same person . That’s stupid when you have to pay shipping for each individual box . I did not do that I was going to the PO and had smokes I was wanting to move cause they are old and someone needs to enjoy them. Some of the boxes were not even open. I did nothing wrong go back to page 172 and start reading from there . There actually is another noob pib that was created along the way. CONAN CAN YOU TOP THAT ONE.
corey sellers Offline
#15354 Posted:
Joined: 08-21-2011
Posts: 10,859
I do have to apologize to SOB I used that hateful name at the end BIDEN THE DUMBASS. I should have never posted that.
Huzza3045 Offline
#15355 Posted:
Joined: 11-07-2022
Posts: 918
#ReleaseCorey #HeDidNothingWrong
JGRAZ Offline
#15356 Posted:
Joined: 10-31-2022
Posts: 1,862
jeebling wrote:
All of this is Tiver’s fault.


Nah
All was going good till a few weeks ago when Corey decided he had to get rid of half of his collection. Herfing
jeebling Offline
#15357 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
corey sellers wrote:
The fun and games of this has always been the passing . But the passing to the same person and picking them up multiple times makes no sense . That means you are going to send multiple packages to the same person . That’s stupid when you have to pay shipping for each individual box . I did not do that I was going to the PO and had smokes I was wanting to move cause they are old and someone needs to enjoy them. Some of the boxes were not even open. I did nothing wrong go back to page 172 and start reading from there . There actually is another noob pib that was created along the way. CONAN CAN YOU TOP THAT ONE.


As the recipient of one very large mother effing bomb, I’m happy to have been caught up in that whirlwind smack down. Is my storage obliterated? Smashed to smithereens? Blasted to kingdom come? Yup. Loving every minute of it too. And it has been a lot of fun even now seeing the shockwave still causing damage so many trades away from Ground Zero. I say let’s set DEFCOM 4.

ram27bat
jeebling Offline
#15358 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
JGRAZ wrote:
Nah
All was going good till a few weeks ago when Corey decided he had to get rid of half of his collection. Herfing


I’ve been digging out all week from some of the damage you’ve caused me, JGRAZ!

Herfing ram27bat
jeebling Offline
#15359 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
Huzza3045 wrote:
#ReleaseCorey #HeDidNothingWrong


Yeah! Maybe we should take up a collection or something…
corey sellers Offline
#15360 Posted:
Joined: 08-21-2011
Posts: 10,859
Just go ahead and set it to 5 . This is my las bomb on here . If you think that was halve of my collection you are badly mistaken. That was not even a 64th . I will now show you you . Just trying to figure out if the box will hold it all . 2016 and has not been made since . SOB is fixing to have to add more storage . I hope he shares with youse guys.
JGRAZ Offline
#15361 Posted:
Joined: 10-31-2022
Posts: 1,862
corey sellers wrote:
Just go ahead and set it to 5 . This is my las bomb on here . If you think that was halve of my collection you are badly mistaken. That was not even a 64th . I will now show you you . Just trying to figure out if the box will hold it all . 2016 and has not been made since . SOB is fixing to have to add more storage . I hope he shares with youse guys.


Maybe I'll send him some extra containers to get him ready
dharbolt Offline
#15362 Posted:
Joined: 08-03-2013
Posts: 7,025
Rut roh
Telecaster52 Offline
#15363 Posted:
Joined: 04-22-2022
Posts: 894
Huzza3045 wrote:
#ReleaseCorey #HeDidNothingWrong


LOL LOL

set him free
set him free
set him free


LeeBot Offline
#15364 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,408
I am mostly good w chaos, but we do need some structure . But I like passing my turn. I get to hit somebody vicariously without having to actually put a box together. It's very lazy, err, I mean "efficient.". I am nothing if not "efficient."
Telecaster52 Offline
#15365 Posted:
Joined: 04-22-2022
Posts: 894
Lets add Lee to the list.
Telecaster52 Offline
#15366 Posted:
Joined: 04-22-2022
Posts: 894
Got to rally the nOOb"s
LeeBot Offline
#15367 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,408
Lee is actually trying to lay low and smoke some of the many fantastic cigars I have already been given.
Telecaster52 Offline
#15368 Posted:
Joined: 04-22-2022
Posts: 894
LeeBot wrote:
Lee is actually trying to lay low and smoke some of the many fantastic cigars I have already been given.


Haha. I heard you was selling all your gifted stuff.
jeebling Offline
#15369 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
Telecaster52 wrote:
LOL LOL

set him free
set him free
set him free




RELEASE THE KRAKEN

ram27bat horse
jeebling Offline
#15370 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
Telecaster52 wrote:
Lets add Lee to the list.


He’s already on the list…are we putting him on twice?
Huzza3045 Offline
#15371 Posted:
Joined: 11-07-2022
Posts: 918
Just got the package from Jeebs. In typical Jeebs fashion, the damages are immense. I will post the damages shortly.
Huzza3045 Offline
#15372 Posted:
Joined: 11-07-2022
Posts: 918
Surely that’s not a box of cigars, it looks like my shipment of textbooks, I thought to myself. However, Jeebs’ wrath does not know the confines of typical procedure.

*= favorite
+= was something that I was wanting to try

Everything not labeled with a * or + is a NH.

AF 858 NT*
AF Cuban corona
AJF New World
AJF New World Puro Especial
AJF RdG Exclusivo
Aganorsa Leaf Casa Fernandez
Arganese Habano
CH Jericho Hill
CH La Careme*
CH Serie E*
Caldwell Eastern Standard Sungrown*
DE Norteno
Diesel rabbit hole sherry cask
Diesel unholy cocktail
Don Pepin Garcia Series JJ+
EP Carrillo Encore
EZ Brass Knuckles death before dishonor
EZ Eminence
EZ black cocoa and marshmellow
El Centurion H 2K CT
Flor de Las Antillas Maduro+
H Upmann Nicaragua AFJ heritage
Hyperion by El Titan de Bronze
LFD Cameroon Cab (x2)+
La Aurora Preferido Cameroon (x2)*
La Aurora Preferido Corojo*
La Gloria Cubana Esteli
La Harencia Cubana
La Imperiosa Nicaragua
Ortega Cigar Co Cubao
Papas Fritas*
Perdomo Champagne 10th anniversary*
Plasencia Reserva Original
Punch gran puro
RP 15th Anniversary
Room 101 Johnny Tobacconaut+
Room 101 Muzzleloader
San Lotano Oval Maduro
Tatuaje Havana IV*
Tatuaje Tattoo*
Temperance Volstead
Temperance Whiskey Rebellion
Valcari the Messenger
Warped Sky Flower+

And as if that weren’t enough, he threw in some pecan treats as well.

Clearly Jeebs can’t read, these are not noob smokes at all. Further, he somehow raided my phone to find my list of cigars I wanted to try without my knowledge.

Anyways, thanks for the bomb Jeebs, I can’t imagine I’ll smoke through these for a couple years at the rate I smoke. Hell of a bomb, brother.
corey sellers Offline
#15373 Posted:
Joined: 08-21-2011
Posts: 10,859
Well done Jeebs
LeeBot Offline
#15374 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,408
That's crazy! Jeebs is leaving a path of destruction in his wake.
JGRAZ Offline
#15375 Posted:
Joined: 10-31-2022
Posts: 1,862
Good lord Jeebs that's insanity.
Congrats Huzza you're covered for the next year or so.
jeebling Offline
#15376 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
Huzza, you are most welcome. At your rate of consumption some of those will be able to rest well. I hope you enjoy.

OBTW, did you get an alphabetical inventory w/that? Today while tidying up my explosives assembly area I found a list of smokes that were in alphabetical order. I hope I didn’t forget to put that in the box and you had a pain in the azz sorting it out.
Huzza3045 Offline
#15377 Posted:
Joined: 11-07-2022
Posts: 918
jeebling wrote:
Huzza, you are most welcome. At your rate of consumption some of those will be able to rest well. I hope you enjoy.

OBTW, did you get an alphabetical inventory w/that? Today while tidying up my explosives assembly area I found a list of smokes that were in alphabetical order. I hope I didn’t forget to put that in the box and you had a pain in the azz sorting it out.


You included a semi-alphabetized list! I always put things through an online alphabetizer before posting on here. Wouldn’t want to post a chaotic list in this sacred place.
jeebling Offline
#15378 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
Oh yes, I remember now. I had a stack of them that were covered by the bags and I missed them, had to work them back through. Anyway, I’m glad you had it covered from jump.
jeebling Offline
#15379 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
LeeBot wrote:
That's crazy! Jeebs is leaving a path of destruction in his wake.


I was feeling a tad guilty because Huzza mentioned that his storage situation is tight but then I thought…meh, eff him, and I launched bedlam on his azz.

ram27bat
Tiver Offline
#15380 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 618
I was gone for the weekend visiting DOD for father's day. Upon my return I found a box that weighs just a bit too much to be a simple nOOb hit, direct from B.21. Well, I opened it to find a nice hit of cigars along with a couple surprises. I'm thinking B.21 is pretty good at this trade/PIB stuff.

Details to follow when I get a list together
Tiver Offline
#15381 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 618
And to the two ne'er do wells, there are packages due to your places tomorrow or Wednesday.

OK, ne'er do well is too strong. You both are great brothers, but I have to razz youse somehow after you all tried putting me through the meat grinder.
Telecaster52 Offline
#15382 Posted:
Joined: 04-22-2022
Posts: 894
Jeebs I'll get your box packed up and shipped today
Tiver Offline
#15383 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 618
Let's get the damages from B.21 posted here. A great assortment of cigars and a couple add-ons

A bag of medium roast from "Death Wish Coffee Co. Well received to be sure. I love coffee and this promises to be a good cup.

A Xikar Eclipse lighter! Terrific and great timing. Carrillo logo (i like Carrillo cigars much). It's a nice triple flame pocket size. I really needed a good pocket lighter as my reliable ones are all table top lighters.

AND the cigars...

Ave Maria Argentum
Cohiba Nicaragua
Gurkha Class Regent - this looks like it might be a pretty tasty Gurk from a quick web look up
Hoyo de Monterrey excalibur
LGC Esteli
Mark Twain The Press No 3- this is a big 7x56 cigar
Nica Rustica - I have yet to try any Nica Rustica, but have wanted to
Punch Gran Puro - I think Punch cigars are solid
RP The Edge
RP No 6 - I've seen these often and look forward to a go
RyJ Reserva Real
San Cristobal Revelation - looking forward to this "Mystic" BP

Bill, this is really nice assortment of cigars that you've sent. Some I've commented on. Others I've known and enjoy.

Thanks for the cigars, coffee and lighter. I look forward much. How ya gonna beat Coffee and cigars? What a GREAT offering.
jeebling Offline
#15384 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
Telecaster52 wrote:
Jeebs I'll get your box packed up and shipped today


Take your time, Tele. Postpone’till October if you like 😂
jeebling Offline
#15385 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
B.21, excellent hit on a well deserving mother…I mean brother 😝 I’ve had Death Wish coffee and enjoyed it. Some of the best cigars from RyJ and Punch you included - in my opinion. Enjoy, Tiver, Stay Smokey brother.
B.harrington.21 Offline
#15386 Posted:
Joined: 03-26-2024
Posts: 130
Tiver wrote:
Let's get the damages from B.21 posted here. A great assortment of cigars and a couple add-ons

A bag of medium roast from "Death Wish Coffee Co. Well received to be sure. I love coffee and this promises to be a good cup.

A Xikar Eclipse lighter! Terrific and great timing. Carrillo logo (i like Carrillo cigars much). It's a nice triple flame pocket size. I really needed a good pocket lighter as my reliable ones are all table top lighters.

AND the cigars...

Ave Maria Argentum
Cohiba Nicaragua
Gurkha Class Regent - this looks like it might be a pretty tasty Gurk from a quick web look up
Hoyo de Monterrey excalibur
LGC Esteli
Mark Twain The Press No 3- this is a big 7x56 cigar
Nica Rustica - I have yet to try any Nica Rustica, but have wanted to
Punch Gran Puro - I think Punch cigars are solid
RP The Edge
RP No 6 - I've seen these often and look forward to a go
RyJ Reserva Real
San Cristobal Revelation - looking forward to this "Mystic" BP

Bill, this is really nice assortment of cigars that you've sent. Some I've commented on. Others I've known and enjoy.

Thanks for the cigars, coffee and lighter. I look forward much. How ya gonna beat Coffee and cigars? What a GREAT offering.


I’m not a huge coffee drinker and the name caught my attention. So hope you like it. Enjoy those smokes buddy!!! That Gurkha isn’t terrible but it’s also not great.
LeeBot Offline
#15387 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,408
That was a nice hit. I've seen that coffee, have wanted to try it.

Nice selection of cigars. I think you're getting the hang of things.
Huzza3045 Offline
#15388 Posted:
Joined: 11-07-2022
Posts: 918
Box from Tiver landed! He has apparently been keeping track of sticks in my wheelhouse based off of posts in this forum. Here are the damages :

-Buffalo Trace (smoked one at the buffalo trace distillery, which isn’t too far from me. Great smoke)
-Camacho Corojo (NH)
-CAO Cameroon (NH)
-Carlos Torano Exodus 1958 (NH)
-CH La Careme (I’m always pumped to have more of these. It’s like smoking a snickers bar)
-Laranja Reserva (NH)
-MF Flor de las Antillas (Stellar smoke, the last one I smoked was fantastic)
-Oliva CT (great smooth Connie)
-Oliva Serie O (had one ROTT before, looking forward to trying another)
-Perdomo Champagne (great Connie)
-Plasencia Reserva Original (NH)
-Warped Corto (already have some resting, glad to have another!)
-Zino Platinum (also an old favorite)

I think the fact that you went through my previous posts to send me some old favorites makes the package even more meaningful. Thanks for the smokes, Greg. I look forward to them!
jeebling Offline
#15389 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
Damn, Tiver. That was an awesome run on Huzza. Good job, he deserved that act of violence 😝
jeebling Offline
#15390 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
TIVER 18 JUNE ‘24

Tiver, you dropped a bomb on me. Seriously, these are cigars that I would select for myself. I’ve only tried a couple of these but I’ve never had them in these vitolas. I’m stoked with the Corona and Rothschild bag as I’ve been looking for these vitolas recently. Luckily, I haven’t pulled the trigger on any of these blends except the CH La Caréme and I have that in the Toro parked in storage awaiting cooler weather to come before I burn it. I intend to smoke a few of these right away. Thank you for another awesome box of smokes my brother from another mother.

Damage assessment, 16 spectacular cigars:
AJF San Lotano Requiem Maduro Rob
CAO Flathead 450 Sparkplug Rothschild
Carlos Toraño Exodus 1959 Rob
Crowned Heads Le Carème Rob
Crowned Heads Maduro Earl “Coronet”
Espinosa 601 Oscuro
Hoyt Quick Draw Corona
JdN Antaño Dark Corojo Rothschild, never seen this and it intrigues me
MF FdlA Sun Grown Belicoso
Oliva Master Blend 3 Rothschild I think
Oliva Serie O Rob
Padron Series 5000 Maduro Rob
Polpetta Rothschild I think
Ramon Bueso Genesis Oscuro Rob
Tat Havana VI Hermosos Rob
Warped Corto Rothschild I think

Some of the ones I identified as Rothschild may be Corona, my apologies to all you FOGs. The rest are Robusto. Tiver could be a mind reader. I’m truly excited to try these never-hads. Thanks again, Tiver for this thoughtful and generous gift.
Tiver Offline
#15391 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 618
Huzza3045 wrote:
Box from Tiver landed! He has apparently been keeping track of sticks in my wheelhouse based off of posts in this forum. Here are the damages :

-Buffalo Trace (smoked one at the buffalo trace distillery, which isn’t too far from me. Great smoke)
-Camacho Corojo (NH)
-CAO Cameroon (NH)
-Carlos Torano Exodus 1958 (NH)
-CH La Careme (I’m always pumped to have more of these. It’s like smoking a snickers bar)
-Laranja Reserva (NH)
-MF Flor de las Antillas (Stellar smoke, the last one I smoked was fantastic)
-Oliva CT (great smooth Connie)
-Oliva Serie O (had one ROTT before, looking forward to trying another)
-Perdomo Champagne (great Connie)
-Plasencia Reserva Original (NH)
-Warped Corto (already have some resting, glad to have another!)
-Zino Platinum (also an old favorite)

I think the fact that you went through my previous posts to send me some old favorites makes the package even more meaningful. Thanks for the smokes, Greg. I look forward to them!


Hey Colton,

Don't give me more credit than I deserve d'oh!

I do pay attention. Mostly I recall your commentary that your choice in smokes typically hovered in a range not too far either side of medium. I tried to go with connies, cameroon, corojo, habano to keep in line.

Hoping a NH or two hits the spot and glad some regulars are adding to your stock

Enjoy

Tiver Offline
#15392 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 618
jeebling wrote:
TIVER 18 JUNE ‘24

Tiver, you dropped a bomb on me. Seriously, these are cigars that I would select for myself. I’ve only tried a couple of these but I’ve never had them in these vitolas. I’m stoked with the Corona and Rothschild bag as I’ve been looking for these vitolas recently. Luckily, I haven’t pulled the trigger on any of these blends except the CH La Caréme and I have that in the Toro parked in storage awaiting cooler weather to come before I burn it. I intend to smoke a few of these right away. Thank you for another awesome box of smokes my brother from another mother.

Damage assessment, 16 spectacular cigars:
AJF San Lotano Requiem Maduro Rob
CAO Flathead 450 Sparkplug Rothschild
Carlos Toraño Exodus 1959 Rob
Crowned Heads Le Carème Rob
Crowned Heads Maduro Earl “Coronet”
Espinosa 601 Oscuro
Hoyt Quick Draw Corona
JdN Antaño Dark Corojo Rothschild, never seen this and it intrigues me
MF FdlA Sun Grown Belicoso
Oliva Master Blend 3 Rothschild I think
Oliva Serie O Rob
Padron Series 5000 Maduro Rob
Polpetta Rothschild I think
Ramon Bueso Genesis Oscuro Rob
Tat Havana VI Hermosos Rob
Warped Corto Rothschild I think

Some of the ones I identified as Rothschild may be Corona, my apologies to all you FOGs. The rest are Robusto. Tiver could be a mind reader. I’m truly excited to try these never-hads. Thanks again, Tiver for this thoughtful and generous gift.


I saw you were having a hard time with the heat so put out a few "shorter" duration smokes for your warm weather enjoyment.

petite corona corona robusto petite rob rothschild whatever as long as you enojoy
jeebling Offline
#15393 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
Thanks, Tiver. Very thoughtful and strengthens the bond of brotherhood. 😎
jeebling Offline
#15394 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705

CH Coronetta Maduro Earl (5 x 52) with thanks to Tiver.

Can’t think of a better cigar I’ve smoked this year. The Monte CC from Delta was awesome but in a different, lighter blend. The two aren’t fairly comparable.

(Post edit: Grab your Tele-nubber and your ballz, this is a fantastic cigar)

Never heard of this until Tiver mentioned it. It is a beautiful cigar with immaculate seems and no veins to speak of. It is firm in the hand but not brittle. One tiny indentation near the foot that was not mushy and presented no problems at all. The foot has a more fruity scent than the body, which has a curious “shop-like” smell that is pleasant. Cold draw tastes either like mild crabapples or cherries that are still firm. Kick off with some black pepper, maybe a hickory lick, and something fruity, floral and sweet. Excellent draw, perfect for my smoking preference. The cigar strikes me as a dry smoker and I like it that way. I’m a noob so I’m not sure if I’m identifying that dryness properly. 3 tokes in strong pizza crust, the brown bits that bubble up over the dough. Hickory smoke and pizza crust dominate, tiny edge of black pepper flavor with a gentle warmth on the backend roof of my mouth. This is mighty close in flavor to Tatuaje Black that has been aged properly for 6 or 7 years. I’ve installed my patented Tele-nubber early because I don’t want to goof it when the cigar wrapper is warm. Beginning transition to second third the Hickory is dominant but balanced, pizza crust is greatly diminished but has firm presence, discernible note of cocoa nib and scant hint of warming cinnamon enter the mix. Wow! The flavor of a jalapeño burned into pizza crust bursts onto the stage and steals the scene with mouth warming flavor. That alternates with a mix of bitter cocoa and orange peel. No salinity up to this point. Perfect burn line and impressive ash, cool smoker even though I’m abusing it. The sweetness of the dark and sticky MSA wrapper remains constant and on the low, no molasses or mineral profile whatsoever that I expect from MSA or the chewy Brazilian and C/PBL wrappers. There has been an elusive note in the retro which is just beginning to show a more creamy texture. The bitter side of roasted Chestnuts jumps in with more black pepper. Still in second third I’m getting hay on some of the draws, very mouth warming spicy effects. Entering final third suddenly need a minor touch up on burn line. Well into final third and the retro is an exhilarating burn. Flavors collapsing but there is burned brown sugar and burned Pecan with some Cedar. Finishing up in grand Ernest Perillo-Cortez fashion, the MSA burned sweetness is pretty much the only flavor, big and bold and stout, retro exquisitely singeing my nostrils. Thank you, Tiver! This was a fantastic cigar.
jeebling Offline
#15395 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705
19 June ‘24
DT&T Polpetta 4 x 48 w/thanks to Tiver. (Worthy of patented Tele-Nubber)

Is this a Rothschild? Corona? Petite Corona? Absolutely stunning mottled ox blood CBL wrapper, basic sweet tobacco on the nose. Nothing in the cold draw but an interesting lighter colored cap has the mouth tobacco tasting mild and oaty. Kickoff with grilled meat and black pepper, oyster sauce. The MSA binder is not hidden behind the CBL wrapper, it is standing out loud and proud. The JR Cigar website says this nugget:
“Available in just one 4 x 48 vitola, the cigars are of made of mostly mixed filler tobacco cuts used in the brands bestselling Mi Querida, Mi Querida Triqui Traca, and Umbagog cigar lines. In addition to the table cuts, the blend also incorporates some long leaf filler, making for a much higher quality mixed filler blend”

Hard to believe this is mixed filler. Firm cigar, stiff ash, perfect burn line and draw. Harder yet to believe is the right down the middle “medium” this cigar is. Fair warning, it is sold as a full profile cigar. Second third, nice flavors with cocoa, earth, caramel popping in and out, but not overly sweet. The salinity is trying to break in but it seems like it’s having a hard go. Retro just now tingling and a bit of orange peel detected. Cool smoker even though I’m pushing it. Strength is building significantly towards full, back of throat and lips beginning to tingle. Final third getting a Cayenne sensation mouthfeel, charred meat and oak barrel. Good right to the nub. Total smoke time about 40-45 minutes. The Rojas breakfast tacos compare about $5.45 to the Polpetta’s $7.3 and the Sumatra taco is equally or more satisfying for me. The La Aurora Preferido prices are all over the place but on sale I can find them for less than $3. I love those. I realize that’s not a side by side price comparison. Polpetta is a good smoke but I probably won’t be buying them if I can still buy the others. Thanks for a good never had smoke, Tiver.
Sunoverbeach Offline
#15396 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2017
Posts: 15,325
4x48 I'd say closest to a Rothschild
Cheno Offline
#15397 Posted:
Joined: 06-06-2019
Posts: 2,188
B21 sorry for the LONG delay, package should arrive Monday according to tracking.
Tiver Offline
#15398 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 618
jeebling wrote:
19 June ‘24
DT&T Polpetta 4 x 48 w/thanks to Tiver. (Worthy of patented Tele-Nubber)

Is this a Rothschild? Corona? Petite Corona? Absolutely stunning mottled ox blood CBL wrapper, basic sweet tobacco on the nose. Nothing in the cold draw but an interesting lighter colored cap has the mouth tobacco tasting mild and oaty. Kickoff with grilled meat and black pepper, oyster sauce. The MSA binder is not hidden behind the CBL wrapper, it is standing out loud and proud. The JR Cigar website says this nugget:
“Available in just one 4 x 48 vitola, the cigars are of made of mostly mixed filler tobacco cuts used in the brands bestselling Mi Querida, Mi Querida Triqui Traca, and Umbagog cigar lines. In addition to the table cuts, the blend also incorporates some long leaf filler, making for a much higher quality mixed filler blend”

Hard to believe this is mixed filler. Firm cigar, stiff ash, perfect burn line and draw. Harder yet to believe is the right down the middle “medium” this cigar is. Fair warning, it is sold as a full profile cigar. Second third, nice flavors with cocoa, earth, caramel popping in and out, but not overly sweet. The salinity is trying to break in but it seems like it’s having a hard go. Retro just now tingling and a bit of orange peel detected. Cool smoker even though I’m pushing it. Strength is building significantly towards full, back of throat and lips beginning to tingle. Final third getting a Cayenne sensation mouthfeel, charred meat and oak barrel. Good right to the nub. Total smoke time about 40-45 minutes. The Rojas breakfast tacos compare about $5.45 to the Polpetta’s $7.3 and the Sumatra taco is equally or more satisfying for me. The La Aurora Preferido prices are all over the place but on sale I can find them for less than $3. I love those. I realize that’s not a side by side price comparison. Polpetta is a good smoke but I probably won’t be buying them if I can still buy the others. Thanks for a good never had smoke, Tiver.



Polpetta is in the same vein as the Liga Papas Fritas. Mixed filler. Cuts from their premium and added long filler. Lots of brothers have issue with the prices and I might also. I did get these in a 5er for $25 and that was a great point to give it a shot. I posted simple impressions in the azzhats 1000000 thread that hit some of your points. I think they would benefit from a few months rest, but were not wasted on an immediate smoke. I think there's meat on them bones.

Overall i feel they are hiding a bit complexity that could mature with a little rest. I would buy again at $5ea
B.harrington.21 Offline
#15399 Posted:
Joined: 03-26-2024
Posts: 130
Cheno wrote:
B21 sorry for the LONG delay, package should arrive Monday according to tracking.



Man it’s all good. I know you been down. I’ll let you know when received and hope your recovery going well.
jeebling Offline
#15400 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 3,705

Esteban Carreras 187 Maduro Toro with thanks to CHENO

Never heard of this outside of the gift by Cheno.
Toothy Nic Maduro, it’s a Puro by AJF. Shiny and oily, streaked dark, flat veins and seems, smells like aged tobacco and a doughnut shop, chocolate on foot, not much on cold draw. Very earthy on kickoff with black pepper, leather and smidgen of anise. Easy draw. I expected more black pepper from AJF Nic but this was not homicidal. The burn line is self correcting but has my eye worried, foot throwing off a bit too much smoke for my liking. Nice mellow savory flavor and lemon balm on tame retro. Second third good balance of savory, sweet, salty notes. Cigar might be a tad under filled, throwing off a lot of smoke, smoke production on draw is variable and I need to keep after it or it tries to die on me. Final third, burn line still ugly but self-correcting, nice savory flavor but kinda monotonous. Black pepper conspicuously absent and retro is very mellow. Burn line required 1 touch up in final third, smoke production all but gone except from foot. Double bumping the draw at the nub I’m getting molasses, burned coffee, no salinity or minerals. Smoke time about an hour fifteen which seems kinda quick. I think the cigar may have been under filled and could have used another month at proper RH. The box this was in in March and April was around 70 to 72, since end of April around 64-66. It was a bit too moist, my fault. A good cigar w/potential, thank you, Greg.
Users browsing this topic
Guest (3)
314 Pages«<304305306307308309310311312>»