Mrs. dpnewell wrote:Victor, being vile and hateful to someone, is being vile and hateful. To me, it is unacceptable and evil, no matter what the motive. If you want to insist that one is more evil then the other based on motive, well, that's your choice.
victor wrote:
So I take it you're in the camp of "it's not right to call Nazis bad names"?
Wow! Where did that come from?!!!!!
David (dpnewell)
How are you not able to see this?
Even your quote above: "being hateful to someone is being vile and hateful. to me it unacceptable and ....etc"
that right there is saying it's not right to be mean to nazis. not criticizing you for it, if you really truly are in the camp of every single human being in this world deserves to be treated nicely, then you're probably a better person than all of us.
(however, based on posts of yours I've seen in the past, I don't think you really adhere to that)
But the logic is unassailable.
If you believe this statement:
"Why are hatefull, vile comments based on race any worse then hatefull, vile comments based on someone's political views?"
Then you believe that saying something hateful about nazis (a political view) is equivalent to saying something hateful about black people, or gays, or anyone.
I am not as good a person as you apparently. I judge people.... daily. If someone says something I believe to be stupid, I judge them as a person who says something stupid. I'll likely say something to them to the effect of "that was stupid".
If someone holds a large number of stupid thoughts in their head, it usually coalesces into a dogmatic political view of equal stupidity.
I believe it is significantly different to judge someone (and point out the judgement) for a believe, or idea they came up with due to an unwillingness to look at information, than it is to judge someone based solely on the color of their skin.
One judgement is based on choices a person has made, ideas they have in their head. The other is based solely on their birth and is something they never had control over.
You appear to find the two things equivalent, and the judgement of each party the same, thus the logical conclusion that you would find bieng mean to nazis as unacceptable too. I don't find it to be equivalent. In fact, I might even judge the decision-making process of people who find them equivalent....