frankj1 wrote:well, he's right in that it is probably constructed well, but that won't assure a "good" cigar.
That's what I was thinking. It was second hand information so I think the inexperienced customer got confused.
I found the following written about Graycliff Chateau Grand Cru, a cigar I really enjoyed a few years ago, but apparently they're all gone now.
I can't even find a picture of one. It came in a pink box that other guys made jokes about. Now I think they were just jealous. It had a little nipple tip on it that made it super easy to light with just one stick match, and quickly swelled out at the end to about a 54 ring gauge, then gradually tapered down fairly straight to a 40 ring gauge before rounding off at the head. Must have been 8 inches long, and priced at $32. It consistently smoked really well from the very start to the last finger-burning end. Wonderful flavor, excellent draw, never got hot or harsh. Even burn. I didn't know how fortunate I was at the time!
If all cigars were like this the world would be a better place. But cigar smokers would be spoiled rotten!
https://www.coronacigar.com/product/Cigars/Cigar-Boxes/Graycliff-Chateau-Grand-Cru-Uncut-PG-Cigars-GCCH24UPG/
Quote:In 2005 Graycliff released Avelino’s masterpiece, the Graycliff Chateau Grand Cru, which is full-bodied, having deep flavors of leather and a spicy core. Many, including myself, compare this cigar to the premium Pre-Castro Cubans of yesteryear, and with carefully selected and expertly blended tobaccos from Costa Rica, Honduras, and Nicaragua, the cigar is very much like those aged Cubans, balanced and rich.
They keep referring to a full body flavor without being too powerful. Flavor intensive but not harsh.
Some full-body cigars I've tried were too strong, others very pleasant.
Some cigars rated medium body I prefer to others rated medium-to-full body.
Some medium-full body I prefer to others medium body.
Sometimes the same cigar is rated medium on one website and medium to full on another website.
Makes me wonder if someone didn't make a mistake in the rating.