Personally I think the Giants made out.
Diva wide receiver that hasn’t proven to be durable - only had one season in which he played in all 16 games. Played in 59 games over his 5 year career.
Salary cap hit in Dead Money is high (...over $19M...) but down-the-road, gives them a chance to sign Barkley to a 2nd contract (...assuming he’s not overused and rundown in 4 years...).
The draft picks give them the opportunity to move up in the draft to pick their QB of the future. Yes, they could have done that last year but Gettleman must have taken his Stupid Pills that day.
Jabril Peppers moves into Landon Collins’ spot. Peppers is still on his rookie contract so better than overpaying Collins.
My opinion and pure speculation but the diva part must have been wearing thin on the Giants locker room. From my limited experience as a player and a coach, loudmouth, “throw me the ball” receivers do more harm than good. When they’re on and catching a bunch of passes, they’re happy and all is good in the world but if you’re not targeting them then no matter if the team wins or loses, the world is crumbling and the reason for losing is that they’re not getting the ball. I’ve seen too many receivers go into a shell and not run routes at full speed / correctly if they don’t think they’re gonna get thrown to. Or half-arse blocking on running plays.
I guess in a couple of years we’ll find out who “won” the trade.