Speyside wrote:Got it, kind of dense on my part. You're saying if JJ'S God exists Trump has done nothing wrong because he had no free will in the matter. Wouldn't this also mean that Trump is a better person than you? I think Trump believes in the same God JJ does, if so based on what you are saying they both need to understand they have no free will so there is no good or bad for them. You on the other hand have free will based on your lack of belief, so you can do good or bad. Unless of course you want to say you have never done bad.
Depends on your perspective.
If JJ's god exists, then yes, you are correct... people have no free will, there is good/bad (as in people who were predetermined to make good/bad actions, but they do not bear the blame for having made those actions). If the god is truly omniscient and omnipotent then all blame rolls up to them.
Philosophically, if this god exists, whether I believe in it or not, I would be predetermined to act in exactly the way I am acting as well. Just another character created by that god as a foil, and just as blameless (but again, can be judged as good/bad based on actions).
Fortunately for all of us, there is no god, omnipotent/omniscient or otherwise. And JJ, tRump and myself are all responsible for our own actions.