Brewha wrote:Cars have clear benefit to society.
AR-15, not so much. In fact none that I can see.
Unless it is an abortion law - right?
Well maybe I think AR-15 are killing school kids and too much of a liability to be a toy. Besides there is no real reason to have them.
Right, right; Guns=Cars.
So shouldn't gun users be licensed, just like car users?
Let's break tis down, a lot to unpack here...
Brewha wrote:Cars have clear benefit to society.
AR-15, not so much. In fact none that I can see.
OK, so one of the leading causes of pollution, climate change and death (by vehicle accident) in the US has no downside, right? Because YOU see value in them, it's ok to ignore the negative impacts they have. Once again, you use your personal belief system "none that I can see" to try to impose on a constitutional right. Not going to work this week or next week.
Brewha wrote:Unless it is an abortion law - right?
Well maybe I think AR-15 are killing school kids and too much of a liability to be a toy. Besides there is no real reason to have them.
Help me find the spot in the constitution that spells out the right to an abortion? Which ammendment was that? I did a word search and, not suprisingly, the word "abortion" isn't there. Anywhere. I see that the second ammendmnet spells out a right very specific to guns, though. I appreciate your consistency in injecting your personal belief once again with "there is no real reason to have them..." Tell that to this lady: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/home-invader-fatally-shot-florida-pregnant-woman-ar-15-n1076026 or anyone who has ever used an AR-15 to stop something bad from happening.
Brewha wrote:Right, right; Guns=Cars.
So shouldn't gun users be licensed, just like car users?
Once again, I searched the constitution for "automobile or car or drive" and found no specifically delineated right afforded to citizens regarding driving. Therefore, States are free to regualte it as they each see fit. Additionally, do you really believe that having some requirement for a "minimum standard" test to own a firearm would increase safety? Has licensing drivers caused an end to speeding, red light running, crashes, etc.?
The problem most 2A propenents have with proposed restrictions on guns (versus addressing real, difficult causes like mental health, social media, lack of parenting, lack of morals, etc.) is that we know they won't work, and as soon as everyone agrees that 30 round magazines are too big and only 20 rounds are allowed, some nutjob will shoot up a bunch of people with a 20 round magazine. Then you will cry out that the solution is to ban 20 round magazines, and we will be down to 10 rounders. Lather rinse and repeat. Eventually, we will have a rediculous web of dumb laws that do nothing to prevent any violence whatsoever. Please see Exhibit A: California.