Slightly different response when I asked "What are the highest rated maduro cigars?"
Cigar ratings can vary depending on personal preference and the rating source, but here are some of the highest-rated maduro cigars according to various cigar publications and websites:
Padron 1926 Serie Maduro - rated 97 by Cigar Aficionado and consistently ranked as one of the best cigars in the world, this cigar is made with Nicaraguan tobacco and has a full-bodied flavor profile with notes of chocolate, coffee, and spice.
Arturo Fuente Opus X Maduro - rated 96 by Cigar Aficionado, this cigar is made with Dominican tobacco and has a rich, complex flavor profile with notes of coffee, leather, and dark chocolate.
Ashton Virgin Sun Grown (VSG) Sorcerer Maduro - rated 94 by Cigar Aficionado, this cigar is made with Dominican tobacco and has a full-bodied flavor profile with notes of espresso, dark chocolate, and spice.
La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero Maduro - rated 92 by Cigar Aficionado, this cigar is made with Dominican tobacco and has a bold, full-bodied flavor profile with notes of black pepper, earth, and leather.
Drew Estate Liga Privada No. 9 Maduro - rated 91 by Cigar Aficionado, this cigar is made with Nicaraguan and Honduran tobacco and has a rich, complex flavor profile with notes of coffee, dark chocolate, and spice.
These cigars are all highly-regarded by cigar critics and aficionados and are known for their high-quality and full-bodied flavor profiles.