Was the Puros Indios a maduro that you smoked?? Have all the cigars you have smoked been lighter wrappers?
I think Puros Indios is somewhat underrated, and makes fine cigars. I smoke about 3 maduro Rothchilde's a week, and the consistency takes 2nd place only to cigars like Padron 2000-3000, Torano Reserve Select, and Gurkha Master Select, IMO.
As far as what compares......CAO Black(spicy), Padron 2000 maduro(sweet), CAO Brazilia(smooth).
It's hard to pick out a dead-giveaway comparison, cause Puros Indios has it's own toastiness.....however you can't go wrong with the cigars I have mentioned above, and Remember....No-one can tell you what a good and bad cigar is until you have tried it.
Disclaimer: JMHO
Dave