Recent PostsForum Rules
Next Topic Sign In to ReplyPrev Topic
Hoyo de Monterrey Dark Sumatra
1. Author: KingoftheCoveDate: Thu, 2/7/2019, 11:28AM EST
Looks tasty. The Expresso is a Rothschild, which is one of my favorite vitolas.
I’ve never tried this HdM line.
Any opinions or experiences?
Thx
2. Author: ZRX1200Date: Thu, 2/7/2019, 12:04PM EST
Pretty good, mild +
3. Author: ZRX1200Date: Thu, 2/7/2019, 12:05PM EST
I can pick a couple up locally to send to you if you want to sample before buying
4. Author: KingoftheCoveDate: Thu, 2/7/2019, 12:21PM EST
ZRX1200 wrote:
Pretty good, mild +

Mild+ ??
The other place, as well as other places, list them as Full strength?

No worries on getting me a few Z...........not much into mild cigars.
Think I might pass on these for now...........just continually on the hunt for a good sub $3 cigar.
5. Author: SunoverbeachDate: Thu, 2/7/2019, 1:07PM EST
Hard for me to judge strength since I like to be left senseless and drooling after a smoke, but I recall liking these. It didn't bore me
6. Author: moonmanDate: Thu, 2/7/2019, 4:16PM EST
I have a 5 pack on the way. I'll report back this weekend. Herfing
7. Author: mjrburnDate: Fri, 2/8/2019, 12:54PM EST
Any of you fellas familiar with the Caldwell Blind Man's Bluff habano?...a good buy at $3 per robusto?
8. Author: delta1Date: Fri, 2/8/2019, 10:55PM EST
great cigar for that price. PM me the details, please. I may have to go off buying hiatus...dammit...
9. Author: mjrburnDate: Sat, 2/9/2019, 12:08AM EST
^ pm sent Herfing
10. Author: KingoftheCoveDate: Sat, 2/9/2019, 1:58AM EST
^^. Noob comes in and starts burning holes in people’s wallets...
11. Author: mjrburnDate: Sat, 2/9/2019, 2:25AM EST
It's a sickness, or an addiction... the first thing to do is admit I have a problem, right? Brick wall
12. Author: Pudding MittensDate: Sat, 2/9/2019, 2:42AM EST
mjrburn wrote:
It's a sickness, or an addiction... the first thing to do is admit I have a problem, right? Brick wall

Problem? What problem? Remember, you can stop anytime you like! jester
.
13. Author: mjrburnDate: Sat, 2/9/2019, 7:24PM EST
Pudding Mittens wrote:
Problem? What problem? Remember, you can stop anytime you like! jester
.


Yeah, that's what I keep telling myself. 1 tower humidor, 9 box humidors, 1 coolerdor, 1 foot locker (for aging) and I'm shopping for another cooler now to house the stuff that'll be delivered next week... I'll stop when I get this one full... wait, just found a sale on AF Exquisitos Sun Grown, gotta have a box or two of those!!! Anxious
14. Author: Pudding MittensDate: Sat, 2/9/2019, 8:16PM EST
mjrburn wrote:
Yeah, that's what I keep telling myself. 1 tower humidor, 9 box humidors, 1 coolerdor, 1 foot locker (for aging) and I'm shopping for another cooler now to house the stuff that'll be delivered next week... I'll stop when I get this one full... wait, just found a sale on AF Exquisitos Sun Grown, gotta have a box or two of those!!! Anxious

Yeah, that's how it works. It's never enough, there's always a next amazing deal you can't let slip by.
Herfing
.
15. Author: SunoverbeachDate: Sat, 2/9/2019, 11:00PM EST
C.A.D. (Cigar Aquisition Disorder) is a crushing, debilitating, thoroughly enjoyable disease
16. Author: mjrburnDate: Sat, 2/9/2019, 11:04PM EST
Sunoverbeach wrote:
C.A.D. (Cigar Aquisition Disorder) is a crushing, debilitating, thoroughly enjoyable disease


RollEyes LOL LOL LOL
17. Author: moonmanDate: Fri, 2/15/2019, 8:24PM EST
I torched my first one this afternoon in the sunshine with the temperature in the 50s. It was definitely an enjoyable experience! Herfing Beer
18. Author: SunoverbeachDate: Fri, 2/15/2019, 8:42PM EST
I've got a box incoming. Couldn't resist
19. Author: KingoftheCoveDate: Fri, 2/15/2019, 8:44PM EST
moonman wrote:
I torched my first one this afternoon in the sunshine with the temperature in the 50s. It was definitely an enjoyable experience! Herfing Beer

Awesome!
What vitola?
20. Author: moonmanDate: Fri, 2/15/2019, 9:27PM EST
Toro
21. Author: moonmanDate: Fri, 2/15/2019, 9:31PM EST
Sunoverbeach wrote:
I've got a box incoming. Couldn't resist


What vitola? If you happen to not love them I'd be down to either trade for some or $
22. Author: SunoverbeachDate: Fri, 2/15/2019, 10:30PM EST
The Expresso (Rothschild) that KoC mentioned above. 4.5x50 if I recall correctly. Plenty in the box though. I'd be willing to discuss a trade
23. Author: moonmanDate: Fri, 2/15/2019, 10:48PM EST
Sunoverbeach wrote:
The Expresso (Rothschild) that KoC mentioned above. 4.5x50 if I recall correctly. Plenty in the box though. I'd be willing to discuss a trade


PM sent
24. Author: SunoverbeachDate: Sun, 2/17/2019, 1:54PM EST
KoC, just refreshed my memory on these (espressos) and would place them med-full IMHO. Tasty smoke even ROTT. Good deal for sub $3.
25. Author: engletlDate: Mon, 2/18/2019, 5:51PM EST
Back in the day...maybe a decade or so ago...I had these in regular rotation in my humi.

Nice medium bodied flavorful smoke from what I remember
26. Author: dstiegerDate: Mon, 2/18/2019, 6:22PM EST
engletl wrote:
Back in the day...maybe a decade or so ago...I had these in regular rotation in my humi.

Nice medium bodied flavorful smoke from what I remember

+1
Just checked...back in the day for me was 2008....last time I bought them, though
27. Author: frankj1Date: Mon, 2/18/2019, 7:27PM EST
+2
don't even remember my last one.
28. Author: KingoftheCoveDate: Mon, 2/18/2019, 7:48PM EST
So why did all you guys stop smoking them?
Blend change?
Palate change?
Price increases?
Or?
29. Author: dstiegerDate: Mon, 2/18/2019, 7:51PM EST
Lots of less boring cigars out there.

30. Author: frankj1Date: Mon, 2/18/2019, 8:45PM EST
yeah, and I was all over the place at the time...plus rfenster was mentoring me in Cuban
31. Author: cacmanDate: Tue, 2/19/2019, 1:49AM EST
Haven't had one in years but used to buy them regularly from my B&M in the city. Good smoke with nice flavor for the price at that time. Not sure how they have changed. in the 8yrs since I've had one. A couple years ago I tried to buy a box from JR. Returned 3 boxes that were littered with mold. Not plume like Customer Service suggested. Haven't bought any since. May have to revisit from a reputable retailer that won't tag me for sales tax at the end of the year.
32. Author: zodyDate: Tue, 2/19/2019, 7:36AM EST
Early on HdM and Punch Rothschild's were a regular smoke, many boxes of them.
HdM Dark Sumatra was good, my tastes just moved on. Pretty one dimensional but not a bad cigar.
33. Author: zodyDate: Tue, 2/19/2019, 7:38AM EST
cacman wrote:
Haven't had one in years but used to buy them regularly from my B&M in the city. Good smoke with nice flavor for the price at that time. Not sure how they have changed. in the 8yrs since I've had one. A couple years ago I tried to buy a box from JR. Returned 3 boxes that were littered with mold. Not plume like Customer Service suggested. Haven't bought any since. May have to revisit from a reputable retailer that won't tag me for sales tax at the end of the year.

Subtle protest?Sarcasm
34. Author: engletlDate: Tue, 2/19/2019, 8:57AM EST
For me it was multiple reasons to be dropped

First and foremost...azzhats around here started bidding them well past the $7 a fiver that they were worth to me back then

Secondly - I pretty much lost any liking for Sumatra tobacco
35. Author: KingoftheCoveDate: Tue, 2/19/2019, 11:40AM EST
Starting to sound like a strong, well constructed one dimensional cigar.
May have to pass for now...
Thx gents...
36. Author: moonmanDate: Tue, 2/19/2019, 11:51AM EST
There's a whole lot of chatter happening here for this cigar that y'all want to pass on. I Love it and will gladly accept if you want to pass Em all to me. I've already made room in my humi for a stash that is being traded to me by that SOB! Herfing
37. Author: pacman357Date: Wed, 2/20/2019, 3:04AM EST
I haven't smoked one of these in a very long time. Mostly because I have tons of brands and sold quite a few of these during the brief time my wife and I owned a cigar & pipe store. However, assuming they are still as good as always, I'd say at least try a fiver. Go for a smaller ring; the wrapper on these cigars is a gem, IMHO, and the narrower ring will give you a bigger dose of it.

Back in the day, I recall a time when these seemed pretty full-bodied to me. However, that was around the time an Oliva El Cobre literally made me sick (a couple years later, I could smoke an EC in the a.m. on an empty stomach, so these would probably rate a solid medium to me today, maybe mild side of medium, going from recollection). Not a tremendously complex or high profile smoke, but I just enjoyed the taste and I could light up something else afterwards and not taste the DS all day. Usually a good deal for the $ on this site last I checked.
38. Author: mjrburnDate: Wed, 3/20/2019, 12:25AM EST
Hey KotC, the mothership has these on closeout, in the espresso size, 40 for $100... slightly cheaper than mb3... if you're still thinking about getting some. I just payed the same per price on cbid for a robusto 5er.
39. Author: SunoverbeachDate: Wed, 3/20/2019, 4:34AM EST
Dammitall! I need some cross site, retroactive price matching
40. Author: Ram27Date: Wed, 3/20/2019, 6:03AM EST
Picked up a box for $109.95+ free shipping. Close enough.



Think

41. Author: mjrburnDate: Wed, 3/20/2019, 10:27AM EST
Ram27 wrote:
Picked up a box for $109.95+ free shipping. Close enough.



Think



A damn good deal w/free shipping!

Sunoverbeach wrote:
Dammitall! I need some cross site, retroactive price matching


All it takes is 3-4 hours a day to keep up with the pricing, well worth it to save $5, right? Brick wall
42. Author: KingoftheCoveDate: Wed, 3/20/2019, 10:41AM EST
Thanks for the heads up...
Currently have a few too many bids out to commit to those this week.
Maybe next month...................they’ll come on sale again here, or there...

Too many cigars........too little time....
43. Author: Ram27Date: Wed, 3/20/2019, 1:29PM EST
Just received and placed in humidor, of course 1 will meet the torch very shortly. Scared

Will report back on. Anxious
44. Author: Ram27Date: Wed, 3/20/2019, 2:40PM EST
Ram27 wrote:
Just received and placed in humidor, of course 1 will meet the torch very shortly. Scared

Will report back on. Anxious





ROTT...... as the General stated above nice medium bodied flavorful smoke. ThumpUp


ram27bat

45. Author: 24132413Date: Thu, 3/21/2019, 1:07AM EST

Generic + average + OK + not bad = $2 per max price!
Sign In to Reply
Next TopicJump to TopPrev Topic