Are these cigars overpriced? You bet. Add in the Ashton VSG, Diamond Crowns, Ashton Cabinet, Opus X, Padron Anniversarios and most Cubans, etc.etc.etc. (Don't forget the designer cigars like, Acid, Natural, some of the Bahiaa, Perdomos, CAOs, etc.)
It's all about supply & demand. Many of the above mentioned cigars are super premiums. They ARE great cigars. There are herfers that have the dollars to spend. The cigar boom brought on escalated prices. That equates high-ticket cigars.
Then you have cigars like JR Ultimates, Consegras, Padron, Punch, Maria Manicini, etc. Age them for some time & you have a great cigar for $1 or $2.