Mr. Wilson,
Thanks for the note and I hope to clarify the confusion. You are correct that our base shipping fee for a 5-pack is $3.95. We ship lightweight items to our customers via Priority-Mail. We have found that Priority-Mail is more reliable (and less damage occurs) than with First Class service. Priority Mail service starts at $3.50 for a 2-lb package. For lightweight packages, it is still more cost effective than UPS. We tack on $0.45 for handling (the box, peanuts, labor, etc.)
However, when a problem occurs and a lightweight package (one 5-pack, one torch lighter, etc.) must be returned back to us, we use First Class postage. We're willing to take a risk on damage or loss ourselves, but we're not willing to take that same risk for packages sent to our customers.
I hope this helps and feel free to email us at [email protected].
- Trish