America's #1 Online Cigar Auction
first, best, biggest!

Last post 11 days ago by MidnightToker( • )( • ). 161 replies replies.
4 Pages<1234>
Gurkha Suggestions
jeebling Offline
#101 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
Jakethesnake86 wrote:
Part of me wonders how that one tastes. Like. Ya know.

My boy, Jake, “a natural born world shaker!”
jeebling Offline
#102 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
maxd518 wrote:
So based on the information everyone has given, I just picked up a few Joya de Nicaragua "red" and Caldwell "The King is Dead" from the auction to start trying a few of what's been suggested. The good news is, I never ended up buying any Gurkha's! hahaha

Also, shout out to Mraia for the Tag, never heard of that before but I'm new in this discussion board so I'll be sure to keep it going when I see an opportunity. Looking forward to see what shows up!

Max, this turned up a lot of great conversation for me. I’ve ordered some Caldwell and a few others myself. Thanks for making this post. I hope I didn’t knock it off track.
JGKAMIN Offline
#103 Posted:
Joined: 05-08-2011
Posts: 1,403
LeeBot wrote:
Man, that is some chit right there. That beats virgin thighs by a mile. Blindfolded! Fiji Water! I swear I thought you were making that up till I looked it up.


Think I'll buy a box and let them age.

LOL! I only looked it up because I was looking yours up. I know they’ve always had ridiculous MSRPs with constant 95% off sales, but your info was much higher than expected so I looked it up. When I did, I found my info which was exponentially more ridiculous. I also didn’t believe it so I looked it up for several sources.Herfing
tonygraz Offline
#104 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2008
Posts: 20,260
KingoftheCove wrote:
Gurkha Centurians???
Oh gawd!!!
Those were friggin terrible 10-15 years ago.
Basically wet grass rolled in a hobo’s New York Times that he wet the bed on….


I knew you had a sensitive palate, but not that sensitive.fog
maxd518 Offline
#105 Posted:
Joined: 09-12-2023
Posts: 33
jeebling wrote:
Max, this turned up a lot of great conversation for me. I’ve ordered some Caldwell and a few others myself. Thanks for making this post. I hope I didn’t knock it off track.


Thanks Jeebling, it's really worked out well with everyone providing input. I feel like we're on the fast track to learning more about cigars and making decisions of what to try and what to avoid!
maxd518 Offline
#106 Posted:
Joined: 09-12-2023
Posts: 33
jeebling wrote:
Max, this turned up a lot of great conversation for me. I’ve ordered some Caldwell and a few others myself. Thanks for making this post. I hope I didn’t knock it off track.


Thanks Jeebling, it's really worked out well with everyone providing input. I feel like we're on the fast track to learning more about cigars and making decisions of what to try and what to avoid!
jeebling Offline
#107 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
💯
😎
Mraia Offline
#108 Posted:
Joined: 04-18-2019
Posts: 426
Great thread. At the very least it got me off my azz to put a little care package for Max. Delivery should be Thursday. Hope you enjoy!
jeebling Offline
#109 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
KingoftheCove wrote:
Padron
Fuente
LFD
Tatuaje
Dunbarton
Liga Privada
Crowned Heads
Southern Draw
Kristoff
Caldwell
Room 101
Others….


Ok…I’ve purchased singles and fivers from this list w/exception of Padron. Southern Draw Manzanita was gifted to me by Cheno. I’ve also had many of the other brands gifted to me recently so, along with my purchases, I’ve got a lot that I think I can experience and get a real grip on what I enjoy.
I’ve tried one Padron. I believe they call it the “thousand series “? Please correct me if I’m wrong. I can’t say I’ve ever smoked a better cigar. It really left an impression on me and after my little experimental season I’m sure I will keep some on hand and explore the other blends they offer.
I’m telling you this King so that you (and many others here) will know that I’m taking your advice seriously and not just spamming messages. And with that, let me thank you, and all of you, for sharing the benefit of your experience.

fog
Mraia Offline
#110 Posted:
Joined: 04-18-2019
Posts: 426
Jeebling, Padrons are the gift that keeps on giving. I have a few here, and always hesitate to smoke them, waiting for the "right occasion". Thats a stupid attitude to take and I have to break myself of that. Im trying to smoke the good stuff along with the everyday stuff on a regular basis. If I could give any advice, it would be to enjoy everything when you can. Yah, you gotta let stuff rest, but when they are ready, light em up.

And the guys here are pros no doubt. Sure you're gonna get a wiseazz here and there, but its all in good fun (usually) and 99% of the folks here wont steer you wrong.
Tiver Offline
#111 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 329
.......

And the guys here are pros no doubt. Sure you're gonna get a wiseazz here and there, but its all in good fun (usually) and [h wrote:
99%[/h] of the folks here wont steer you wrong.


No use in exaggerating Mraia. It's a well established statistic that those who won't steer you wrong is a steady 98.2%. The other 1.8% is a list of hooligans, miscreants and transients who complain about stoopid things like order delays and getting outbid, but have little to contribute regarding the quality smoking experience.
Barbara Offline
#112 Posted:
Joined: 05-12-2008
Posts: 53
It appears to be very popular to dismiss Gurkha en mass without really being aware of the changes to the company within the last couple of years. Granted, in prior years, Gurkha spent more input on box design and marketing than on the quality of the cigars it produced. In fact, Gurkha, as an entity, manufactured no cigars. It purchased job lots from various manufacturers, banded, and boxed them. Since Jim Colucci took over running the company, there is an emphasis on marketing quality cigars. The Gurkha Nicaragua Series is a 100% Aganorsa cigar, manufactured in Nicaragua by the same factory as brands like Aganorsa Leaf, Casa Fernandez, Guardian of the Farm, Warped, Illusione and JFR. If you can still find them both, Gurkha San Miguel and Gurkha Treinta were also manufactured by the highly esteemed Aganorsa factory. The Treinta is a blend of Aganorsa grown Criolla 98 and 99 tobacco for its long filler and an Aganorsa Corojo 98 for its binder. The wrapper is a beautiful Ecuadorian Habano rosado. The San Miguel has a Nicaraguan Aganorsa shade grown corojo wrapper, a double Nicaraguan binder, and all Nicaraguan filler. These are all quality cigars. I'd also suggest that you sample the new Cellar Reserve series. We all have differing taste palates and until you sample a cigar, you can't really know if it's a cigar you'll enjoy.

Keep in mind that in the list of brands provided by KingoftheCove, eight of the list do not manufacture their own cigars. They contract for production and may or may not blend the manufactured product themselves.
Stogie1020 Offline
#113 Posted:
Joined: 12-19-2019
Posts: 5,341
Barbara wrote:
It appears to be very popular to dismiss Gurkha en mass without really being aware of the changes to the company within the last couple of years. Granted, in prior years, Gurkha spent more input on box design and marketing than on the quality of the cigars it produced. In fact, Gurkha, as an entity, manufactured no cigars. It purchased job lots from various manufacturers, banded, and boxed them. Since Jim Colucci took over running the company, there is an emphasis on marketing quality cigars. The Gurkha Nicaragua Series is a 100% Aganorsa cigar, manufactured in Nicaragua by the same factory as brands like Aganorsa Leaf, Casa Fernandez, Guardian of the Farm, Warped, Illusione and JFR. If you can still find them both, Gurkha San Miguel and Gurkha Treinta were also manufactured by the highly esteemed Aganorsa factory. The Treinta is a blend of Aganorsa grown Criolla 98 and 99 tobacco for its long filler and an Aganorsa Corojo 98 for its binder. The wrapper is a beautiful Ecuadorian Habano rosado. The San Miguel has a Nicaraguan Aganorsa shade grown corojo wrapper, a double Nicaraguan binder, and all Nicaraguan filler. These are all quality cigars. I'd also suggest that you sample the new Cellar Reserve series. We all have differing taste palates and until you sample a cigar, you can't really know if it's a cigar you'll enjoy.

Keep in mind that in the list of brands provided by KingoftheCove, eight of the list do not manufacture their own cigars. They contract for production and may or may not blend the manufactured product themselves.

Barbara, how long have you worked for Gurkha?
Mraia Offline
#114 Posted:
Joined: 04-18-2019
Posts: 426
Tiver wrote:
No use in exaggerating Mraia. It's a well established statistic that those who won't steer you wrong is a steady 98.2%. The other 1.8% is a list of hooligans, miscreants and transients who complain about stoopid things like order delays and getting outbid, but have little to contribute regarding the quality smoking experience.

Sarcasm

Yeah, I didnt take the miscreants and transients into account, but the hooligans are, on the whole, Ok. LOL
jeebling Offline
#115 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
maxd518 wrote:
ok everyone, I'm hoping I could get some input from some of you cigar aficionados her in the forum. I've been hearing a few people talk about Gurkha's and I've been looking at some here on the website. I want to try some but I'm always hesitant to try something new without suggestions. I'm a big fan of Rocky Patel and buy a lot of RP Flor de San Andres, The Edge Habano Toro. I also buy a lot of Cohiba Connecticut Robusto, and My Father The Judge. Any suggestions would be appreciated!


Hey Max, I’ve been shown copious amounts of generosity since I started posting as a noob here in the CB forums. To keep that spirit alive I’ve sent you an unofficial RAOK as a welcome aboard. Nothing fancy but a few different wrappers and “strength” profiles and vitolas that you might enjoy exploring. I’ve found that most cigars that I’ve tried so far don’t really stand out but I’ve learned what different wrappers taste like and which vitolas I prefer. Getting a little experience behind my belt before I start spending more for cigars that I’m not interested in. Don’t send anything back to me. Keep that for the next guy who is trying to broaden his experience with cigars. I hope you can find the cigars helpful even if they don’t stand out as something you’d like to purchase in the future.

Your USPS tracking number is: 9505510121174074449917

Beer
Stogie1020 Offline
#116 Posted:
Joined: 12-19-2019
Posts: 5,341
(in before Frank)
"Magic happens here..."
tonygraz Offline
#117 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2008
Posts: 20,260
I smoked the Gurkha Nicaraguan in the last year or so and my notes say "somewhat strong - no flavor". Several cigars touting Aganorsa are just not as good as AJ's blends. Nice to hear that Gurkha is at least trying to make good cigars, but I don't think they have succeeded yet.
Jakethesnake86 Offline
#118 Posted:
Joined: 12-29-2020
Posts: 4,143
^ thanks for the input Tony. I was almost curious
Mikey the Chain Offline
#119 Posted:
Joined: 03-11-2023
Posts: 1
I have had only one Gurkha that I like. It is the San Miguel. It’s a solid med-full, always burns well and has pleasant notes.I have purchased this multiple times. Of course the band has great artwork, but the cigar stands up for itself. Everything else Gurkha I’d pass by.
maxd518 Offline
#120 Posted:
Joined: 09-12-2023
Posts: 33
Shout out to Mraia! I received the box of cigars from him yesterday after being TAGGED and what a surprise it was. He sent an amazing collection most of which I've never tried so looking forward to that! I have to say, Mraia set the bar high with the variety and quantity he sent me, so I'll do my best to keep this TAG alive and find someone else to tag as well!

Thanks again, this is awesome!
Mraia Offline
#121 Posted:
Joined: 04-18-2019
Posts: 426
maxd518 wrote:
Shout out to Mraia! I received the box of cigars from him yesterday after being TAGGED and what a surprise it was. He sent an amazing collection most of which I've never tried so looking forward to that! I have to say, Mraia set the bar high with the variety and quantity he sent me, so I'll do my best to keep this TAG alive and find someone else to tag as well!

Thanks again, this is awesome!


Very much my pleasure! let us know what you liked and didnt like. I have no ego to bruise, and truly am curious.
Enjoy the hell out of them!
jeebling Offline
#122 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
Mraia wrote:
Jeebling, Padrons are the gift that keeps on giving. I have a few here, and always hesitate to smoke them, waiting for the "right occasion". Thats a stupid attitude to take and I have to break myself of that. Im trying to smoke the good stuff along with the everyday stuff on a regular basis. If I could give any advice, it would be to enjoy everything when you can. Yah, you gotta let stuff rest, but when they are ready, light em up.

And the guys here are pros no doubt. Sure you're gonna get a wiseazz here and there, but its all in good fun (usually) and 99% of the folks here wont steer you wrong.

I just ordered a single to add to my deep storage
Herfing
Tiver Offline
#123 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 329
maxd518 wrote:
Shout out to Mraia! I received the box of cigars from him yesterday after being TAGGED and what a surprise it was. He sent an amazing collection most of which I've never tried so looking forward to that! I have to say, Mraia set the bar high with the variety and quantity he sent me, so I'll do my best to keep this TAG alive and find someone else to tag as well!

Thanks again, this is awesome!



Don't be shy about posting up a list once you get a handle on what they all are Max.

We all appreciate smoking vicariously through the lists posted on these threads.

Herfing
danmdevries Offline
#124 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,384
Stinks like noob in here maxd wrong thread

https://www.cigarbid.com...17/TAG-Redux#post4754117
MidnightToker( • )( • ) Offline
#125 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2023
Posts: 831
Gotta love how the Gurka Suggestions thread just keeps going.
maxd518 Offline
#126 Posted:
Joined: 09-12-2023
Posts: 33
danmdevries wrote:
Stinks like noob in here maxd wrong thread

https://www.cigarbid.com...17/TAG-Redux#post4754117

Haha gotcha, learning every day!
Palama Online
#127 Posted:
Joined: 02-05-2013
Posts: 23,697
maxd518 wrote:
Haha gotcha, learning every day!


Post up the contents of your TAG! in the thread referenced by Danm.
Barbara Offline
#128 Posted:
Joined: 05-12-2008
Posts: 53
Stogie1020 wrote:
Barbara, how long have you worked for Gurkha?

I'd enjoy working for Gurkha, but I've been retired since July, 2000, 24 years next July. I've participated on and off at this forum since 2001. I had a prior moniker, but was unable to recall my login, so I adopted my late wife's name and re-registered several years ago. You'll find some of my posts here with my original moniker.
https://www.cigarbid.com...posts/2461/Monte-Canario
jeebling Offline
#129 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
Sincere condolences regarding your late wife. It is touching that you would use her name. To me anyway.

Well, Steve, if I may call you that (?), how did you make out with the 9 coolers? What ever happened to Monte Canario by the way? Back then were you pretty much already a collector with many years of smoking cigars under your belt or were you embarking on a pilgrimage to learn about cigars? How long did it take to amass 9 coolers worth? Do you still smoke cigars? I’m curious about your experience with cigars and I think all of this is ok to discuss in this thread w/o fear of hijacking.

😎
Barbara Offline
#130 Posted:
Joined: 05-12-2008
Posts: 53
jeebling wrote:
Sincere condolences regarding your late wife. It is touching that you would use her name. To me anyway.

Well, Steve, if I may call you that (?), how did you make out with the 9 coolers? What ever happened to Monte Canario by the way? Back then were you pretty much already a collector with many years of smoking cigars under your belt or were you embarking on a pilgrimage to learn about cigars? How long did it take to amass 9 coolers worth? Do you still smoke cigars? I’m curious about your experience with cigars and I think all of this is ok to discuss in this thread w/o fear of hijacking.
My father, born at the turn of the century, was a cigar smoker. He primarily smoked clear habanos; Tampa made cigars of Cuban tobacco. By the time I was 16-years-old, I was swiping cigars from his boxes. Every Friday my father would come home from work with two 25 count boxes of cigars. They'd last one week. He was rarely seen without a cigar. I just assumed that men smoked cigars. The only time in my adult life when I wasn't able to enjoy a good cigar was 1968-1969, when after I graduated university, Uncle Sam "invited" into his army and sent me off to Vietnam for 15 months.
I've been collecting cigars for over 50 years, but I confess that the collection has been almost an obsession. Within the last couple of years, as I saw age 80 creeping up, I came to the realization that I was smoking less and less and still acquiring a lot of cigars. Besides the coolers, I had 24 humidors that needed tending. I found two charities to which I could make major donations of cigars, the one most important to me is Cigars for Warriors. https://cigarsforwarriors.org/
In the last three years, I've sent major donations to C-f-W each year and have instructions in my estate plan for the entire collection to be donated after I die.
I still have several coolers and about a dozen humidors. I find that as age creeps up, I spend more time researching knowledge of tobacco, cigars, and their respective manufacturers. I've been to Cuba, Honduras, Dominican Republic, Nicaragua, Mexico, Philippines and domestically observing and learning about the growth of tobacco, its processing, and manufacture into cigars. As I'm sure every premium cigar smoker is aware, the places to socially smoke a cigar have become few and far between.
And, as the price of Cuban cigars has escalated almost beyond belief, for most of us a habano is a rare treat. Fortunately, the quality of non-Cuban, New World cigars has increased and in many cases surpassed the lure of habanos. I still do enjoy an occasional habano, and have one humidor restricted to Cuban custom rolls.
I was a big fan of Pedro Martin's Tropical Tobacco, from his earliest days, and only within the last couple of years finally parted with his Solo Aromas, Lempira, Maya, Cacique and Casanova cigars. (I kept one unopened box of Maya.) I'm sure most of the cigar veterans here recall Martin's Don Juan and V Centennial branding. With Martin's passing Tropical Tobacco was ultimately sold and became Aganorsa, which now is the focus of most of my purchases.
I admit to going against the grain of many long time collectors and have rarely bought a significant amount of Fuente makes. I've always felt that there is created rarity to increase retails. That is not to say that the Fuentes don't make wonderful cigars, but rather that shrewd marketing has created rarity and escalated price points.
I've rambled on...my apology. I do make it a point to try to know who actually is manufacturing the cigars I purchase. As I stated above, many well known and respected brands are contracted to large manufacturers and are not blended by the brand owners. Some are; some aren't.
I used my late wife's name when I re-registered, simply because I knew I'd never forget it. Thank you for the very kind condolences.

Added later: Monte Canario, to the best of my knowledge, became history. I'm actually surprised that another maker didn't acquire the branding. The last Monte Canario cigars I acquired were obviously made for the U.S. market and tasted devoid of Cuban leaf. I'd guess that they were primarily comprised of native brena Canary Islands tobacco. My understanding is that Hacienda del Cura, another Canary Islands leaf became prevalent in the cigars of the Canary Islands.
jeebling Offline
#131 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
Not rambling at all, every word is interesting to me. Thanks for taking the time. I look forward to reading your posts.
Mraia Offline
#132 Posted:
Joined: 04-18-2019
Posts: 426
I agree with Jeebling Barbara. Very interesting for sure. Don’t be a stranger around here!
Ram27 Offline
#133 Posted:
Joined: 04-30-2005
Posts: 49,025
Agree great post, very interesting.
Thanks
Tiver Offline
#134 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 329
Yes , thank you Steve.

Many people still appreciate sentences and punctuation, along with coherent thoughts. Your observations and experiences are hardly ramblings. They are a welcome addition and this forum would be the better for it with your continued participation.

Mraia Offline
#135 Posted:
Joined: 04-18-2019
Posts: 426
^ this. 1000%
LeeBot Offline
#136 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,005
^ Is that you in that picture Mraia, and are you wearing a rashguard?

And ditto, Barbara. Welcome aboard. Complete sentences and all.
Mraia Offline
#137 Posted:
Joined: 04-18-2019
Posts: 426
LeeBot wrote:
^ Is that you in that picture Mraia, and are you wearing a rashguard?

And ditto, Barbara. Welcome aboard. Complete sentences and all.

That’s me playing drums, in my Sticky Fingers shirt. Not a rash guard lol
tonygraz Offline
#138 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2008
Posts: 20,260
Did a little research today and noticed that Sean Williams has joined up with Cohiba and is still active in cigars and spotted some of his old El Primer Mundo creations on line.

Back to Gurkha and their expensive Black Dragon churchill box (20) going for $ 1,133.on line. Around 10 years or so ago I bought out the last run (plus several unfilled B.O.s) of the Black Dragon Nublizers that CBID had. Great smoke if you don't mind a lack of dimensions. Still have a few that I smoke on special occasions
maxd518 Offline
#139 Posted:
Joined: 09-12-2023
Posts: 33
Ok, I’m back to add a little to this discussion. Based on all the input and the list provided here I thought I’d share what I think I’ve experienced. I tried a Tatuaje Caballero, and Crowned Heads Serie E… loved them both, especially the Tatuaje which was really smooth and really good flavor. The bad… I tried a Caldwell The King is Dead… well he must be dead because that cigar was terrible. No flavor, about the only good thing I can say about that was it burned evenly. Extremely disappointed in the Caldwell, but since they’re on the GOOD list in this thread, is there. A specific Caldwell that is considered good?
Sunoverbeach Offline
#140 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2017
Posts: 14,668
I only read your first post and last.

I suggest you steer clear of Gurkhas. That may have been stated once or twice here already.

Caldwell's a little hit and miss for me, but the Blind Man's Bluff are purty good
jeebling Offline
#141 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
Max, I just had an Eastern Standard and it was my first Caldwell. I was disappointed in the cigar but I’m glad I’ve got the other blends to try out. I’m all about trying it for myself and making my own determination, like you. I have a couple more Eastern Standards and I will smoke them to see if they are all crap or hit-and-miss. My philosophy is smoke’em if you got’ ‘em and don’t buy again if I don’t like’em.
maxd518 Offline
#142 Posted:
Joined: 09-12-2023
Posts: 33
jeebling wrote:
Max, I just had an Eastern Standard and it was my first Caldwell. I was disappointed in the cigar but I’m glad I’ve got the other blends to try out. I’m all about trying it for myself and making my own determination, like you. I have a couple more Eastern Standards and I will smoke them to see if they are all crap or hit-and-miss. My philosophy is smoke’em if you got’ ‘em and don’t buy again if I don’t like’em.

Yeah, I bought a 5'er of The King is Dead so I'll definitely try the rest to see if they're all the same. I also bought 2 Blind Mans Bluff so I'll give them a shot as well. The bottom line is, like you, I'm trying a lot of different things now, thanks to this thread and all the suggestions from all of you. I did try a Crowned Heads and Tatuaje that were recommended in this thread and thought they were great. I've been taking a lot of notes and writing down everything so I can go back and buy the ones I like! haha
maxd518 Offline
#143 Posted:
Joined: 09-12-2023
Posts: 33
Sunoverbeach wrote:
I only read your first post and last.

I suggest you steer clear of Gurkhas. That may have been stated once or twice here already.

Caldwell's a little hit and miss for me, but the Blind Man's Bluff are purty good

Thanks for the input, I haven't tried any Gurkha's since this thread... if one thing is for sure, there was no question about good or bad from everyone here! hahaha
Mraia Offline
#144 Posted:
Joined: 04-18-2019
Posts: 426
maxd518 wrote:
Ok, I’m back to add a little to this discussion. Based on all the input and the list provided here I thought I’d share what I think I’ve experienced. I tried a Tatuaje Caballero, and Crowned Heads Serie E… loved them both, especially the Tatuaje which was really smooth and really good flavor. The bad… I tried a Caldwell The King is Dead… well he must be dead because that cigar was terrible. No flavor, about the only good thing I can say about that was it burned evenly. Extremely disappointed in the Caldwell, but since they’re on the GOOD list in this thread, is there. A specific Caldwell that is considered good?


I just had a Caldwell The King is Dead The Last Payday (dont know where or how they get these dumb names). It was fantastic. The construction, the burn, everything about this cigar was flawless. Now I am NOT a Caldwell fan. I got a sampler or two, and some I liked a bit better than others, but on the whole Meh.
This one though, was a Cigar of the Month selection and I will definitely order more. Its about $15 and worth every dime. FOR ME. I also felt the Freud Agape was dynamite. $30 a stick though....

Palama Online
#145 Posted:
Joined: 02-05-2013
Posts: 23,697
Mraia wrote:
I just had a Caldwell The King is Dead The Last Payday (dont know where or how they get these dumb names). It was fantastic. The construction, the burn, everything about this cigar was flawless. Now I am NOT a Caldwell fan. I got a sampler or two, and some I liked a bit better than others, but on the whole Meh.
This one though, was a Cigar of the Month selection and I will definitely order more. Its about $15 and worth every dime. FOR ME. I also felt the Freud Agape was dynamite. $30 a stick though....



You and Lee oughta start a Dumb Name club or sumting li’ dat. Beer
HighSierraSmookin' Offline
#146 Posted:
Joined: 02-13-2024
Posts: 110
maxd518 wrote:
Ok, I’m back to add a little to this discussion. Based on all the input and the list provided here I thought I’d share what I think I’ve experienced. I tried a Tatuaje Caballero, and Crowned Heads Serie E… loved them both, especially the Tatuaje which was really smooth and really good flavor. The bad… I tried a Caldwell The King is Dead… well he must be dead because that cigar was terrible. No flavor, about the only good thing I can say about that was it burned evenly. Extremely disappointed in the Caldwell, but since they’re on the GOOD list in this thread, is there. A specific Caldwell that is considered good?

The Midnight Express is a gem imho.

Oh...and adding to that small list of "G" smokes we talked about, give the Platinum 12 year a go.
jeebling Offline
#147 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
This may interest some of us. I take it with a grain of salt.

https://youtu.be/6FhaMjsjQHw?si=clEBxKCSm0M1Mt9_
JGKAMIN Offline
#148 Posted:
Joined: 05-08-2011
Posts: 1,403
jeebling wrote:
This may interest some of us. I take it with a grain of salt.

https://youtu.be/6FhaMjsjQHw?si=clEBxKCSm0M1Mt9_

That’s a very fair take on their brand, all about marketing and packaging which puts them on the map. Unfortunately for them, their first cigars have never been considered premium, ultra premium or exclusive by anybody other than Kaizad. They roll out crap in a fancy package and it’s still crap, while brands like Padron wow you with quality product and ho hum packaging. At the end of the day you’re smoking a cigar, not the exquisite box or ring or faux MSRP.
jeebling Offline
#149 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,134
That’s it in a nutshell. As an aside comment though, that classic Padron cedar box with a clean black stencil makes my heart go pitter-pat. I love that clean no nonsense style.
HighSierraSmookin' Offline
#150 Posted:
Joined: 02-13-2024
Posts: 110
I'll never understand the big stems I get in Padron 64's and 26's. Everyone one I've had was like that.
Anybody else have this experience, and why do they do this. There must be a reason.
Users browsing this topic
Guest
4 Pages<1234>