Sam ...
For a surprisinly decent utilitarian cigar ashtray, let me recommend Big Lots to your attention ...
for a buck apiece, I got several cigar ashtrays that are quite functional ... not exotic or exquisite, mind you, but utilitarian function ... however, I found a very nice single cigar ashtray there for less than $5 incl tax ... no foolin' ... this is a heavy, crystal appearing ashtray about 3.5 inches at the wide end, tapering to about 2.5 at the narrow end with a well for the ashes in the wide end and a long cigar rest slot that runs from the well and opens out through the narrow end ... if I see another, I'll pick it up for you ... but you must have one of these stores up your way ... check it out.