Recent PostsForum Rules
Next Topic Sign In to ReplyPrev Topic
Butifarra Review
1. Author: cacmanDate: Mon, 1/14/2013, 6:12PM EST
I'm not very good at reviews or distinguishing flavors to the detail others can, but I'll offer the following in the best spirit.

Johnny-O! Flying Pig aka Butifarra (5 X 55) - dark colorado
Fresh and ROTT so it felt a little soft, but solid construction. Nipped the cap with my Palio.
The initial light offered hints of soft cedar. There is a subtle sweetness. Over the bulb opened spices of white pepper. Also caught hints of a slight nutty spice.
Ash held well for the first third, breaking shortly after the photo taken.
Shortly after the ash broke it did require a touch-up.
The soft cedar further develops/strengthen and nutty spice continues, but also offers a creaminess.
Due to the freshness and developing a nice tar, reaching the final 3rd it becomes a little more difficult to keep lit. Still offers a creaminess, but the semi-sweet nutty spice continues. Cedar develops and becomes more complex.
Medium bodied but medium-full flavored for sure. Flavor has more nuance and is not an in-your-face blast. Never became bitter but I do smoke slower than most. Good hour and a half to finish.

The risk was worth the reward. Found the cigar very enjoyable. With age can anticipate the flavors to further develop and become more complex without gaining any strength. Will definitely dry-box for a min of 6-8hrs next time.
Herfing

ButifarraSlides.jpg
2. Author: JennaR@cigarbidDate: Tue, 1/15/2013, 9:12AM EST
Wow sounds good!ThumpUp
3. Author: leftypostholeDate: Tue, 1/15/2013, 10:41AM EST
Thanks bro
4. Author: edin508Date: Wed, 3/20/2013, 9:21PM EST
Thanks
5. Author: carpenter69Date: Wed, 3/20/2013, 9:39PM EST
Johnny O rocks!
6. Author: cacmanDate: Wed, 3/20/2013, 11:18PM EST
A couple brothers since have compared it to a WOAM, but I never got that flavor profile. To me it was completely different. The Butifarra's from what I could find through Google looked similar to the H. Upmann, and the flavor profile to me was more similar to a richer HU than a WOAM. Another BOTL suggested notes from a Punch DC. But I'd agree with medium-bodied offering hints of toasted macadamia nut and cream.

These where from the Economically Advantage line. Would be interested in the comparison to the Factory line offered now.
7. Author: cacmanDate: Sun, 1/4/2015, 3:17AM EST
Have seen some interest in the Johhny-O's recently.
Still have a few of these resting.
8. Author: cacmanDate: Tue, 11/17/2015, 11:16AM EST
Bumped for Noisy Tutor
9. Author: recklessDate: Wed, 11/18/2015, 8:07AM EST
Carl the first pic was just taken backwards correct?
10. Author: NoisyTutorDate: Wed, 11/18/2015, 11:44AM EST
well this spurred me to get some! I think john has some of these coming in soon.
11. Author: cacmanDate: Wed, 11/22/2017, 9:53AM EST
Only have 1 left.
12. Author: Ewok126Date: Wed, 11/22/2017, 10:16AM EST
Enjoy it Cac!
Sign In to Reply
Next TopicJump to TopPrev Topic