| 1. Author: Cycleman | Date: Fri, 7/31/2020, 8:17PM EST | |
1- RyJ Short Churchill 2- Liga Provada #9 3- Padron ANYTHING 4- Coh Siglo 4 5- Perdomo Habano Robusto Corojo |
| 2. Author: Cycleman | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 7:56AM EST | |
No one loves me..... |
| 3. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 8:42AM EST | |
It's not you. We're just afraid of commitment |
| 4. Author: ZRX1200 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 12:16PM EST | |
*insert sympathy post* |
| 5. Author: ZRX1200 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 12:22PM EST | |
1~ H Upmann Mag 46
2~ Bolivar PC
3 ~ Monte #2
4~ Fuente Mag44
5~ Fuente Hemingway Classic sungrown |
| 6. Author: opelmanta1900 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 12:36PM EST | |
You guys have terrible taste in cigars...
1-4. CAO Brazilian
5. Papa Fritas |
| 7. Author: CarsonTheCat | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 2:03PM EST | |
1 - Arturo Fuente Añejo Reserva Xtra Viejo (size doesn't matter)
2 - Padron 1926 No. 35 Maduro
3 - My Father Le Bijou 1922 Toro
4 - Drew Estate Undercrown Sungrown Toro
5 - CC Partagas Short |
| 8. Author: ZRX1200 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 2:05PM EST | |
^ 888 and 46 are the best. |
| 9. Author: CarsonTheCat | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 2:29PM EST | |
ZRX1200 wrote:^ 888 and 46 are the best. You are correct...I've had the 46 and the 60, but not the 8-8-8....Wish they weren't so darned hard to find! |
| 10. Author: Maldeev2003 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 3:25PM EST | |
Still buying samplers and trying everything out!
Burned a Brickhouse Connecticut last night, wasn't too thrilled, good draw but wrapped started flaking after the cut. Guess i can expect that though with he price point.
I also ordered a Leaf sampler by Oscar, cool presentation and the two I've had were good.
I'm gonna keep an eye on this post and learn from the oldheads!! Keep the recommendations coming! |
| 11. Author: CelticBomber | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 3:37PM EST | |
In no particular order
San Christobal El Principe
La Aroma de Cuba Noblesse
Partagas Short (every day smoke)
Siglo 4
My Father Le Bijou |
| 12. Author: Palama | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 5:56PM EST | |
Hmm, Top 5...  Always a tough question for me as it depends on how you define “Top”. Nonetheless, my Top 5 is based upon what I want to grab to smoke when I go spur-of-the-moment humi-diving. but here goes: A. Fuente 8-5-8 Maduro or Sungrown - depends on what day of the week and/or box I pull from A. Fuente Anejo #46 A. Fuente Casa Cuba Divine Inspiration A. Fuente Mag R44 Tatuaje Petit Cazadores Reserva |
| 13. Author: frankj1 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 6:55PM EST | |
Maldeev2003 wrote:Still buying samplers and trying everything out!
Burned a Brickhouse Connecticut last night, wasn't too thrilled, good draw but wrapped started flaking after the cut. Guess i can expect that though with he price point.
I also ordered a Leaf sampler by Oscar, cool presentation and the two I've had were good.
I'm gonna keep an eye on this post and learn from the oldheads!! Keep the recommendations coming! several listed here are Cubans with the same name as legal smokes. ask for clarification before bidding. |
| 14. Author: delta1 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 7:16PM EST | |
^ public service announcement...
pay attention noobs |
| 15. Author: Whistlebritches | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 7:38PM EST | |
Mine could change day to day but these would make the top 10 anyday.Top 5 today
Fuente Hemingway Signature Sungrown
Ashton VSG Illusion
My Father Cedros Deluxe Cervantes
Tatuaje Miami Especiales
Fuente Magnum R 44 |
| 16. Author: Maldeev2003 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 7:56PM EST | |
Thanks for the clarification, had no idea. I feel like most people here have quite a bit of experience/stashed gold. Hard coming into the scene with just store bought stuff.
Learning more every day though. |
| 17. Author: opelmanta1900 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 8:08PM EST | |
I'm with Ron... it changes a lot...
power ranger is probably at the top...
I'd forgotten about anejo's... those are probably on there...
I saw a lancero at the vherf this last weekend that will probably make my list if my local has one and let's me buy it....
Honey and hand grenades might be in there but it's been a long time...
MF Promesa lancero would earn an honorable mention...
I'm sure there are others... |
| 18. Author: ZRX1200 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 9:14PM EST | |
What lancero Joel? |
| 19. Author: clickbangdead | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 9:59PM EST | |
Like others, mine change over time, but right now I'd go:
Trinidad Fundadore
H. Upmann Conn no. 1
Illusione HL candela
Partagas Presidente
Poor Larranaga Monte Carlo
|
| 20. Author: opelmanta1900 | Date: Wed, 8/19/2020, 10:11PM EST | |
ZRX1200 wrote:What lancero Joel? Opus x Phantom I think? |
| 21. Author: Abrignac | Date: Thu, 8/20/2020, 12:43AM EST | |
Opus X power ranger
Fuente classics and anjeo m
Punch punch
Partagas
Bolivar
Monte Crisco
Took me 15 minutes to post this picture damn voice **** |
| 22. Author: Palama | Date: Thu, 8/20/2020, 1:39AM EST | |
opelmanta1900 wrote:Opus x Phantom I think? Are you thinking of the lancero that Zody was smoking? Iirc, it had a black footband. |
| 23. Author: ZRX1200 | Date: Thu, 8/20/2020, 1:55AM EST | |
Ah Mr Fancypants!
Opus X Power Ranger is good too Anth.... |
| 24. Author: engletl | Date: Sun, 8/23/2020, 12:59PM EST | |
In no particular order
Anejo.
Undercrown.
Oliva Saison maduro.
Rosa Dr Guadalupe.
Diesel uncut. |
| 25. Author: cacman | Date: Sun, 8/23/2020, 5:51PM EST | |
In no particular order
Tatuaje 7th Reserva
Tatuaje Cohete
A Fuente WOAM
A Fuente Añejo 46
Montecristo No2 or Petit Edmundo |
| 26. Author: KingoftheCove | Date: Sun, 8/23/2020, 9:24PM EST | |
Changes constantly......currently little time to smoke.....but this is what I’ve been grabbing lately...
Camacho Corojo (circa 2006) from the MB3 place box close out a few years back
Sobremesa....various vitolas
PAM 64 Monarca
Jaime Garcia Robs (well rested ones)
Oliva Melanio Robs |
| 27. Author: danmdevries | Date: Mon, 8/24/2020, 2:48AM EST | |
by sheer volume, I think my favorite is the HUHC. I smoke about two boxes a year of those.
Party Shorts are a close second, about a box a year.
Beyond those there really isn't any cigar ive bought multiple boxes of.
I don't have the attention span to really enjoy a cigar beyond 30 minutes. Hell, there was a HUHC in my ashtray that I set down 5 minutes after lighting last week and wandered off to spray roundup on the driveway cracks. |
| 28. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Mon, 8/24/2020, 6:11AM EST | |
I think you need to rearrange your priorities a bit danm. |
| 29. Author: DrMaddVibe | Date: Mon, 8/24/2020, 6:49AM EST | |
Vegas Robaina - Famosos
Padron - '64 Anniversary (prefer the Maduro but will grab a Natural for a change of pace)
Flor de Ybor City No. 80
Montecristo - Nicaraguan
Intensa Toro
Those are in the rotation right now for me. |
| 30. Author: Cycleman | Date: Tue, 8/25/2020, 5:39AM EST | |
That's some great smokes you all have going!!!!!!!! yum
|
| 31. Author: hnixon12 | Date: Thu, 8/27/2020, 2:35PM EST | |
Bolivar RC or BF
HDM EE
Monte PE
RJ Short Churchill
HDM Epicure Deluxe
Padilla 1932 Pepin Rolled isnt on here cuz you cant get them anymore :(:( |
| 32. Author: richokeeffe | Date: Thu, 10/1/2020, 11:43AM EST | |
Since I smoke so many, I will have to have a couple of different answers for you. All will be in no preferential order.
Everyday smokes
Oliva V #4
Oliva MB3
Perdomo 20th anniversary
Aging Room F55 Quatro
AJ Fernandez New World Cameroon
Special once in a while smokes(too pricy for everyday consumption)
Padron 75th
Ashton ESG
Partagas Serie D #4
Norteno
Sin Compromiso
Newer sticks that are incredible smokes and potential to crack the lists. Some of them have technically been out a year or two but they have just arrived in my local
Julius Cesar Corona (new smoke. Think they have released a maduro line. had one yesterday - it's amazing)
OchoCinco
NBK
Mi Querida Triqui Traca
|
| 33. Author: clintCigar | Date: Thu, 10/1/2020, 12:00PM EST | |
Sunoverbeach wrote:It's not you. We're just afraid of commitment This. I'm on like a 50+ cigar rotation and still trying new ones. Here is a list I made back in Dec 2019 from my I smoke a schitton topic: http://www.cigarbid.com/...9/so-is-it-good-or-bad- Stolen Throne Crook Of The Crown Esteban Carreras Mr Brownstone Maduro A. Flores AFR-75 San Andreas Maduro LFD Double Ligero Maduro Obsidian Camacho Triple Maduro Kristoff Pistoff Kristoff Ezra Zion All My Ex's Maduro Warped Don Reynaldo Leaf By James JdN Antano 1970 JdN Antano Dark Corojo Jas Sum Kral Tyrannical Buc Maduro & Habano Viaje TNT Viaje C4 BLTC Bishops Blend BLTC Morphine Foundation Highclere Castle Victorian Foundation Menelik Dunbarton Muestra de Saka Exclusivo Davidoff Special R Saint Luis Rey Serie G Maduro Punch Bareknuckle Diamond Crown Maximus DE Undercrown Maduro DE Liga Privada T52 DE Liga Privada Unico Serie UF-13 La Gloria Cubana Serie R Maduro Nub Dub |
| 34. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Thu, 10/1/2020, 5:54PM EST | |
See? Afraid of commitment |
| 35. Author: MoreBeer | Date: Fri, 10/2/2020, 12:45PM EST | |
Top 5? Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
Liga #9 toro
Fuente Anejo - pretty much any style, they're all good
Padron 1926 maduro churchill
Kristoff ligero maduro
San Cristobal churchill
* I could probably add Liga 52's in there as well. They have been a little hit and miss however. DE makes some nice stuff. I remember buying the #9's and T52's when they first came out at $175 a box.
Picking a top 5 is tough, as I like many low cost sticks as well. Aside from standout premiums such as Liga #9's and Fuente Anejo's, there's a multitude of cigars which can be had under $5 that are right up there with $10 - $15 sticks.
|
| 36. Author: SV84 | Date: Sat, 10/3/2020, 12:06PM EST | |
I only smoke all the #1 Cigars of the Years listed from CA. I can’t waste my smoking time on anything less and unworthy. |
| 37. Author: ZRX1200 | Date: Sat, 10/3/2020, 12:21PM EST | |
Michael.....
BTW I think RyJ Short Churchill’s are airballs.
But you like commie waffles so I’m not surprised. |
| 38. Author: KingoftheCove | Date: Sat, 10/3/2020, 8:25PM EST | |
CAO Brazilia.............I smoke nothing else... |
| 39. Author: hnixon12 | Date: Mon, 10/5/2020, 4:42PM EST | |
ZRX1200 wrote:Michael.....
BTW I think RyJ Short Churchill’s are airballs.
But you like commie waffles so I’m not surprised. easy Jamie on the SHort Churchills....they tast better Rottt! no aging needed lol |
| 40. Author: ZRX1200 | Date: Mon, 10/5/2020, 6:16PM EST | |
Man I even had the Pepin rolled with block lettering and they sucked too. |
| 41. Author: hnixon12 | Date: Sat, 10/10/2020, 11:49AM EST | |
LOL Jamie....I am proud, havent heard a Pepin joke from you in a while....whoop |
| 42. Author: Mr. Jones | Date: Sun, 10/11/2020, 9:51AM EST | |
Way too late...
Pity post |
| 43. Author: frankj1 | Date: Sun, 10/11/2020, 6:39PM EST | |
Mr. Jones wrote:Way too late...
Pity post it's very liberating, is it not? |
| 44. Author: Buckwheat | Date: Mon, 11/9/2020, 11:29AM EST | |
#1 - Partagas Serie du Connaisseur No.2 from the '70's #2 - RyJ Petit Corona from the '70's Dress Box in Cello #3 - RyJ Short Churchills Tubos Original Release #4 - Cohiba Siglo VI Tubos from 2008 #5 - Trinidad Reyes tied with Partagas Shorts & RASS - Any years will do. Sadly, I don't have the collection that I once had where I could go down and smoke any of these as the mood struck me. No regrets.    |
| 45. Author: ZRX1200 | Date: Mon, 11/9/2020, 12:23PM EST | |
Reyes is an underrated cigar. |
| 46. Author: delta1 | Date: Mon, 11/9/2020, 4:54PM EST | |
that is an impressive list Buckwheat! |
| 47. Author: MACS | Date: Mon, 11/23/2020, 2:22PM EST | |
You shared quite a few memorable smokes with me, Julian. Still #1 on my list of all time best cigars I ever smoked... 1987 Dunhill Cabinetta. Never would have smoked a cigar like that if it wasn't for you sending me one. I'm sure Andy and Mike also thank you... we passed that around like a doobie.  |
| 48. Author: Mr. Jones | Date: Sun, 11/29/2020, 6:48PM EST | |
CycLeman sets heavy... 🤪🤪🤪🙄🙄🙄🤐🤐🤐🤫🤫🤫 |
| 49. Author: 05busa | Date: Mon, 5/10/2021, 3:03PM EST | |
Acid kuba kuba ;) |
| 50. Author: delta1 | Date: Mon, 5/10/2021, 6:10PM EST | |
he said top 5...
bass turd |
