Recent PostsForum Rules
Next Topic Sign In to ReplyPrev Topic
How soon can you light up?
1. Author: MaydayGDate: Sat, 7/2/2022, 4:33PM EST
Hello new to buying from the site- I received my winning bids today and wonder how long I should keep in my humidor before smoking?

Thanks
2. Author: Ram27Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 4:38PM EST
I myself don't wait, puff ROTT.
3. Author: corey sellersDate: Sat, 7/2/2022, 4:38PM EST
Some smoke rott right off the truck some don't. I generally smoke one then put them to rest.
4. Author: delta1Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 4:41PM EST
usually wait a minimum of two weeks, but for some cigars that I'm anxious and curious about, I do what corey do...

Cigars sold by online vendors are typically stored at 70F and 70RH, the industry's "standard"...for most of us that's too wet and results in some burn issues and some harsh flavors...so we let them rest a bit to dry out some...a few guys will put a cigar into a "dry box" for a day or two to speed up the drying process...
5. Author: corey sellersDate: Sat, 7/2/2022, 4:50PM EST
What he said ^^^^^
6. Author: MaydayGDate: Sat, 7/2/2022, 6:51PM EST
Ok - i was thinking they would be too dry and needed hydration..
7. Author: Jakethesnake86Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 6:52PM EST
Personally I’ll take a dry cigar over a wet one. Within reason
8. Author: ZRX1200Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 7:05PM EST
I dunno, I might start smoking my Tatuaje TAA 2011 now
9. Author: Jakethesnake86Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 7:18PM EST
You should probably rest that a little while z
10. Author: SunoverbeachDate: Sat, 7/2/2022, 9:45PM EST
If they were new ones to me, I used to light one up right away. Usually turned out ok but the couple weeks plan is a good one.
11. Author: frankj1Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 10:46PM EST
several give them a freezer treatment when received...
12. Author: Stogie1020Date: Sun, 7/3/2022, 12:02AM EST
I try to wait a full month. Try.
13. Author: PalamaDate: Sun, 7/3/2022, 3:27AM EST
Stogie1020 wrote:
I try to wait a full month. Try.


Ditto.

However, if I read a review from someone I respect (e.g., The Katman…) and he recommends 3 months or more before ashing one up, I’ll wait those extra few weeks. But, that’s just me, ymmv.
14. Author: bassman45Date: Sun, 7/3/2022, 8:50AM EST
ZRX1200 wrote:
I dunno, I might start smoking my Tatuaje TAA 2011 now



🤣🤣
15. Author: KingoftheCoveDate: Sun, 7/3/2022, 8:03PM EST
One week for every day of travel………….minimum.
If they have humidification in the packaging, three days for every day of travel.
16. Author: clickbangdeadDate: Mon, 7/4/2022, 12:09AM EST
This comes up allll the time, most peeps have already stated the obvious above, but 90 days is good yardstick. As has been said, a lot of sticks are shipped way to wet and smoke terrible ROTT. I've got some boxes that took almost 9 months to become smokeable if just tossed in the humidor (all the HVCs I've gotten have been that way, not sure if that is endemic to the line, just an observation over several boxes). I mean, you've bought a few, so feel free to try one ROTT, but if it's kinda harsh, muted, or has difficulty staying lit, leave the rest to nap.
17. Author: danmdevriesDate: Mon, 7/4/2022, 8:12AM EST
I buy enough to last a year or more at a time.

Short go-to smokes that have consistently performed well straight from the shpo I'll smoke right away. The rest sit for months or even years before I smoke em. My last order was a box of PCR, 25 baitfish, box of Herrera Esteli, and a box of MF le bijou. The baitfish I lit one from the box before it even went in the house. The rest will probably wait until I get tired of the baitfish.

If you have a certain humidity level you prefer, it's going to take a few weeks to acclimate. Some truly need rest and not just acclimation. Your taste and the cigars burn performance will tell you.
18. Author: bgzDate: Mon, 7/4/2022, 8:20AM EST
Smoke them right off the truck.

Actually, if you have a softy palate you might want to wait, but if you like strong cigars... right off the truck.

Anyone telling you to wait, that's like old guard "knowledge" that's been spread over and over without any evidence that it's what you should do... keep in mind, most of us don't age cigars, most of us store them (there might be a couple people on here that actually age cigars, but they're rare).

I'll tell you this, if you rather have the oils from the cigar become one with the cellophane instead of the cigar, then you should wait.

If you rather your cigar be several times weaker than it was when you got it... then you should wait.

If you smoke cigars because you like to smoke cigars, then smoke em if you got em.
19. Author: tonygrazDate: Mon, 7/4/2022, 11:50AM EST
For Diesel brand I never smoke ROTT- wait 3 months. Reminds me that I should start smoking some of the older ones.
20. Author: borndead1Date: Mon, 7/4/2022, 8:30PM EST
A lot of cigar makers these days are not fermenting their tobacco long enough. This leads to a nasty chemical/ammonia flavor showing up anywhere from 1" in to halfway through the cigar.

For mild, Connecticut wrap cigars, I usually let them rest nekkid (out of the cellophane) in the cabinet for a few weeks to a few months.

For 'stronger' cigars, I usually let them rest nekkid for at least 6 to 12 months; sometimes longer.

21. Author: borndead1Date: Mon, 7/4/2022, 8:34PM EST
bgz wrote:
Smoke them right off the truck.

Actually, if you have a softy palate you might want to wait, but if you like strong cigars... right off the truck.

Anyone telling you to wait, that's like old guard "knowledge" that's been spread over and over without any evidence that it's what you should do... keep in mind, most of us don't age cigars, most of us store them (there might be a couple people on here that actually age cigars, but they're rare).

I'll tell you this, if you rather have the oils from the cigar become one with the cellophane instead of the cigar, then you should wait.

If you rather your cigar be several times weaker than it was when you got it... then you should wait.

If you smoke cigars because you like to smoke cigars, then smoke em if you got em.



That hasn't been my experience at all. I have CT wrap cigars from 3 or 4 yrs ago that are still excellent, and 5 yr old Cubans that still aren't 'ready.'

Methinks you have the palate of a goat.
22. Author: bgzDate: Mon, 7/4/2022, 8:55PM EST
borndead1 wrote:
That hasn't been my experience at all. I have CT wrap cigars from 3 or 4 yrs ago that are still excellent, and 5 yr old Cubans that still aren't 'ready.'

Methinks you have the palate of a goat.


That might be true, I can drink scorpion pepper sauce straight out of the bottle.

But cts rested more than a few months is a wasted ct.

Cubans with years... tried the experience, not the biggest fan... decided I rather smoke Diesels rott.
23. Author: Stogie1020Date: Tue, 7/5/2022, 12:41PM EST
My exception seems to be the antano 1970. Loved it fresh, but it lost too much zip for my palette after sitting around for a year.
24. Author: tonygrazDate: Tue, 7/5/2022, 3:40PM EST
Ben. I think goat means greatest of all time.
25. Author: bgzDate: Tue, 7/5/2022, 8:57PM EST
Then there's that... Diesels ROTT or you ain't in contention.
26. Author: frankj1Date: Tue, 7/5/2022, 9:28PM EST
MaydayG wrote:
Hello new to buying from the site- I received my winning bids today and wonder how long I should keep in my humidor before smoking?

Thanks

you should keep in your humidor until she says you may come out of your humidor.
As for smoking, also up to her, apparently.

WTF did you do?

Good luck.
27. Author: Jw3000Date: Tue, 7/5/2022, 10:39PM EST
Build an inventory, and never worry about it again. I wouldn’t bother about resting if you want to taste. Or as suggested, check with mom. /joking
28. Author: robmac61Date: Wed, 7/6/2022, 4:01AM EST
I seem to be like most. I smoke one ROTT but the rest sit for at least a few weeks to a couple of months which isn't a problem since I'll be smoking the previous batches. I always save one or two out of each lot to sit for a while longer just to see how much if any it improves with age. I've been doing this for about 25 years now and honestly I can't really tell much difference. A good smoke is a good smoke and if its maintained well in the humidor should continue as such. I've got a pre-embargo 1960 cuban (bought several in a shop in Charleston back in 2009) and while i've smoked most of them I still have one left that I plan on smoking for my retirement day. I figure if it lasted 50 years under maintained conditions, whats a few more years?

IN the end you just need to experiment and see what suits you.
29. Author: BuckyB93Date: Wed, 7/6/2022, 10:03AM EST
Twenty NINE!
Sign In to Reply
Next TopicJump to TopPrev Topic