2251. Author: Stogie1020 | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 4:53PM EST | |
82823 Tat Lomo De Cerdo Tuxtla |
2252. Author: corey sellers | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 4:54PM EST | |
82823 - Isabella awesome smoke from my brother from another mutha . Conan Thank you so much I am going to pick up a box of Robbie’s I think. |
2253. Author: corey sellers | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 4:55PM EST | |
82824 ^^^^^^^ you was supposed to wait for me I had to type more . |
2254. Author: tonygraz | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 5:05PM EST | |
82825 - Nicaraguan Cream robusto 82826 - Unclaimed Maduro robusto grande |
2255. Author: Jakethesnake86 | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 6:01PM EST | |
82827 hvc Black Friday 23 from jgraz thanks j! |
2256. Author: JGRAZ | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 6:43PM EST | |
82828 - Caldwell Long Live the King Mad Mofo Magnum |
2257. Author: danmdevries | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 7:04PM EST | |
82829 Fugazi COTY compare to Aging Room
I don't love it, but it's got no signature Raymond Pages flavor wet hay and solvents. Tastes like a generic mass market cigar, so I spose it actually does compare well to Aging Room.
This sampler has been the worst cigars I've had all year. |
2258. Author: danmdevries | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 7:08PM EST | |
82830 Fugazi COTY compare to Padron 1964.
I smoked an 8th inch of this cigar. It takes the cake for the worst cigar I've smoked this year. Tasted like wet socks worn for two days straight and dipped in solvent.
This entire sampler has been awful. The sampler I bought last fall was actually decent. These all taste super green at best. Downright rotten at worst. Apologies to anyone I've recommended these to, they're definitely not the same as my first go around with them |
2259. Author: MidnightToker( • )( • ) | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 7:18PM EST | |
82831 - AB Magic Toast |
2260. Author: danmdevries | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 7:23PM EST | |
82832 Fugazi COTY compare to EPC la historia.
This is actually a good cigar. No way it's from the fugazi knockoff blender. This is an EPC overrun rebanded. There's depth to the flavors, mineral/earth mostly. There's texture to the smoke, the ash isn't blooming and flaking, it's required nothing of me to stay lit. |
2261. Author: jeebling | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 7:40PM EST | |
82833: AF Curly Head Deluxe Maduro Lonsdale (Panatela?) with thanks to Jake
Excellent after dinner cigar IMO. Started out with a taste of cedar and oak, toast and earth, somewhat savory. About midway the Connie BL kicked in and it had hints of Dr. Pepper and 7Up. Lots of thick smoke and a low key sweetness throughout. Perfect draw for my preference. Thanks, Jake, for the excellent smoke. This one came out of a box of 40 cigars you sent to me, a feat of generousity I have yet to match.
|
2262. Author: cashmoneydave | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 8:34PM EST | |
82834 - AF casa cuba quatro |
2263. Author: MidnightToker( • )( • ) | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 9:10PM EST | |
danmdevries wrote:Fugazi COTY compare to EPC la historia.
This is actually a good cigar. No way it's from the fugazi knockoff blender. This is an EPC overrun rebanded. There's depth to the flavors, mineral/earth mostly. There's texture to the smoke, the ash isn't blooming and flaking, it's required nothing of me to stay lit. I thought that was the best of the sampler as well. I also kinda liked the AF Anejo. The other 4 were no good, 2 I have yet to.smoke. |
2264. Author: danmdevries | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 10:12PM EST | |
82835 Fuente Chateau SG.
Not bad is about all this one earns. Dry, one note, not much going on.
I knew I didn't care for em 10 years ago, but it came in a sampler with some good stuff for cheap. |
2265. Author: Stogie1020 | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 10:48PM EST | |
corey sellers wrote:82824 ^^^^^^^ you was supposed to wait for me I had to type more . Haha, sorry! 82836 Camacho Triple Maduro |
2266. Author: MidnightToker( • )( • ) | Date: Fri, 5/24/2024, 11:51PM EST | |
82837 - DE KFC |
2267. Author: Palama | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 1:57AM EST | |
#82,838 - AF Mag R44
Only a few left from a 2018 box. |
2268. Author: tonygraz | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 11:52AM EST | |
82839 - Macanudo Cafe Hyde Park |
2269. Author: jeebling | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 12:41PM EST | |
82840: RP BP Royale Church Not good. Tar-like moisture build up on head and the ash was blooming. Obviously the RH was too high so that’s my hit. |
2270. Author: MaduroJorge | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 1:36PM EST | |
82841 Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Sun grown
Well made. Slow burn |
2271. Author: JGRAZ | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 1:39PM EST | |
82841 - 2023 Tat PCA. Definitely a highlight of 2024 for me This is not only a first 2023 for me but also a first PCA of any year. Absolutely loved it. Are they all great sticks? I got this one in a Tat blind buy from luxury place and have been sitting on it for a couple of months. This morning I bought a box without even trying it, so glad I did. I would love to try some of the older ones. Guess I’ll post something in the trades section. |
2272. Author: delta1 | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 2:02PM EST | |
82842 -- Ashton Classic 898...at 6.5 x 44, it's a short lancero, perfect size for me...first half was great, then the bitterness started until the last 2 - 3 inches when the harshness and tarry residue popped up...first dud among all the Ashton Classics I've smoked over the years...hope this is an anomaly and not the standard for the rest of the box... |
2273. Author: Huzza3045 | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 2:28PM EST | |
82843 - Foundation The Tabernacle Glad my B&M convinced me to give this a try. Really solid smoke |
2274. Author: JGRAZ | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 2:30PM EST | |
Huzza3045 wrote:82843 - Foundation The Tabernacle Glad my B&M convinced me to give this a try. Really solid smoke Big fan of them all, particularly the David and Goliath perfecto’s |
2275. Author: LeeBot | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 3:16PM EST | |
delta1 wrote:82xxx -- Ashton Classic 898...at 6.5 x 44, it's a short lancero, perfect size for me...first half was great, then the bitterness started until the last 2 - 3 inches when the harshness and tarry residue popped up...first dud among all the Ashton Classics I've smoked over the years...hope this is an anomaly and not the standard for the rest of the box... That's what I think of as a lonsdale. A little fatter and longer than a corona. Kind of a corona with a chubby. |
2276. Author: tonygraz | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 3:40PM EST | |
82844 - Helix Natural robusto |
2277. Author: jeebling | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 4:11PM EST | |
delta1 wrote:82842 -- Ashton Classic 898...at 6.5 x 44, it's a short lancero, perfect size for me...first half was great, then the bitterness started until the last 2 - 3 inches when the harshness and tarry residue popped up...first dud among all the Ashton Classics I've smoked over the years...hope this is an anomaly and not the standard for the rest of the box... What’s the deal w/that tarry residue? Is it because the tobacco just won’t adjust to storage RH? Some tobacco just sucks and slips by the QA? |
2278. Author: jeebling | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 4:15PM EST | |
82845: RP Vintage 1979 with thanks to Jake Fairly yellow cello. The barnyard smelled more like feed lot. Had a raised seam in last third. Punched it and lit it with delicious cream of peppered cedar flavor. Thought this was going to be a winner but it became very bitter at the end of first third. I couldn’t smoke it because the moisture at the shoulder was burning my lips. Had to reluctantly discard. Still, I’m grateful for the smoke, Jake! |
2279. Author: MidnightToker( • )( • ) | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 4:23PM EST | |
*82847 - Oliva Connecticut reserve XXX41 was doubled |
2280. Author: JGRAZ | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 6:13PM EST | |
82848 - Warped Cloud Hopper |
2281. Author: danmdevries | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 6:52PM EST | |
82849 Megilla Gordo. Not Bad for a yard gar while mowing. Bad for Amy other time.
82850 Fugazi Opus from the sampler. Same green rushed chit flavor as the others in the sampler.
82851 Warped Maestro del Tiempo. Smoked from bulk storage that's been sitting way too high to be smoking from, so it wasn't great. I need to learn to stop doing that and just smoke from the desktop. |
2282. Author: danmdevries | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 7:19PM EST | |
82852 Fuente OpusX PerfecXion No. 5
I wanted to end my week of bad cigars with something good. |
2283. Author: Plowboy221 | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 7:26PM EST | |
82853- AF 8-5-8 RSG |
2284. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 7:59PM EST | |
82854 - Privada LCA Year of the Wabbit Thanks to Leebot from a while back. Just started it but excellent smoke so far |
2285. Author: RobertHively | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 8:14PM EST | |
82855- DE Liga Privada H99 Papas Fritas
82856- Dunbarton Todos Las Dias robusto
|
2286. Author: tonygraz | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 9:00PM EST | |
82857 - Magellan Dominicans corona |
2287. Author: PapaWhiskey | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 10:06PM EST | |
JGRAZ wrote:Big fan of them all, particularly the David and Goliath perfecto’s I've been buying boxes of Tabernacle Robusto which I really enjoy but tried a Goliath the other day and even though I'm not a big ring guy really enjoyed it. 82858 - AF 858 MD 82859 - AF Rothschild MD 82860 - Fake Cohiba Behike my cousin got suckered into on vacation in DR. He was so proud I didn't have the heart to tell him it was fake. It was a well-constructed, descent cigar but not a Cohiba Behike. 82861 - AF 858 MD |
2288. Author: cashmoneydave | Date: Sat, 5/25/2024, 10:28PM EST | |
82862 - Buenaventura Dimensiones |
2289. Author: Huzza3045 | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 6:48AM EST | |
PapaWhiskey wrote: 82xxx - Fake Cohiba Behike my cousin got suckered into on vacation in DR. He was so proud I didn't have the heart to tell him it was fake. It was a well-constructed, descent cigar but not a Cohiba Behike.
Got a box of fake davidoffs for 20 bucks in the DR two years ago and they were some of my favorite sticks. I only have one left, and I can’t bring myself to smoke it. |
2290. Author: LeeBot | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 10:22AM EST | |
82863 - Lampert Event Exclusive toro from Jake. Thank you, Jake! He was was a good one. 82864 - DE Undercrown Maduro belicoso, smoked lying in a hammock in the woods. Good times. 82865 - 601 La Bomba Flash Bang. There, I said it. You figure out what it is. |
2291. Author: danmdevries | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 10:46AM EST | |
82866 Luciano Mas Igneus
Started off bland, generic burning tobacco. 10-15 minutes in a nice spice blend that gave up after 10 minutes and fought off a big tunnel with some torch work and purging I got it going again for another 10 minutes of spice with a little sweet nuts on the finish before it fell back into bland generic burning tobacco again.
Could see a void in the filler from the time the burn went awry all the way to when I put it down. I'll try another before passing judgement but for now not bad. |
2292. Author: MidnightToker( • )( • ) | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 11:54AM EST | |
82867 - Perdomo 10th anniversary champagne |
2293. Author: danmdevries | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 1:07PM EST | |
82868 Plasencia white label original.
Assorted spices, some cedar and ginger? Weird. I've bought a handful of Plasencia cigars but haven't gotten around to trying them. This one's decent but I don't see it becoming a regular in my humidor. |
2294. Author: jeebling | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 1:17PM EST | |
82869: Sancho Panza Glorioso (BP Toro) (6.1"x50)
A Connecticut from Sancho P. I normally associate them with their tasty and affordable Maddies. This one was beautiful and well constructed. Burned a little crooked and needed touch up 2x in the middle but beyond pet peeve it presented no problem. The flavor at kickoff was a mix of marshmallow, strong milk tea, nutty. The marshmallow faded in first inch. About mid way the light molasses and mineral taste of CBL entered the mix creating a new well balanced flavor. The CBL never over powered. The thick smoke was creamy and palette coating throughout the smoke. As far as complexity goes, not a lot. What I got was classic Connie with that CBL flavor balanced in at the middle. If you’re looking for an affordable Connie with a bit of body you might give this one a try. |
2295. Author: Huzza3045 | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 2:21PM EST | |
82870 - Warped Chinchalle
I officially understand the hype. While I didn’t pick up on notes of “buttery shortbread”, it was a tasty medium stick. |
2296. Author: tonygraz | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 3:17PM EST | |
82871 - Havana Cream robusto 82872 = Gurkha Dragonlord toro 82873 - Nicaraguan Cream robusto |
2297. Author: MidnightToker( • )( • ) | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 4:06PM EST | |
82874 - Oliva Black Swan First time trying these..not a fan. Tastes like a RP cigar. The Black Swan was made in a collaboration with RP as there is also an RP Black Swan that probably tastes like an Oliva. |
2298. Author: Plowboy221 | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 4:36PM EST | |
82875- Davidoff Millennium |
2299. Author: tonygraz | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 4:47PM EST | |
82876 - Unclaimed Maduro robusto grande |
2300. Author: JGRAZ | Date: Sun, 5/26/2024, 5:32PM EST | |
82877 - LFD 1994 with thanks to Jake. This is a first for me, and I enjoyed it very much. Luckily I was graced with a couple more between Max and Corey hits.
82878 - Rojas Breakfast Tacos Connecticut |