I'm reluctant to make recommendations due to a steadfast refusal to think of myself as old ... of course, in order for me to remain steadfast in that attitude, I must also be steadfast in my refusal to look into a mirror ... LOL
Hey, I gotta ask you ... no matter what I recommend, how do you know if YOU'll like it ??? I must tell you that some of my favorites are the same as a great many of the others here, but I like some that many of the others consider dog rockets ... and some of what others bid some high $$ to win, I'd give away if I had 'em ... my best and most sincere recommendation is that you follow the suggestion to pick up some 5-packs of different cigars ... give 'em a try ... be sure to remember what you like (and what you don't) ... do a few trades ... pick up a single of something that looks good at a local store and give it a shot ... after you've got some idea of what you like (and what you don't), take a look at that brand on
http://www.cigarsinternational.com ... at the bottom of the page, they've got some cigars listed that you might also want to try ... watch for those brands to pop up on the bidding and try a 5-pack of those ...
It's really the only way you're gonna know the real answer to your question ... and that's the very best advise this guy (whether old or not) has to offer ...