Or perhaps A+.
Recently smoked my first Buccanero. It was a Full Sail gifted by Billy.
Nothing can justify the militant style loyalty seen on this board for this brand, but let me tell you this. This cigar was First Class all the way.
If you like 'em full bodied, you have to give this a try.
Not an ounce of harshness, but it could make your toes curl on an empty stomach. I had the forsight to smoke one well into the evening hours with some grand marnier, and I wish I had a dozen more to be certain it wasn't a fluke.
It burned flawlessly.
The smoke was pleasant to those on the deck who were not smoking.
And the flavor was first rate.
So count me in on the "thumbs up" crowd.
Just don't expect me to lash out when someone finds fault with them...
