I've had the Perdomo2 and the Perdomo Reserve Maduro.
The Perdomo2, both Cameroon (red band) and Maduro (yellow band), I really liked, especially the Maduro, which had a very strong cedar taste that I loved.
I had my first Perdomo Reserve Maduro today, but I can't give it a good review yet. I had the No. 4 (same as you're getting) and had several burn problems.
First off, the perfecto foot has a cap on it seperate from the main wrapper, and the outside of it didn't catch fire when I lit up, so I had to relight it two or three times before it caught. Then, half-way down, the burn became very uneven and I eventually tossed.
I'll try some other PR Maddies, but that one just sucked. I've found that there are only two types of perfectos, those that are made well and smoke like a dream, and those that aren't made well and are a b!tch to light up.