America's #1 Online Cigar Auction
first, best, biggest!

Last post 20 years ago by phenix007. 29 replies replies.
no more support for Iraq from France/Germany
phenix007 Offline
#1 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
Where do these two spineless countries get over whining on the Iraq issue....Germany's attitude actually bothers me more because it is unexpected opposition...France on the otherhand has been totally spineless and without convictions other than total appeasement and capitulation since Napoleon....My father once said that going to war without France as an ally is like going duck hunting without your accordian....how true...pour more French wine in the street and go to England or Spain for your next vaction
plabonte Offline
#2 Posted:
Joined: 09-11-2000
Posts: 2,131
Pouring French wine in the street makes as much sense as farting in bed to get back at your wife who has already divorced you and moved out.

They already got their moeny from the sales. Dumping it in the street is only going to dirty your street.
phenix007 Offline
#3 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
it's simply a token gesture and a way for JOE BLOW to make a statement of condemnation not and economic sanction,,,,It's called standing up for your convictions...hurts you as much or more than the target of your condemnation...having principles means nothing until it cost you to stand up for them..
jdrabinski Offline
#4 Posted:
Joined: 08-16-2002
Posts: 794
Two serious questons:

1. Why is political disagreement 'whining'?

2. Those countries are democracies. The VAST majority of their people opposed the war in Iraq. If we require them to do what WE say, instead of responding to the will of THEIR OWN people, then are we not disrespecting democracy?

If we want to spread democracy across the world (not a bad idea, in my view), then we need to respect the democractic sovereignty of other nations.

John

PS: love or hate their foreign policy, the French make the best wine in the world. Send it to me and I'll drink it like the socialist **** I am.
DrMaddVibe Offline
#5 Posted:
Joined: 10-21-2000
Posts: 55,618
I'll stick to Californian and Australian and I can rest assured that what I'm drinking isn't filtered in cow's blood!
plabonte Offline
#6 Posted:
Joined: 09-11-2000
Posts: 2,131
I don't understand how hurting yourself as much or more then the other guy helps. I think a bigger statement would be made if you hurt them without hurting yourself. That shows you don't need them. But everyone is free to express themselves in their own way I guess.

jdrabinski - I think that is the best point I've ever seen on any thread debate on this or any other board. Well done.

DR MV- Lots of nice Shiraz coming out of Australia

GTofMurphy Offline
#7 Posted:
Joined: 05-16-2002
Posts: 341
jdrabinski,

You need to bring more to the party than just political rhetoric. Facts will set you free!


“Why is political disagreement 'whining'? “

You need to a take a step back and understand the facts. These countries did not support the US in this “War on Terrorism” only because of their own special interests:
• Germany, France and Russia didn’t want the US go into to IRAQ because it would screw up their current business deals with that killer Saddam
• By the US going in on it’s with out their approval. This lessened their own international political power. France specially hates being a 3rd rate country
• The US is the only super power both Military and Economic and French, German and Russian governments felt that by holding the US hostage during this their own power and popularity will increase internally because they are perceived as being “strong”. It did occur in France, Germany and Russia.
• We continue to be the most benevolent and generous country in the history of the world and they wanted a mold the spin where they would be able to take some of the credit for a solution.

With terrorism being such an important topic for all countries it’s pretty sad they could not look past their own selfish agendas and come together to defeat this type of blatant terrorism.


” Those countries are democracies. The VAST majority of their people opposed the war in Iraq. If we require them to do what WE say, instead of responding to the will of THEIR OWN people, then are we not disrespecting democracy? “

• I for one don’t want our foreign policy shaped two governments run by Socialists (France and Germany) and one by ex-communist (Russia). I am sure as a liberal that gives you a “hard on” just thinking about that possibility.
• The Europeans have a long history just talking, talking and talking about issues without resolutions. If you don’t tackle the problem it will get worse. (See the history of WWI, WWII, League of Nations, UN etc etc, etc). They succeeded in “talking” Hitler into trying to take over the world.
• A true leader is one who doesn’t take a poll before they decides on the path to take. I true leader thinks seriously about the ramifications and then makes the decision with-out the latest CNN poll. You can not run a country based on poll results because polls are flawed. (Although Clinton tried.)
• What we did in IRAQ was democracy in action ( Establish the leaders powers, Elected leaders, Debate subject, Decide on course, Take action, monitor plan and make changes if necessary)

GT
phenix007 Offline
#8 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
in response to several post above... the whining I'm referring to is not aimed at the desent...but the lack of resolve and the undermining of our efforts via the UN...can you honestly deny that the French are pacificist when it comes to the French ie their Vichey capitulation to the Germans rather than fighting for their freedom as a country and a government...the free french notwithstanding
I don't deny that they are a democraacy as a form of govt...but whenever its principles and freedoms are thereatened they fold and will not sacrifice for those principles and beliefs...they have a 2 generation at least of folding when threateded
The Germans on the otherhand are both a surprise and disappointment to me...I expected much more resolbe than they have shown and have thrown their lot in with the French..so be it..
as to the comments relative to pain suffered by oneself...as I stated to say you stand for something...a principle,freedom,etc...doesn't mean a damn thing until one is will to stand up and suffer the pain and loss for holding those beliefs above even life itself....i.e. patrick Henry..signators to the Declaration of Independence...many of whom lost their lives,family and properties by that declaration...but the principle of freedom was more demanding of them....
to be meaningful and not so much diatribe...one must stand up and be counted knowing it will cost you dearly...ask the Jews about Macina...the Christians about denying their God and theafter the colisieum...one could go one and on(without the French being a footnote)

Also learned to love the Argentine wines from the Mendoza area especially their own Malbec...all are tremendous bargins here in the staates
tailgater Offline
#9 Posted:
Joined: 06-01-2000
Posts: 26,185
Which Argentine wines?

I've never been a big fan of French wines. They're OK, but I like the full body complexity of the California Cabs.
I've also enjoyed many of the Shiraz' from down under. Great bargains.

tailgater Offline
#10 Posted:
Joined: 06-01-2000
Posts: 26,185
John,
You did make some good points, although they were rebutted very intelligently.
However, your statement regarding the US "requiring" them to follow us is indeed flawed.
We did not force anything on these countries. But if they claim to be our allies, then they should have supported us. Not necessarily by joining our forces into Iraq, but certainly by stepping aside and not hindering our efforts in the early stages.
Did any non-Arabic nation think that Sadam's Iraq was a peace-loving country and America was the unjust aggressor?
If that were true, then the UN would have been against our bringing in troops to surround Iraqwhen Sadam was refusing to cooperate with UN weapons inspectors.
They all thought it was OK to flex our muscles, why then did they cry foul when we actually used them?

jdrabinski Offline
#11 Posted:
Joined: 08-16-2002
Posts: 794
Tailgater,

I actually found the responses pretty incoherent and comprised mostly of non-sequiturs. I've actually searched for an intelligent point or two and found none. Just a rehash of how European history has had a lot of wars. Yes, I went to Middle School too...already knew that. Or folks just made their own comment, not really addressing my rather simple questions.

By name-calling France and Germany, instead of understanding a difference of opinion (unresolvable one), we look idiotic and disrespectful of their democratic process. Calling our critics 'whiners' may work on right-wing am radio, but the world is more serious and complex than that kind of bull****.

I wish supporters of GWB were more adult in their response...'more adult'--I can't think of any other way to put it. So much WHINING about allies having different opinions sounds like a bunch of 5th graders who are mad because their friends left the soccer game. Allies are not blind supporters. They are autonomous nations, with whom we share a lot of common interests.

Further, by your logic, WE should have not gone to war in Iraq because our allies said 'no.' Right? I mean, think about it...we showed ourselves to be bad allies by not doing what THEY wanted to do. Or maybe blind loyalty is not the meaning of 'ally.'

We did, after all, come crawling back to the UN like an ex-girlfriend who blew up and stormed out, showing up later sheepish and begging. THAT embarrassed me. What were we thinking?

John
phenix007 Offline
#12 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
tailgater...almost anything from the Mendoza area..seems they are all good...try their own variatal called Malbec..bodagas such as Luagos...montel...Navarro etc.I just now experimenting with the ones available in the US...haven't found a bad one concentrate on the reds but several pinot grigios are very good...the values are outstanding IMHO..
jdrabinski Offline
#13 Posted:
Joined: 08-16-2002
Posts: 794
"Freedom Grigio," please.
jjohnson28 Offline
#14 Posted:
Joined: 09-12-2000
Posts: 7,914
My butt itches!
phenix007 Offline
#15 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
John...unfortunately you've apparently choosen the low road in this discourse of attempting to demaean the opposition rather than addressing the salient points in the position...apparently in middle school you became aware of the facts but not the substance of the history....I am sorry you take my arguments as being shallow but feel yours is somehow on a "higher plane"...when in fact I find yours absolute void of substance or principle but only simplistic and self serving...thankfully you and I will never agree concerning the inherent stength of being true to a faith or principle only the easy unfettered way out of a difficult conflict without sacrifice....where the is no soul the is will
phenix007 Offline
#16 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
John ...freedom grigio????what kind of sh#@ is that
whose being incoherent and simplistic???
jdrabinski Offline
#17 Posted:
Joined: 08-16-2002
Posts: 794
I didn't say your comments were shallow. I said they were non-sequiturs, which means that they didn't address my questions. Fine. Maybe you didn't want to. But I did not call them shallow.

John
jdrabinski Offline
#18 Posted:
Joined: 08-16-2002
Posts: 794
Freedom Grigio was a joke. I thought that was obvious! Just adding some levity...or, as it turns out, not adding levity.
phenix007 Offline
#19 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
friendly intent taken...butwhere's the levity???over my head??
jdrabinski Offline
#20 Posted:
Joined: 08-16-2002
Posts: 794
The levity was the assumption--apparently wrong on my part--that most people thought the 'Freedom Fries' thing was silly. Pinot is a French word, so I was having fun with that.
phenix007 Offline
#21 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
Thanks for the explanation...I didn't catch on...actually that is quite creative and funny and I am not being factious...although I do not agree that MOST people thought freedom fries was silly....I'll bet on a poll that says more appreciated it than didn't...now that was funny and had a very salient point in my eye.
usahog Offline
#22 Posted:
Joined: 12-06-1999
Posts: 22,691
I'll bet Retired and Active Military Members to this Day WE could get enough people to head on over to France for a little Excavating Party and could draw enough funds to support it!!!! We Could Bring Our Own Home!!!!!!

F*CK France... not all their people feel the way their Government Does... another Simple case of Money Talks and BS Walks... Allies My A$$ Only when its Monitarly in their Interest... Plabonte no way am I directing this at you or many others of the Origin it is at the Goevernment of France...

Hog
rayder1 Offline
#23 Posted:
Joined: 06-02-2002
Posts: 2,226
My wife and I are members of a monthly wine club. We kept getting domestic wines in shipments that chould have had an international selection.

They sent out an apology letter to their membership, explaining the selections they had to substitute with domestic wines were shipments from France.

In the current political climate, they decided to suspend selections from France indefinitely.

Frankly (no pun intended) I make every attempt to avoid having as much a one penny be spent on a French product or company.
phenix007 Offline
#24 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
Good for you rader.....thank goodness Nic.and Honduras are not opposing us in the UN...we might have to sacrifice something priceless and start smoking dutch masters or something
plabonte Offline
#25 Posted:
Joined: 09-11-2000
Posts: 2,131
No offense taken USAhog.

"Freedom" fries is one thing I just don't get. You remove the word French from a common term yet a lot of the words you use on a daily basis are derived from the French language. And this changing of one word is supposed to somehow make a bold statement? The most ironic thing is that French fries aren't even French.

I'm in a wine of the month club as well. We still get French wine (among others) and I still drink it. I'm with jdrabinski on this one. If you don't like the wine send it to me. One of my favorite reds is the Beaujolais.
jdrabinski Offline
#26 Posted:
Joined: 08-16-2002
Posts: 794
Plabonte,

I love it when the Beaujolais Nouveau comes out in early winter. I always get pissed that it sells out. Could this be the year I get all I want? LOL!

John
phenix007 Offline
#27 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
you can have mine next month..phenix
tailgater Offline
#28 Posted:
Joined: 06-01-2000
Posts: 26,185
John,
If France was attacked like we were on 9/11, and they made a proactive mission to remove other eminent threats, then we would support them.

Their refusal to do so may have led to more lives lost and the ability for Iraq to hide WOMD.

Nice allies.
rayder1 Offline
#29 Posted:
Joined: 06-02-2002
Posts: 2,226
If I get a shipment of B.N. the club (I don't use their name due to their association with a cigar club) I'll be happy to trade you the B.N. for a Cab or Pinot.
phenix007 Offline
#30 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2002
Posts: 245
If the French were attacked instead on 9/11...they would have surrendered to Osama or whoever they could appeal to before we could get to their aid..which we would do without hesitation or debate..phenix
Users browsing this topic
Guest