I've not been impressed with the few Caldwell I've had. Construction was not on par with my expectations for a $10+ cigar. Flavor wise, I don't remember, so must've not been for me. I dont like full/full or pepper forward. Dont remember if that was the profile or not. I do remember needing a relight, and a split wrapper, and the fact that I've smoked a couple and really don't remember em. A $10+ cigar I tend to remember.