So, I just finished the Island Jim. That cigar is...pretty awesome, I compiled some notes on it while I was smoking it. They're what I use for writing, consider it my mini-review:
ISLAND JIM by Oscar Valladares & Co.
Earthiness, Pepper, Leather
Wrapper: Nicaraguan Jalapa
Binder: Honduran
Filler: Honduran
Body – Full
Perceived Value - $5-$8 Stick
Any Issues – Due to the nature of the double cap, there are some draw issues, not terrible, it just takes getting used to.
The cigar is very aesthetically pleasing, and the spice comes through especially on the retrohale.
Would I buy this cigar? Yes, though if this wasn't given to me, I’d definitely be looking for it in a sampler first. Its’ Eye catching, but the name and manufacturer don’t stand out in my head enough to take a leap. I'm very glad to have discovered this cigar, and it will be a regular in my rotation.
Additional Comments: That Jalapa is “Bacon Wrapped Steak” delicious. I'm so glad I ate lunch before I had this stick, otherwise I may have had an issue.
Leaf By Oscar - Sumatra
Medium Bodied
White Pepper, Tobacco, Citrus (On Retro-hale)
As the cigar progresses the White Pepper turns into a black pepper, and the Tobacco flavor lightens.
Surprisingly smooth for a Sumatra, lacks toothiness
Initial appearance: This is a very cool, unique presentation. It comes wrapped externally in an entire tobacco leaf, with its own band that says “Leaf by Oscar – Sumatra” on it. I’ve never seen anything like it, and depending on the persons palate, any of the cigars from this line would make a stellar gift on aesthetics alone.
Perceived Value: $3-$5/Stick
This is the most Non-Sumatra, Sumatra wrapper I’ve had since the La Aurora 1495. Not something I would smoke every day, but if you’re looking for a lighter Sumatra cigar, this is one to check out.
Would I buy it again? Honestly? No. It wasn’t what I look for in a Sumatra. I’ll stick with my Fallen Angels. That being said, if you like the 1495, Look this one up.