I don't know if there is a bad cigar from the Aging Room.
Both the M356ii, Bin #1, and Quattro F55 are all box worthy. And I just had the AR Maduro the other night. WOW. That may just be the best maduro I have ever had. Have not had any of the others, but the ones I have tried are definitely worth the time and $. You can even get the M356ii at one place in bundles instead of boxes and the prices are sick.