izonfire wrote:Great.
We got another sci-fi nerd in the nuthouse...
Hey-yo!!! I'm a sci-fi nerd too! Especially where Star Trek is concerned!
I think Kirk could take Picard in a fight, but as far as being a responsible, rule-abiding (mostly) Captain, that would go to Picard.
Sisco was a pretty good Captain, but he bought into the whole religious Emissary thing too much. Janeway was a pioneer, as far as being the first female captain lead in the show, and being thrown 70,000+ lightyears out into the middle of nowhere, but she broke the prime directive a few times, especially the temporal prime directive.
Archer was a little bland for me......but he was also a pioneer, taking the NX-01 (the first Warp 5 capable ship) out into TRULY uncharted territory.
There, that's my little sci-fi run......