| 57401. Author: fourfear | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 9:21AM EST | |
72534-AB Caribbean Cask
72535-AB White Gold
72536-Ave Maria-Argentum |
| 57402. Author: Telecaster52 | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 1:39PM EST | |
72,537- Aganorsa Leaf Aniversario Nicaragua
Gifted from Cheno. Thanks it was a great smoke. |
| 57403. Author: Stogie1020 | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 2:37PM EST | |
Speaking of Telecaster...
72538 - Nica Rustica c/o Telecaster52. I had read good and bad reviews of these and kinda had been wanting to try one. I was really surprised at how smooth and consistent it was. I expected something a little rougher, but the blend was right up my alley. Really a very nice smoke. Any idea how long this one had been resting T52? |
| 57404. Author: Telecaster52 | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 3:46PM EST | |
72,539- AB Nica Puro Stogie talked me into it.
I think I ordered these in April this year but the box is dated 2018. I think that's when they stopped production. |
| 57405. Author: Twi | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 4:56PM EST | |
72540- Arturo Fuente Anniverxario |
| 57406. Author: Dg west deptford | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 5:00PM EST | |
72541 - BLACKBIRD unkind
72542 - TATUAJE Tuxtla 7th |
| 57407. Author: Palama | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 6:51PM EST | |
Twi wrote:725xx- Arturo Fuente Anniverxario It's a small miracle!  First post and he / she includes the correct number!  |
| 57408. Author: tonygraz | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 8:17PM EST | |
72543 - Ramon Bueso Genesis robusto |
| 57409. Author: Jakethesnake86 | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 8:40PM EST | |
72544 San Pedro Nicaragua robusto |
| 57410. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 8:46PM EST | |
Some folks research before jumping in
72545 - Henry Clay Rustic Cheroot |
| 57411. Author: Jakethesnake86 | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 9:06PM EST | |
Heck I can’t get the number right 75 percent of the time. And I know I’m supposed to count |
| 57412. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Wed, 6/29/2022, 10:13PM EST | |
We believe in you, Jakey |
| 57413. Author: Telecaster52 | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 6:36AM EST | |
[quote=Sunoverbeach]Some folks research before jumping in
That hurts. I thought we was friends. |
| 57414. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 8:14AM EST | |
'Twas a general comment towards the whole community.
I can't be blamed for your guilty conscience |
| 57415. Author: LeeBot | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 8:47AM EST | |
I did not put the number in my first post. We can't all be brane serjuns.
72546 - New World Cameroon churchill |
| 57416. Author: Telecaster52 | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 8:53AM EST | |
72,547 Tabak Red Eye
72,548 AB Magic Toast.
Sorry but that's the order they were ash'd |
| 57417. Author: fourfear | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 9:43AM EST | |
72549-AJF New World Puro Especial |
| 57418. Author: Telecaster52 | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 1:23PM EST | |
72,550- MF La Opulencia |
| 57419. Author: Dg west deptford | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 5:08PM EST | |
72551 - EZ Louis Zuitton '20 |
| 57420. Author: Telecaster52 | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 7:10PM EST | |
72,552- Stolen Throne Crook Of The Crown
Gifted from Stogie. I'm getting the return attack prepared. |
| 57421. Author: midmofan | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 7:37PM EST | |
72,553
A Room 101 Roxxo from my deep stash! Still amazing! |
| 57422. Author: Jakethesnake86 | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 8:38PM EST | |
72554 Gilberto oliva noir torpedo |
| 57423. Author: Telecaster52 | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 8:41PM EST | |
72,555 Nica Rustica |
| 57424. Author: tonygraz | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 9:09PM EST | |
72556 - Ramon Bueso Exclusivo No. 1
72557 - Nicaraguan Cream churchill |
| 57425. Author: LeeBot | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 9:39PM EST | |
72558 - Privada Classique corona gorda
72559 - Cain F lancero |
| 57426. Author: Stogie1020 | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 9:49PM EST | |
Telecaster52 wrote:72,552- Stolen Throne Crook Of The Crown
Gifted from Stogie. I'm getting the return attack prepared. No.You.Are.Not. Put the box down and reassess your love for flat rate boxes and packing tape.... It's not healthy. But I hope you enjoyed the cigar. |
| 57427. Author: getpips | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 9:50PM EST | |
Ramon bueso olancha vintage
Very rich complex maduro |
| 57428. Author: Stogie1020 | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 10:02PM EST | |
getpips wrote:Ramon bueso olancha vintage
Very rich complex maduro I am not on the welcoming committee (they should be along shortly with waffle questions) but don't forget to put the next sequential number in front of your smoked cigar so we can attempt, poorly, to keep track of something for some purpose that is terribly unclear. Also, welcome. |
| 57429. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Thu, 6/30/2022, 10:25PM EST | |
To quote the illustrious Princess Leia, "I am not a committee" but welcome Pips.
As Stogie alluded to, one question of utmost importance: Pancakes or Waffles?
Next # is 72561 |
| 57430. Author: Palama | Date: Fri, 7/1/2022, 3:51AM EST | |
#72,561 - JRE Aladino Corona
While herfing with a couple of h.s. buddies at The Row Kaka’ako |
| 57431. Author: Jakethesnake86 | Date: Fri, 7/1/2022, 7:01AM EST | |
72562 la palina classic robusto. Gummy Jones sent me this one last year. Random bombing. Thanks gummy. Digging it so far |
| 57432. Author: fourfear | Date: Fri, 7/1/2022, 9:36AM EST | |
72563-RP Vintage 1990 |
| 57433. Author: delta1 | Date: Fri, 7/1/2022, 12:42PM EST | |
Palama wrote:#72,532 - Cigar Dojo ReviveR 2021 Toro Really liked the one I smoked in March. Hoping a few more months of rest will make this even better. Edit: the spice(s) and (white?) pepper seemed more forward than what I remembered…but in a good way. Burn and draw were spot-on. These are gonna be great down the road, too bad the right coast place is sold out.  doing the same...smoked two and was a bit underwhelmed...construction was fine, flavor not bad but had my hopes way up... have decided to let the rest sit for a few months/year...hope you're right that there will be a measurable improvement |
| 57434. Author: Palama | Date: Fri, 7/1/2022, 3:23PM EST | |
delta1 wrote:doing the same...smoked two and was a bit underwhelmed...construction was fine, flavor not bad but had my hopes way up...
have decided to let the rest sit for a few months/year...hope you're right that there will be a measurable improvement
Interesting….  I know you have a much more developed palate than me so maybe my plebeian tastes were easily impressed? Fo’ sure I didn’t get no buttery shortbread.  |
| 57435. Author: delta1 | Date: Fri, 7/1/2022, 6:32PM EST | |
it does seem as though our tastes in cigars are usually aligned...and I normally agree with your judgement on the quality of a specific cigar...
the Reviver was a decent cigar, but I had high hopes...The Corojo and criolla wrapper didn't deliver the spicy sweet cedar punch I was expecting, given the hype...this seemed more like a standard Nicaraguan leather, wood and strong tobacco kinda smoke...see the over the top review by Kohnhead that swayed my purchase:
https://kohnhed.com/2021/11/05/reviver-by-cigar-dojo-and-aganorsa-leaf-2021-cigar-reviews-by-the-katman/ |
| 57436. Author: Jakethesnake86 | Date: Fri, 7/1/2022, 6:54PM EST | |
72564 micallef Reata Churchill from a trade with delta. Solid smoke. Very nice. With some google help. This is a Mexican Claro wrapper. Silky smooth but full of flavors. Lovin it.
Everything you sent in that package has been amazing. Thank you again |
| 57437. Author: Palama | Date: Fri, 7/1/2022, 7:53PM EST | |
delta1 wrote:it does seem as though our tastes in cigars are usually aligned...and I normally agree with your judgement on the quality of a specific cigar...
the Reviver was a decent cigar, but I had high hopes...The Corojo and criolla wrapper didn't deliver the spicy sweet cedar punch I was expecting, given the hype...this seemed more like a standard Nicaraguan leather, wood and strong tobacco kinda smoke...see the over the top review by Kohnhead that swayed my purchase:
https://kohnhed.com/2021/11/05/reviver-by-cigar-dojo-and-aganorsa-leaf-2021-cigar-reviews-by-the-katman/ Yup, Katman’s review sent me immediately to the site and I bought a box. Luckily the discount coupon code worked so was able to get them for under $9 per, shipping included. Can’t explain the differences of opinion but maybe it’s as simple as different roller and different bales of tobacco? |
| 57438. Author: tonygraz | Date: Fri, 7/1/2022, 10:17PM EST | |
72565 - AB Project 40 experimental robusto |
| 57439. Author: clintCigar | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 4:20AM EST | |
72566-72567 - Southern Draw Quickdraw Pennsylvania (x2)
72568 - AJ Fernandez Last Call Maduro
72569 - Black Works Studio Intergalactic
72570-72571 - Liga Privada T52 Coronet (x2) |
| 57440. Author: Jakethesnake86 | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 7:03AM EST | |
72572 hammer and sickle tradicion robusto |
| 57441. Author: LeeBot | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 9:24AM EST | |
72573 - Foundation The Tabernacle lancero from Jake. I thought it was excellent. Really interesting floral notes, and some kinda yeasty thing in the middle like beer. I found myself puffing too fast because I liked it so much, had to force myself to slow down. Thank you Jake! |
| 57442. Author: Jakethesnake86 | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 9:44AM EST | |
Awesome lee. Glad you liked it! |
| 57443. Author: tonygraz | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 9:57AM EST | |
72574 - CAO Columbia Tinto |
| 57444. Author: Jakethesnake86 | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 12:52PM EST | |
72575 perdomo lot 23. Left inside tractor cab a couple weeks. Tastes completely normal |
| 57445. Author: tonygraz | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 4:03PM EST | |
72576 - Oliva 5 Melanio robusto 2nd |
| 57446. Author: delta1 | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 4:39PM EST | |
Jakethesnake86 wrote:72564 micallef Reata Churchill from a trade with delta. Solid smoke. Very nice. With some google help. This is a Mexican Claro wrapper. Silky smooth but full of flavors. Lovin it.
Everything you sent in that package has been amazing. Thank you again glad you liked it/them, Jake. Micallef kinda flies under the radar here in the CBid forums...rarely mentioned...I got one a few years ago at the Big Smoke in Las Vegas...it was the Herencia...IMHO, it was the best of that show's offerings, and it didn't hurt that the Cigar Vixen was personally working their table... I've tracked down a few other of their lines, including the Reata, and have thought highly of most...ironically the one that got high ratings in CA, the Leyenda, was my least fave... |
| 57447. Author: Dg west deptford | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 4:53PM EST | |
72577 - PSD 6 '19 |
| 57448. Author: Dg west deptford | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 5:01PM EST | |
72578 - Illusione LGC Rex |
| 57449. Author: Jakethesnake86 | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 5:48PM EST | |
delta1 wrote:glad you liked it/them, Jake. Micallef kinda flies under the radar here in the CBid forums...rarely mentioned...I got one a few years ago at the Big Smoke in Las Vegas...it was the Herencia...IMHO, it was the best of that show's offerings, and it didn't hurt that the Cigar Vixen was personally working their table...
I've tracked down a few other of their lines, including the Reata, and have thought highly of most...ironically the one that got high ratings in CA, the Leyenda, was my least fave...
I do believe I have more of those now that you mention it. That was the first of those I’ve tried. Oddly seems CA ratings really don’t mean much. Once in a while I’ll agree a cigar is good that they give high ratings to. But as a rule I pay little mind to anything they publish. I get more solid info from this forum. |
| 57450. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Sat, 7/2/2022, 9:35PM EST | |
72579 - Stolen Throne Argos toro
A Winston's Humidor in exclusive thanks to mjrburn |
