| 45151. Author: clintCigar | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 3:23PM EST | |
54738 - Partagas Black Bravo |
| 45152. Author: clintCigar | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 4:08PM EST | |
54739 - A. Flores Gran Reserva Corojo 2006 |
| 45153. Author: fiddler898 | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 4:10PM EST | |
54740: Monte #2. |
| 45154. Author: clintCigar | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 4:50PM EST | |
54741 - Fallen Angel |
| 45155. Author: Palama | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 5:34PM EST | |
Sunoverbeach wrote:
547xx- AF 858 SG '13
The beginning of wrapper comparison. Thanks to Conan for the well aged test subject. Initial SG response: liked it
Glad you liked it Dan.  So are you gonna smoke an 8-5-8 a day?  |
| 45156. Author: clintCigar | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 5:48PM EST | |
54742 - Diesel Whiskey Row Gigante (got this here on cbid for 4.50. It's a beast!) |
| 45157. Author: Cereal City Cigar Smoker | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 6:05PM EST | |
#54,743 - The King is Dead - Diamond Girl
#54,744 - Kristoff Criolla Corona |
| 45158. Author: corey sellers | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 6:27PM EST | |
54744 ~ Man of War torp sucked
54745 ~ Vaije C-4 one left got to get more next time |
| 45159. Author: corey sellers | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 6:28PM EST | |
54747 ~ Vaije C-4 |
| 45160. Author: tonygraz | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 6:48PM EST | |
54748 - Gurkha Status torpedo
54749 - Gurkha Ancient Warrior presidente
54750 - Gurkha Genghis Khan |
| 45161. Author: corey sellers | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 6:56PM EST | |
The gurkha fest is still going give them Tony |
| 45162. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 8:20PM EST | |
Palama wrote:So are you gonna smoke an 8-5-8 a day? I aim to smoke an 858 per timeframe I can reasonably guarantee I won't be interrupted. Ideally 1/day, but that's probably optimistic. |
| 45163. Author: clintCigar | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 8:44PM EST | |
54751 - RoMa Craft Neanderthal |
| 45164. Author: SmokeMonkey | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 8:47PM EST | |
54752 - Herrera Estelí Brazil |
| 45165. Author: Palama | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 8:51PM EST | |
Sunoverbeach wrote:I aim to smoke an 858 per timeframe I can reasonably guarantee I won't be interrupted. Ideally 1/day, but that's probably optimistic. If you’re not doing it already, suggest you take notes to help you remember. |
| 45166. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 9:06PM EST | |
Was very diligent about that for a while, but have fallen behind lately. I'm a slacker at heart |
| 45167. Author: Palama | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 9:18PM EST | |
Sunoverbeach wrote:Was very diligent about that for a while, but have fallen behind lately. I'm a slacker at heart Life happens. |
| 45168. Author: Palama | Date: Wed, 7/24/2019, 10:36PM EST | |
#54,753 - Tat PCR
Quick smoke before dinner. |
| 45169. Author: clintCigar | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 12:17AM EST | |
54754 - Caldwell Dos Firmas |
| 45170. Author: clintCigar | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 1:48AM EST | |
54755 - A. Flores Gran Reserva Corojo |
| 45171. Author: Palama | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 2:12AM EST | |
#54,756 - JRE Aladino Robusto |
| 45172. Author: Cereal City Cigar Smoker | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 3:32PM EST | |
#54,757 - 7-20-4 Dog Walker
#54,758 - AB Mundial |
| 45173. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 3:57PM EST | |
54759 - CAO Italia
54760 - MOW PA Maduro beli |
| 45174. Author: Phil222 | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 3:59PM EST | |
54761 - Alec Bradley American Sun Grown
Thanks to cashmoneydave. |
| 45175. Author: tonygraz | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 6:11PM EST | |
54762 - Gurkha Ancient Warrior presidente
54763 - Gurkha Widomaker maduro churchill
54764 - Gurkha Black Ops maduro churchill |
| 45176. Author: corey sellers | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 6:17PM EST | |
Dam Tony the gurkha fest continues give it hell
54765 ~ Undercrown Sungrown gran toro
|
| 45177. Author: corey sellers | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 7:07PM EST | |
54766 ~ Room 101 Daruma should have got more boxes of these |
| 45178. Author: SmokeMonkey | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 7:35PM EST | |
Sunoverbeach wrote:Was very diligent about that for a while, but have fallen behind lately. I'm a slacker at heart This 4 years ago. The best I do is rate everything I smoke or revise ratings based on my current palate. 54767 - Plasencia Alma Del Campo Really good, but as I understand it’s somewhat expensive, not sure it’s worth retail. That said, it was very different than my normal profile and I loved every minute of it. Great change of pace with some very interesting flavors. |
| 45179. Author: Whistlebritches | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 8:47PM EST | |
54768-Room 101 Chief Cool Arrow...…….rest has done these well |
| 45180. Author: tonygraz | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 10:07PM EST | |
next is 54769 |
| 45181. Author: frankj1 | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 10:50PM EST | |
fiddler898 wrote:54740: Monte #2. I was eyeballing the one you gave me. Is it ready? |
| 45182. Author: frankj1 | Date: Thu, 7/25/2019, 10:55PM EST | |
54769~ LFD DL452
from fiddler898
one of three great smokes he dropped on me during his visit this week on Cape Cod. Haven't had one in a couple of years, used to be a real favorite.
despite my gravitation to slightly milder smokes, I have always been able to fully enjoy this particular little cigar. This one was a great reminder.
Thanks Alan. |
| 45183. Author: Palama | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 2:19AM EST | |
#54,770 - Crowned Heads Four Kicks Maduro Corona Gorda |
| 45184. Author: Phil222 | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 12:50PM EST | |
54,771 - Aganorsa Leaf Signature Selection |
| 45185. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 4:29PM EST | |
54772 - PDR Oscuro torpedo
54773 - AF 858 Maduro '14
Next in the wrapper comparison and came with a nicely yellowed cello. Thanks again to Conan. I'm loving this game and couldn't have done it without you. OK, I could have, but it's easier when they all hit your mailbox at once fully aged and ready to go. I've enjoyed both but I'm going to give the edge to the Maddy over the SG. Found the SG more interesting with a strong note of cedar assuming from 5+ yrs in the sleeve. Found the Maduro to have a slightly sweeter profile but not excessively so and just hit my palate in all the right ways. Argued that I was letting my preferences cloud my judgment, but that's just what preferences do. |
| 45186. Author: corey sellers | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 4:36PM EST | |
54774 ~ Southern Draw Firethorn |
| 45187. Author: Cereal City Cigar Smoker | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 4:38PM EST | |
#54,775 - HC Pigtail
#54,776 - CAO Flathead 554 |
| 45188. Author: SmokeMonkey | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 6:50PM EST | |
54777 - Oliva MB3 from a trade with Corey some years ago, I’d guess, as it’s dated 2016
Always a solid smoke, which is what I was looking for. Thanks to my Southern brother. |
| 45189. Author: corey sellers | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 6:58PM EST | |
54778 ~ Liga Privada dirty rat from Deadeyedick just started it and it going to be great the wife and I already dug into the nutsack and the habanero peanuts good stuff there |
| 45190. Author: corey sellers | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 6:58PM EST | |
Glad you liked it Monkey if you need a few more just say the word brother |
| 45191. Author: Palama | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 9:30PM EST | |
Sunoverbeach wrote:54772 - PDR Oscuro torpedo
54773 - AF 858 Maduro '14
Next in the wrapper comparison and came with a nicely yellowed cello. Thanks again to Conan. I'm loving this game and couldn't have done it without you. OK, I could have, but it's easier when they all hit your mailbox at once fully aged and ready to go. I've enjoyed both but I'm going to give the edge to the Maddy over the SG. Found the SG more interesting with a strong note of cedar assuming from 5+ yrs in the sleeve. Found the Maduro to have a slightly sweeter profile but not excessively so and just hit my palate in all the right ways. Argued that I was letting my preferences cloud my judgment, but that's just what preferences do. Glad you’re able to discern the differences without having to wait a few months or years. Ultimately, hope it expedites your cigar knowledge growth.  |
| 45192. Author: Palama | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 9:33PM EST | |
#54,779 - AF Casa Cuba Divine Inspiration
One of my favorite Fuente Friday smokes. |
| 45193. Author: Cheno | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 9:39PM EST | |
#54,780 - liga privada #9
First one I've had, I'm maybe 3 minutes into it with a glass of Basil Hayden. And so far I'm loving it. |
| 45194. Author: tonygraz | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 9:52PM EST | |
54781 - gurkha Ancient Warrior presidente
54782 - Gurkha Rogue Ruthless
54783 - Gurkha 125th anniv. toro (a bit of flavor in the final third) |
| 45195. Author: izonfire | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 10:28PM EST | |
During the week -
54784 - AB American Sungrown
54785 - HC Habano Colorado
Today -
54786 - AB Tempus Maduro
54787 - Flathead 660 |
| 45196. Author: clintCigar | Date: Fri, 7/26/2019, 11:36PM EST | |
54788 - FedHeads 2019
54789 - Gurkha Seduction
54790 - AVO Classic No. 6
54791 - Caldwell Long Live the King |
| 45197. Author: clintCigar | Date: Sat, 7/27/2019, 1:07AM EST | |
54792 - The Filthy Viking |
| 45198. Author: Palama | Date: Sat, 7/27/2019, 2:54AM EST | |
#54,793 - PAN 64 Principe
These used to be a short smoke favorite until Padrons disappeared from the bidding sites. |
| 45199. Author: Sunoverbeach | Date: Sat, 7/27/2019, 8:35AM EST | |
Palama wrote: Ultimately, hope it expedites your cigar knowledge growth. There's always hope. Though to date I've resisted any personal emotional or intellectual growth so momentum may be working against me. |
| 45200. Author: gummy jones | Date: Sat, 7/27/2019, 11:31AM EST | |
54794 ryj cc |
