Don't base it on how many cigars you smoke now. Take that number and multiply it by 5. If you smoke 2 a week now, assume you'll smoke 10 a week once you fill your humi with high quality inexpensive smokes. Besides, you'll have to smoke down your stash just to make room for all of your new winnings. Then figure that you'll want to be able to age cigars for a year. I wouldn't recommend messing with anything smaller than a Havana Footlocker, but would definitely recommend the Club Chairside. I've been through several humis, and wish I would have gotten the chairside in the very beginning. The smaller humis require too much attention.
If you really only want something small, just buy a sampler that comes with a humi. Most of the time you can get a great deal on the smokes and the humi is essentially free. I would further recommend focusing on a sampler that comes with a travel humi. They work well for storing sticks and will be useful long after you upgrade your capacity.