Actually pacman, we leave lighters and matches on the window ledges outside. Only in the smoking areas of course. Sometimes the passengers get it and put them back, sometimes they don't. But there's usually at least one lighter available if you look. They're on the second row of windows, you have to look up.
Trust me, I hate taking lighters away. Its a hassle and causes me extra work. There's the paperwork, calling the airline to come get the damn lighter, and waiting around for the airline to come get it. I could be doing more useful things.
I don't get why we need to take bic type lighters, I really don't. Butane is a gas though, I can see it...in a large capacity. A can of butane is bad (and yes, people try). A little lighter though? Pfft.