burgess_b
Sunday, July 15, 2007 10:06:00 AM
when i get back to the states, i will definitely check into that kitty litter.

here is a question. as TG states, the kitty litter keeps in the crap (smells, etc)...so do the beads, as well???

and i do not think ANYone believes the beads were "made" for cigars. they were made for art work. i often see a glass of water in a display case with pottery over here. paper and canvas get the beads.

Thunder.Gerbil
Sunday, July 15, 2007 10:27:00 AM
^^^

If the chemical lattice is the same, which AFAIK, it basically is, then the properties would be essentially the same.

The H-beads were not intended to trap impurities, they were intended to function as a humidity regulation device and only with only pure water, so no need for the larger pore size to permit impurity penetration into the core of the bead. The H-beads, being only slightly porus would only trap impurities on the surface layers.

There have been reports of people using H-beads and the beads discoloring due to tobacco pieces getting mixed into the container and then picking up a black/brown tint due to the tar/nicotine being trapped in some of the beads.

JTokash
Sunday, July 15, 2007 11:51:00 AM
Too bad I don't use either beads or litter. If I did, I could sign up for some time at the materials characterization lab on the campus and tell you the exact compositions and crystallographic data for the two. I guess the mystery will remain. LOL I guess that might ruin the conversation though... then what would we talk about? 🙂

If the litter works, I'd say go for it... why pay more for another product that does the same thing, even if the first product isn't intended for that specific use. When was younger and I would go to the target range, I would use a carbide lantern to blacken the front sight on the M1A I was shooting to keep the sun from making a glare on it. Was that the intended use of a carbide lantern? No. Did it work for me? Yes.

Time for me to go for a smoke.

Regards,

-JT

bsevern
Sunday, July 15, 2007 12:21:00 PM
I have four cooladors, one 3,000 stick cabinet humidor, four tubadors, four large desk top humis, and something I've probably missed (I think I need a new hobby, damn I could've built my Daytona Coupe for what I have *invested* in cigars).

I have everything going here - gel, H-beads, K-beads, Cigar Oasis and even water pillows depending on the application. The K-beads work as well as anything in my experience, YMMV. Buy what works for you or you feel secure in your mind is the best solution really is the bottom line IMO.

Oh and I do buy Mobil1 synthetic oil for my Viper at Wallyworld, does that make me a cheap azz?

guyute
Sunday, July 15, 2007 12:27:00 PM
Exactly, there's Plenty of products out there that hobbyists use as a cheap alternative to whatever is designated as the "real" item.

For instance, one of my fishtanks for the past 7 years was a tank of African Cichlids. The water chemistry is Much different from tap water. I could spend roughly $30/mo on PH Upper, Alkalinity Buffer, etc...

Instead I mix Baking Soda, Epsom Salt and Marine Salt in very small quantities. You're talking maybe $3/mo instead of $30.

That being said, I bought beads a few weeks ago... because I needed something in a hurry, and didn't take the time to research kitty litter. I will be going to Petsmart pretty soon though. Not just for litter, but also for "filter media bags" (designed for fishtanks), to bag the litter.

teedubbya
Sunday, July 15, 2007 1:32:00 PM
and don't forget the poo scoop