MACS
Monday, August 4, 2008 12:35:00 AM
Sorry I missed this!

I've not read through the posts, but I was a pot smoker extraordinaire, back in HS. Man... was I always stoned...

I completely agree with decriminalizing it. Legalize it, do whatever you have to do.

It is much, much, MUCH less harmful to you than alcohol. And stoned drivers don't drive reckless and kill people. They drive really slow, laugh a lot and make other drivers crazy.

teedubbya
Monday, August 4, 2008 6:32:00 AM
DMV I do beleive suicide is against the law in many states..... crazy eh?
DrafterX
Monday, August 4, 2008 6:37:00 AM
'Cause suicide is painless...

teedubbya
Monday, August 4, 2008 6:38:00 AM
unless you use a cheese grater and start at your feet
DrafterX
Monday, August 4, 2008 6:40:00 AM
True..true...
Sardious
Monday, August 4, 2008 9:35:00 AM
"And stoned drivers don't drive reckless and kill people. They drive really slow, laugh a lot and make other drivers crazy."

Not always true. I have had some friends that drove CRAZT when high and I know a ton of people that drink a few too many and drive overly slow in hopes of not getting a DUI. Even most motorcycle guys that do the 90 mile an hour wheelies in rush hour traffic smoke weed to get the "guts" to try to kill themselves. Intox means not able to think clearly one is not all happy and safe while the other is all scarey and evil. It deoends on the person. Mt friends foather in law is drunk a lot, he has some bad addiction, but he is never violent or mean and he doesn't dive drunk cause he gets intox at home, he is quieter when drunk and never an a-hole. So alchohol can he just as "friendly" for some people depending on the person. Just as weed can make people do stupid damaging stuff depending on the person.

stats

An estimated 38,000 high school seniors in the U.S. reported in 2001 that they crashed while driving under the influence of marijuana and 46,000 reported that they crashed while impaired by alcohol.

Sio weed safer sure by a little bit but totally safe...no. Also I know very few people that get high that don't usually drink at the same time unless it is early in the day. For some reason they think it is ok to smoke at 10AM but it is wrong to drink that early.

pabloescabar
Monday, August 4, 2008 9:39:00 AM
not to me's
Sardious
Monday, August 4, 2008 9:52:00 AM
Also for fuz, potts is attacking the one guy’s act of legalizing one substance while doing the act of banning another. It is not really an attack on the "person" he is not saying "but that rep. is a democrat" he is saying that the rep is in the act of trying to ban or criminalize tobacco.

For your priest scenario it would be more like

Priest: I think abortion is morally wrong

Guy: because it is killing an innocent?

Priest: yes

Guy: But you support the war

Priest: Umm yes what does that have to do with abortion?

Guy: Innocents die in the war too

SO with your rep and potts

Rep: Legalize MJ the government should not control what you put in your body

Potts: that includes tobacco?

Rep: No tobacco is bad for you and should attempt to remove it from society

Hence not attack on the person but perceiving the person by the whole of his current actions.

So why support someone who will free one substance but yet actively attempt to work to ban another than you use. In your statement that the government should not control what substances you take then why take the side of someone whose action is to control the tobacco you like to partake in? That is against the action not against the man. Don't hold onto a Latin phrase at the point of losing ground. Sometimes it is best to cut losses and move on to the next point. But the Latin did make you look more intelligent but you made your side point about the comeback point, don’t linger if you can’t get a solid win toward the main argument (decriminalization) off the side point. People will not forget the possibility of personhood attacks.

Also person attacks are not and have never been invalid. They are taught in college debate. A pro pot site like NORML will use only studies that support their cause and if that is always the same one or 2 studies made by another pro pot group that may have interviewed only a pro pot section then an attack on the person “or institution/group” is valid because they will refuse things that do not support them and close themselves off to the whole for the purpose of justifying a position that they have personal interest in.

Just trying ot help out so that we can see the thread reach 420

FuzzNJ
Monday, August 4, 2008 9:55:00 AM
Driving under the influence of anything, including very little sleep is reckless and stupid. Teaching kids to just say no and if you do it I'll kill you just leads to them making one stupid decision after another that could just lead to death.

If they do end up having a drink or a toke, or the person driving has, make sure they have enough trust in you to be able to call you for a ride. If all you've told them is that it's all evil, they will be too afraid to call and take a stupid risk. I'd rather have them home alive.

and yes, this is my personal opinion.

DrMaddVibe
Monday, August 4, 2008 9:55:00 AM
#162...do they try the corpse too? I mean you break the law, the cops write a ticket, you don't show up for your court date, you're in contempt, you get more time...seems like a lot of work to off oneself.

WHERE DOES IT STOP????????????????????

FuzzNJ
Monday, August 4, 2008 10:00:00 AM
Sardious, he's not arguing the position, he's talking about Frank's position on tobacco in an attempt to discredit his position on marijuana, which is not relevant to this discussion. That's an attack on Frank and his positions, therefore an ad hominem referring to Frank's credibility. Classic tactic, but a logical fallacy, if you want to be technical about it, which I apparently do.

;)

FuzzNJ
Monday, August 4, 2008 10:01:00 AM
170: all good questions, which is why the law is stupid, but, it's on the books.
Sardious
Monday, August 4, 2008 10:05:00 AM
#169 funny that you bring up being too tired. Since that apparently scores worse for driving than alcohol!

I was also the unfortunate example, even though I did not get the ticket.

I am on my motorcycle. A guy changes lanes without signaling and hits me. I get hurt. Here is the kicker I was on about 2 days no sleep...on a highway on the motorcycle. I was in the guys blind spot but I seen him coming into my lane before he hit me. I braked and swerved to avoid getting hit but did so too late. I am to this day convinced that if I was not so tired I could have easily avoided getting hit. It is not all that rare for a driver to turn into your lane without seeing you on a bike. I have never remotely been hit by a lane changer outside of that time. I say he may have made a change with no blinker and no warning and into a spot where someone else already was at so yeah he was in the wrong but I could have avoided him had I not been dead tired.

Any excuse to make people aware of that danger.

teedubbya
Monday, August 4, 2008 10:05:00 AM
lol 170

yup.

actually they collect the fine from the estate and there are other benefit implications

DrMaddVibe
Monday, August 4, 2008 10:09:00 AM
Sounds like Judge Roy Bean to me!

"How much is in his pockets?"

"4 bits yer honor"

"Fine him 4 bits too, now hang him...boys the drinks are on the house.

DrMaddVibe
Monday, August 4, 2008 10:10:00 AM
Yeah, we all know that running a gay sex bordello out of a congressional address does wonders for one's credibility...kinda hard to hurt him there, eh?
FuzzNJ
Monday, August 4, 2008 10:11:00 AM
174: benefits, certainly. Usually there is a cut off though, after you have had a policy for a certain amount of time determined by the company, suicide is no longer considered a negative consequence, but the fine print details may negate all post death benefits.