Also for fuz, potts is attacking the one guy’s act of legalizing one substance while doing the act of banning another. It is not really an attack on the "person" he is not saying "but that rep. is a democrat" he is saying that the rep is in the act of trying to ban or criminalize tobacco.
For your priest scenario it would be more like
Priest: I think abortion is morally wrong
Guy: because it is killing an innocent?
Priest: yes
Guy: But you support the war
Priest: Umm yes what does that have to do with abortion?
Guy: Innocents die in the war too
SO with your rep and potts
Rep: Legalize MJ the government should not control what you put in your body
Potts: that includes tobacco?
Rep: No tobacco is bad for you and should attempt to remove it from society
Hence not attack on the person but perceiving the person by the whole of his current actions.
So why support someone who will free one substance but yet actively attempt to work to ban another than you use. In your statement that the government should not control what substances you take then why take the side of someone whose action is to control the tobacco you like to partake in? That is against the action not against the man. Don't hold onto a Latin phrase at the point of losing ground. Sometimes it is best to cut losses and move on to the next point. But the Latin did make you look more intelligent but you made your side point about the comeback point, don’t linger if you can’t get a solid win toward the main argument (decriminalization) off the side point. People will not forget the possibility of personhood attacks.
Also person attacks are not and have never been invalid. They are taught in college debate. A pro pot site like NORML will use only studies that support their cause and if that is always the same one or 2 studies made by another pro pot group that may have interviewed only a pro pot section then an attack on the person “or institution/group” is valid because they will refuse things that do not support them and close themselves off to the whole for the purpose of justifying a position that they have personal interest in.
Just trying ot help out so that we can see the thread reach 420