If you are choosing between a 45ACP and a 40S&W, I would go with the 45 simply because it has a bigger, heavier bullet and less felt recoil than a 40. With even the bad guys wearing vests these days, the 45 will at least knock them down and allow you to get away (or deliver a close range follow-up shot, if you prefer).
The 40S&W and the FBI is a sordid story about bureaucracy and compromise. Originally, after the infamous LA shootout, a group of "experts" wanted the 10mm which offered greater kinetic energy and penetration (200gr Bullet @ 1,300FPS) , but the recoil was too much for the 5th percentile, i.e., women and small men. So the FBI compromised on a shortened version of the 10mm they had S&W develop, hence 40S&W. One of the basic assumptions was that the 40S&W would have less recoil than the 45ACP. That assumption is false. The recoil impulse of the 40 is significantly sharper and thus has more "felt" recoil than a 45ACP whose recoil is spread over a longer pulse. If I remember correctly the original 40 was spec'd at 200 grain bullet @ 1,000 FPS and that has continually decreased over time to lower the recoil which is still considered objectionable to 5th percentile personnel. Thus the current FBI spec'd 40 S&W offers little more performance than a 147gr 9mm.
If you like the Sig but favor a 1911, Sig makes a 1911 that is a better gun than the Kimber. In my opinion, the Taurus PT-1911 shoots as good as and is of equal build quality as the Kimber for a lot less money.
JMHO.