avdmustang
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 7:57:00 PM
The $ is being taken from the rich in EITC. I know it is given to the working poor and I am all for it. But it is redistribution of wealth, plain and simple. But since it was Reagans plan, it is ok.
simmons_j_m
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 9:00:00 PM
Two points here...

1) it is redistributing wealth in an abstract way... really it's a tax return, but yes someone did have to pay for it.

2) it is not socialist because it does not require making someone poorer to pay the poorest person. The earned income credit did not require those that made more than $______ to give up some extra of their wealth in order to pay for the program... it was built into the tax system... not only that but everyone who pays taxes (even the recipient) would be paying for the program...

Obama's tax plans are socialist in nature because he feels it is the duty of rich (defined as $250,000 or more a year) to take care of the poor... while honorable in philosophy... it's socialist in nature. Government has no place to make anyone help another person... this should be done through private enterprise, not big brother.

Just my .02...

- J

donutboy2000
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 9:27:00 PM
You simply don't get it. Perhaps it's all beyond your capacity to understand.