8trackdisco
Saturday, November 29, 2008 4:55:00 PM
Last effort and then I'll leave this alone.

Situation A.

A gunman walks into a store, in a state where C&C is legal. There are 100 people in the store when a lone gunman walks into the store wanting to kill as manay as possible.

Situation B.

A gunman walks into a day care, in a state that C&C is NOT allowed, shoots the 4 adult daycare workers, bars the door and starts shooting children.

Is his total body count going to be in the store or the day care?

8trackdisco
Saturday, November 29, 2008 4:56:00 PM
(assuming their are 96 children in the daycare)
wtjvj
Saturday, November 29, 2008 5:03:00 PM
Damn 8track, B is a little harsh.

How about B the same as A but a non carry state?

8trackdisco
Saturday, November 29, 2008 5:10:00 PM
I'm trying to determine if he will fall back on we'd never know. He's already said on this thread that anybody using my thought process is "a fool".

If he comes back and says each situation is the same or we could never tell, or there are no guarantees. I'll try not to respond because then I'll KNOW he's just trying to 'eff with me.

Alz I'ze no iz dat if der be a bad guy wit a gat, even iffi' TG is packin', itz ahl baaaad.

wtjvj
Saturday, November 29, 2008 5:16:00 PM
At one time or another we are all fools.

But thats not the point.

rfenst
Saturday, November 29, 2008 5:37:00 PM
8track,

Too many changing hypotheticals with varying circumstances to be able to coherently analogize or distinguish from one another.

Suffice it to say, it would have been nice if the victims/hostages had weapons and opportunities they could have used to better protect themselves and the others.

Even better, I sure wish this tragedy had never happened...

8trackdisco
Saturday, November 29, 2008 5:40:00 PM
'..Suffice it to say, it would have been nice if the victims/hostages had weapons and opportunities they could have used to better protect themselves and the others. ..'

-------------------------------------------------------

Exactly.

RICKAMAVEN
Saturday, November 29, 2008 11:44:00 PM

9. Author: MACS

that's because you have one.

RICKAMAVEN
Saturday, November 29, 2008 11:51:00 PM
from what i read, most of the guys that want or feel the need to carry a concealed weapon, and that includes some friends that have a license to carry, pray for the day when they can draw and shoot.

they live in this dream world where they kill a bad guy before he can unload an ak47 in his directions.

i am not against guns, i own two hand guns, one in my home and one in me office, and i dread ever needing to take them from their holster.

RICKAMAVEN
Saturday, November 29, 2008 11:53:00 PM

6. Author: VaMtnMan

you ever try those games at arcades, where you play the sheriff and the video is the bad guy.

they also have one with cops and robbers.

GreenWolf70
Sunday, November 30, 2008 3:28:00 AM
Rickamaven, like most liberals you just don't understand. Its not that we "live for the day" when we can cap a bad guy. Its that we don't want to stand there helpless while innocents die, or are harmed. If you have ever been in that situation in real life, you will not ever want to be in that situation again. One man, or woman, can make a difference. In most cases in comes down to will.

Its the same reason I served for 34 years in the Army, I didn't want to be one of those people standing in the background pissing and moaning while others took action.

delarob
Sunday, November 30, 2008 11:47:00 AM
Just as I have insurance for my home/car/life, I also carry.

Hopefully I'll never need to use any of the above.

teedubbya
Sunday, November 30, 2008 12:19:00 PM
I'm not sure what Indias laws are in terms of concealed weopons

It also seems to me that the suposedly trained Indian commandos had their hands full in the shoot out. Not sure how joe six-shooter would fare.

I say supposedly trained commandos by the way a few of them handled their AKs on film..... over their head random spray into a building..... strange

teedubbya
Monday, December 1, 2008 1:41:00 PM
Indian citizens have the right to own, possess and carry guns provided a license / permit is obtained under the Central Arms Act, usually necessitating a background check from the nearest police department, or other law enforcement agency. The Indian government also distributes arms to citizens in areas ravaged by foreign infiltration and insurgency, as state policy.

this may answer some of the question

teedubbya
Monday, December 1, 2008 1:46:00 PM
I am finding contradicting info stating that India has draconian gun laws and stating they have lax gun laws and stating that the laws on the books are not enforced.... interesting.... they are more like the US than I thought 🙂
teedubbya
Monday, December 1, 2008 1:49:00 PM
FIREARMS OWNERSHIP

Percentage of Households with Firearms: Not known

Estimated Number of Firearms: There are an estimated 40 million firearms in India, the majority of which are illicit. India accounts for the majority of small arms in South Asia, which has an estimated 75 million firearms (63 million of which are in civilian possession). (3)

Types of Legal Firearms:

Relevant law - Arms Act, 1959 & Arms Rules, 1962.

Prohibited Bores

Prohibited Bores - Arms Rules, 1962 - Schedule I - categories I(b) and I(c).

MHA - sole licensing authority - w.e.f 8.8.1987.

Applications to be made through the local licensing authorities/State/U.T. Governments.

Non Prohibited Bores

Non-Prohibited Bores - Arms Rules, 1962 - Schedule I - category III.

District Magistrate/Collector - licensing authority - license for the whole State or part thereof.

All India or part license - granted by the State/U.T. Governments only.

Renewing authority - DM/Collector.

Applications in Form-A - available in the Collectorates/DM's offices.

Purposes of Lawful Firearms Ownership: Target-shooting, protection of person or property and private security. Firearm ownership is not permitted for the purposes of collecting or for hunting of game for sport or food. (2)

FIREARM DEATH, INJURY AND CRIME

In India, the rampant proliferation of illicit small arms combined with poor policing, has eroded human rights, weakened democratic institutions and polarized ethnic, religious, economic and political differences between citizens. (6) (7)

It is difficult for enforcement agencies to keep a check on violence when during elections private armies of politicians carrying illicit firearms roam at large (6). The problem of intimidation by such criminal elements is compounded by the fact that legal firearm ownership is so limited - making it impossible for a private citizen to effectively defend himself/ herself.

Suicides and Firearm Accidents in India, 1990 - 1994 (2)

1990

1991

1992

1993

1994

Total Suicides

73,911

78,450

80,149

84,244

89,195

Firearm Suicides

535

571

561

712

586

Firearm Suicide Rate

0.06

Firearm Accidents

2,731

3,169

3,341

1,980

2,375

Firearm Accident Rate

0.26

Source: The UN, Study on International Firearm Regulation, 1999 update.

Note: India reported its homicide statistics as "not reasonably available".

TYPES/SOURCES OF FIREARMS WHICH ARE MISUSED

India is part of a region that is saturated with small arms; it would be almost impossible to calculate the quantities and types of weapons in India. (7) The primary source for the proliferation of weapons in South Asia was the first Afghanistan war. The war in Cambodia was also a major source of supply. Most of these weapons were absorbed by Pakistan and India. Supply and demand are both fuelled by the continuing conflicts in the region; for example, the contested area of Kashmir between India and Pakistan, the US-led war in Afghanistan and the civil strife in Sri Lanka. (3) Further sources of illicit small arms include the illegal arms production "cottage industry" in India, leaks and thefts from State stocks, and problems in the licensing process. "Cottage industry" pistols, known as "kattas", are produced using a variety of ordinary items, including plumbing pipes and jeep steering columns. (6)

Illegal Trade: Despite India's stringent regulation of arms transfers, exports and imports, India still faces the problem of weapons which are smuggled into the country by various anti-national groups. As far as cross-border smuggling of SALW is concerned, the seizures, though not by any means a true measure of the real extent of illicit SALW trafficking, assist the authorities in a statistical assessment of the real dimension of the problem. For example, in Jammu and Kashmir and the north-eastern areas alone, the security forces have, since 1990, seized approximately 39,000 weapons of all types. The markings and types of weapons confiscated clearly indicate that these are brought into India through illicit channels from outside the country. A small amount of crude "country-made" weapons are also found to be produced clandestinely in India. (4)

DOMESTIC FIREARM LEGISLATION (2)

India's domestic policy on small arms and light weapons is regulated under the Arms Act (1959) and Arms Rules (1962). Due to the gravity of the problem of the proliferation of illicit SALW (Small Arms Light Weapons) and their misuse in terrorist activities, India has, since 1987, withdrawn substantially the license issuing powers of State and District authorities - who may not, now, issue licenses for prohibited bore weapons. Since 1987, their powers have been limited to issuing licences for non-prohibited bore weapons and these licenses are valid for a limited geographical area. Licenses for possession of prohibited bore weapons may only be issued, under special conditions, by the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India. (4)

Licensing Requirements: All firearm owners must be licensed. Applicants must provide information regarding:

their date of birth;

the availability of a safe place to store the firearm and ammunition;

the purpose for which they require a firearm;

any previous criminal record or prohibition to possess a firearm. However, if the report of the police officer is not sent within the prescribed time limit (3 months), the licensing authority may grant the licence. (2)

The applicant must present photographic identification and pay the prescribed fee for that firearm. (2) Under the existing law, all civilians are required to get their weapon /s inspected once a year by a competent authority - this is also recorded in the licence. (4)

The licensing authority may also refuse the licence for which he will record the reasons. The licensing authority may refuse to grant the licence if the applicant:

is of unsound mind;

is below the age of 16;

is deemed by the licensing authority to be a threat to the security of the public peace;

has been sentenced on conviction of any offence involving violence to imprisonment for any term at any time during a period of 5 years after the expiration of the sentence;

has been ordered to execute a bond for keeping the peace or for good behaviour at any time during the term of the bond. (2) (6)

The licensing authorities maintain list of firearm owners and the firearms held by them. No centralised database is maintained about firearm ownership and the identification of firearm. Every police station maintains a register of the licence holders in its jurisdiction, with the name of the licensee, description of weapon and its purpose. This list is updated from time to time. The licences are renewed after the prescribed period mentioned in the license or 3 years, whichever is earlier. Any police officer or other officer specially empowered on this behalf by the Central Government can demand the production of licence from the person carrying firearms or ammunition. The licensee is required to inform the licensing authorities of any change of place of residence. (2)

Registration Requirements: All small arms manufactured in India are uniquely marked by stamping to indicate the registration number, manufacturer/factory of origin and the year of manufacture on one or more of the critical components of a small arm - the body, the breech block and the barrel - during the final stages of production. This applies to arms that are produced for private/personal use and those which are used by armed forces, police or paramilitary forces. Allotment of these registration numbers for the armed forces/police and para-military forces is done centrally and a record is maintained of these registration numbers along with the indent. This provides for a double check on the records. A record of each and every weapon manufactured by the factory is kept along with the information on the concerned dealer. Arms which do not bear specified identification marks may not be sold or transferred. Further, any person found in possession of a weapon without identification marks would be presumed to have removed/obliterated the marks unless proven otherwise. (4)

Training Requirements: No training certification is required. However, some state governments do require such a certificate from professional bodies. (2)

Storage Requirements: The firearm must be stored in the safe place described by the owner in his or her licence application. There is no regulation regarding safety in domestic custody by the owner except the initial assurance of availability of safe place to keep arms in his application for grant of licence. (2)

jpotts
Monday, December 1, 2008 1:54:00 PM
I think where T.G. is going with this is that CCWs apply to semi-automatic handguns.

The terrorists were most likely carrying fully automatic AK-47s with lotsa extra ammo.

Unless you were some commando, you might have a fighting chance. Most average citizens would probably be cut in half in the crossfire.

That being said, if we had more people with more guns, the damage would have been minimized.

pacman357
Monday, December 1, 2008 4:19:00 PM
#3 Couldn't have said it better myself. Any time something big and terrible like this happens, speculation runs wild...all ends of the spectrum and plenty of it.
RICKAMAVEN
Monday, December 1, 2008 7:51:00 PM
71. Author: GreenWolf70

what does my social inclinations have to do with understanding people that own guns and then fantasizing

situations where they can draw and we can cap a bad guy.

i had a rifle pointed at me and toby and a second man coming 15 feet from me demanding the keys to my car.

i threw him the keys and they both left.

police found my car withing an hour because of a lojak.

suppose i had a hand gun on me at the time. then what, shoot at the car driving away.

JDELLLL
Tuesday, December 2, 2008 5:45:00 AM
Yeah, Rick. If someone is robbing you and you manage to get the drop on them, you should be able to shoot them on the spot and get a white rose pinned on your ass for doing it. It'd cut down on robberies and all we'd typically lose was some criminals.