Guilty as to non-union, but my wife is union (AT&T) and I see the possible need for a union when is comes to large corporations. They can't do what I do in a small company with fewer employees, and have a need for collective bargaining. My issue is with the UAW doing too good a job. Simply pricing their labor costs out of the market. I would love for someone to tell me what a UAW line worker with 10 yrs actually makes, including benefits, unemployment/down times guarantees and pensions. I honestly have no idea, only what I hear from the OKC plant (before it was closed after OKC put up big money to build it and the tax exempt concessions).
I have never used the term "socialism" in my posts as that angle never crossed my mind. My problem is that why is it the gov't (taxpayers) responsibility to make sure a particular company, in a particular industry survives? GM and Chrysler are not the only auto manufacturers. Granted, I doubt their ability to make it back to a be profitable company, and that raises the point of why would you "loan" money to a company in such dire straits, but where do stop and what criteria as you going to use when the next one comes along. And it certainly will. Won't insurance companies be lining up after the next hurricane? Aircraft manufactures, home builders, wheat farmers, buggy whip makers,.. who decides who gets what and under what circumstances? The bank bailout is going to be short slippery slope right into Pandora's Box, I don't mean that in a good way. What if the Big 3 come back in a few months, as most people think they will, when this amount isn't enough.
I cringe at the thought of gov't running health care, and I'm not sure I want them dictating the rules for a managing a car manufacturer. What about GM's competitors ( ignoring the "foreign aspect for the moment) trying to complete with a company that's got Uncle Sam gorilla on its back and in it's pockets. It causes all sorts of problems in the market place, in whatever industry you pick. You cause more trouble than you fix.
I don't have an answer other than let a fair market decide.