Re: 23.
Dude. Put down the crack pipe.
"I’m from the camp that he made better music than Van Hagar and Gay Halen.
He KNOWS what a good guitarist is supposed to sound like and he’s no dummy on the instrument himself."
Holy ****, I want what you're smoking.
While DLR was a showman, and a very good one, he was in no way "the band".
Musically, that is and will always be both the Van Halen brothers. Michael Anthony was an adequate bass player, but nothing special. He just happened to luck into a really good gig. Nothing wrong with that. However, both VH boys have innovated and affected the world of rock-and-roll (and influenced countless tens and perhaps hundreds of thousands) in immense ways. Eddie from the inception, then Alex, primarily starting with the 1984 album. He had flashes of greatness before...but it really hit hard with this album.
When they started, the producers of their initial work were crap. Drums/bass from one side, guitar the other, Overmic'ed and recorded too loud, the vocals were always the weakest part of VH. However, as mentioned before, DLR was a great showman, and did a great job as the front man.
However, when you think of VH, you think of Eddie and his guitar. F*cking period.
One thing that p*ssed off the band was DLR's insistance of having at least one reworked or cover song in every album. For creative guys like Eddie/Alex, this was a problem.
Once I heard Sammy would be joining the band, musically, I knew they would be better--because Sammy has the talent, not only with the singing chops (Dave can't sing anywhere close to Sammy), but he was a good guitar player as well (nowhere close to Eddie, but who is?), and....the man can write a song (lyrics). Half the time, I wondered what the hell Dave was trying to say; as well as having him blatantly steal from other songs (see Running with the Devil as well as others).
Re: 23 again....ARE YOU F*CKING SERIOUS? He made better music than VH?
Cough, cough, Bull****, cough.
He had Steve Vai and Billy Sheehan, arguably two of the top musicians for their instrument. But the songs they did were poppy and crap, mostly.
"Just like Paradise".....holy ****, what a f*cked up song that was.
Show me where he could play guitar even halfway decently. He does a great job on the steel drums that you referenced above.
But being good musically doesn't translate into a rockin' band, nor does it guarantee album sales. Although, VH + Sammy sold about as many albums in four records as VH + DLR did in six.
Having said all of that.........
One of my favorite songs from VH is "Take your Whiskey Home". Great music, the vocals fit, and the lyrics are tight.
My $.02.
fret