PurpleSageRighter
Thursday, April 7, 2005 3:16:00 PM
^

Charlie
Thursday, April 7, 2005 3:23:00 PM
Been smoking cigars for about 10 years, second time, as I smoked them in the Navy!

Favs in no particular order:

Brazila by CAO

Perdomo Reserves Rosados

Padrons

CAO's

AVO Maduros

Bucaneros

Joya de Nicaragua Anatanos

La Gloria Cubana Serie R

Partagas Black Labels

Ashtons

This list is a living list that changes from day to day!

Charlie

alaska_badger
Friday, April 8, 2005 4:03:00 PM
After about 6 months of sampling and such, I'd have to agree with others who say their tastes are changing (as with coffee, I generally like stronger cigars now than when I started... but not exclusively)

As of this point in the time-space continuum-thing:

(and in no particular order)

AVO Maduro #2

Montecristo #2 (ISOM)

Montecristo Cigar d'Artes belicoso (non-Cuban)

CAO Black

CAO Italia

Indian Tabac Super Fuerte

Gurkha XX Centurian

AF 858 SG

Cusano XClusivo

RP Vintage (both the '90 and '92)

Gurkha Expedition

and Habanos Torres Piramides, a locally blended and rolled cigar made in Mesa, Arizona by a personal friend, who is the son of a Cuban expat roller/blender.

badger

keitha13
Friday, April 8, 2005 5:20:00 PM
6 Years

1) K. Hansotia Signature

2) Rocky Patel Sungrown

3)Rocky Patel Vintage 92

4)Rocky Patel Vintage 90

5)Bauza

6)Opus X

7)Gurkha Regent

8)Arturo Fuente Chateu

9)Carlos Torano Exodus 1959 Gold

10)Gukha Expedition

keitha13
Wednesday, April 27, 2005 12:40:00 PM
Just bringing this to the top.

I think he forgot.

ASC
  • ASC
  • Aficionado
Wednesday, April 27, 2005 12:56:00 PM
Perhaps he got overwhelmed...

I was overwhelmed just reading over the vast variety of responses.

nwb
  • nwb
  • Aficionado Topic Starter
Wednesday, April 27, 2005 5:07:00 PM
Sorry, I didn't realize I hadn't posted the results. I did kind of get overwhelmed (plus I'm still receiving info). But here are the prelimary results.

My whole purpose for this survey was to see what kind of cigars people preferred, and if there was a correlatin between experience level and the type. The reason that this even came up - I was at a local and he said he couldn't sell a Nicaraguan cigar to save his life. I thought that kind of strange.

But the numbers don't really lie. On average, most new smokers prefer mild cigars (65%), mostly Dominicans. As smokers gain experience, their tastes evolved toward full-bodied cigars (50%). And those that had been smoking the longest preferred the lower range of full (don't have a %, but just an observation).

What I found the most interesting was the increase in the number of Nicaraguans people had in their top 10, especially in the top 5. I found that almost 50% of the people I surveyed had a Nic. in their top 10.

So why can't this local sell a Nic? After I thought about it, it really made sense. I live in a college town where most cigar smokers a relative new to the world of fine cigars. Thus, they tended toward mild Dominicans, especially Fuentes (I know, they aren't really that mild, but the name carries it far).

Now for my opinions. I love Nicaraguans...they are my favorites, even more so than Cubans. I lot of that has to do with consistency, but Nic. smokes are some of the most flavorful out there. And the stats seem to back me up on this, too.

Sorry about the delay in the results...been busy with the new job. And keep in mind this is by no means a perfect study. But I though it interesting.

Now, onto smoking my Padron 6000 maddie.

nwb

nwb
  • nwb
  • Aficionado Topic Starter
Wednesday, April 27, 2005 5:09:00 PM
Sorry about typos...its a long post.

nwb