Some of what I choose to use as a cutter is dictated by practicallity, i.e., a smaller ring gauge lends itself to a straigtht cut. With the larger ring gauges (50 - 60+) it's not so easy. Usually I use a punch pattern with the larger ones. I did use a v-cut fairly often with larger gauge cigars, but found that the tars that accumulated in the "v" area as I continued to smoke it really adversely impacted the taste. Now I stay mostly with a punch or the cigar scissors that unfolds with the Xikar cutter I have. Just my thoughts...............