chazbo
  • chazbo
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
10 years ago
Tamapatom, good write up🇨🇮
bgz
  • bgz
  • Herf-A-Holic
10 years ago

Interesting. Been a long time since I smoked one of those. Guess I gotta buy some more.

dharbolt wrote:



Ya, I try not to run out. Usually buy more when I start running low on them. Worth a box or 10 IMO.

shaun341
10 years ago
TampaTom package arrived today and since there was a humipak in the bag I decided to start right in.

Review on cigar #5

5x50 dark brown wrapper possible maduro or just light enough in color to be a dark natural. Triple cap and just a small blemish with a wrinkle right near it on the wrapper. Starts out with a strong bitter chocolate taste to it. Initial impressions is that it taste just like a young Le Bijou I once smoked. Just a few minutes in and I decide to do a retro and I pick up some cedar and just a touch of pepper from that. Knocked the ash off at 3/4 inch mark and burn line is pretty straight. Not much change in this cigar besides about midway the pepper picked up ever so slightly but it did always remain in the background and dropped back down shortly after. Towards the end the chocolate lost that bitterness for just a few minutes but then it came back. I would almost swear that this is a young Le Bijou but I know that it is not. Something is telling me that I have smoked one of these before but can't put my finger on what it is.

I could go a couple ways with this one as a local roll or midrange but I think I will go with midrange because it seems like with a little more rest this would be a good. Also if I were to guess on wrapper I would definitely think this is a mexican san andres maduro.
stinger88
10 years ago
Namadio, yours should go out Monday. Cigars and sauce picked, just need to get to the PO.
dharbolt
10 years ago

Ya, I try not to run out. Usually buy more when I start running low on them. Worth a box or 10 IMO.

bgz wrote:




I agree with you
delta1
10 years ago

Delta Force report

#1 Very firm dark with even darker splotches and a thick oily wrapper. Perfect construction. Closed foot. Triple cap, cant recall but maybe a pigtail. Extremely hard and firm. Some visible veins but gorgeous in a refined rustic sort of way. Great draw for such hard stick. Burn wavers a little but no touch up needed. This is an earthy smoke with a smooth edge. Builds up some pepper power. Meaty and thick feel with long finish. Woody notes of cedar? So cliche. Nice though. Lots of rich flavor. This is a powerhouse that keeps building till it knocks me on my azz. Medium/full to full. Very enjoyable and by the end I am convinced this may be the top shelf. However, it is a bit much for my tastes. I imagine those who go for fuller body would like this. I would easily smoke this again but not one I would stock my humidor with.

#2 This one I can tell is fire cured a mile away. So I took it on a walk in the woods. Odd that this was a very light wrapper. Ordinary construction. I have had several fire cured and I could not identify. Not a MUWAT. I have had a few Leccia Black but the campfire BBQ flavor always fades into the background after the fist few draws. Not this. It keeps pumping out that distinctive burnt wood flavor. Worked out nice as I walked through the swamp and I imagined it would be nice sitting around campfire. Not something that I would want very often but a nice little change. Very consistent, not very complex. When you dont have time to think about it, its doing its thing. So far if #3 does not fall short, this may be the yard gar. At least it seems so to me.

#3 Construction is good. Open foot. Maybe not a triple cap. Consistent medum brown wrapper. Firm with some very minor soft spots. No real identifiable aroma on prelight. Nice mild initial flavor and draw but burn starts out a little lopsided. My initial impression at this point is that the #1 will beat out this one for the top shelf position. As I continued, the burn corrected itself and something of a camphor or floral light sweetness could be identified. About a 1/2 inch in I picked up a spicy pepper that faded back to the other flavors. Not too strong but nice change up. The pepper would come back and fade out at several points and never overpowered. This was more creamy and smooth with no earthiness at all. A solid medium and it never lost its unique flavor. Reminds me of a Crowned Heads. It had a 2 1/2 inch perfect white ash before it dropped. Wow, I'm really enjoying this and will have to seek this out. This one is tbe top shelf in my book.

Hot sauce said Jalopenos so i poured it on. Came out like battery acid. Burn baby burn. Destroyed my taste buds. Good stuff.

tamapatom wrote:




#1 - HR/Hirochi Robaina, top shelf

#2 - you nailed it, Leccia Black, yard gar that hits the spot when you want some barbecue

#3 - El Centurion, latest version, medium tier in price but great bang for buck smoke.

Nice reviews, tamapatom. Well done!
tamapatom
10 years ago

#1 - HR/Hirochi Robaina, top shelf

#2 - you nailed it, Leccia Black, yard gar that hits the spot when you want some barbecue

#3 - El Centurion, latest version, medium tier in price but great bang for buck smoke.

Nice reviews, tamapatom. Well done!

delta1 wrote:


Never had an HR, but knew it was a great cigar even though not exactly in my wheelhouse. Thought the second one could only be Leccia but the persistent fire cured flavor threw me a little. I think it mellows out with some humidor time from my experience. The last one is a treat because i would never have stumbled on this one even though i like My Father. Happy to know its an affordable stick.
tamapatom
10 years ago

TampaTom package arrived today and since there was a humipak in the bag I decided to start right in.

Review on cigar #5

5x50 dark brown wrapper possible maduro or just light enough in color to be a dark natural. Triple cap and just a small blemish with a wrinkle right near it on the wrapper. Starts out with a strong bitter chocolate taste to it. Initial impressions is that it taste just like a young Le Bijou I once smoked. Just a few minutes in and I decide to do a retro and I pick up some cedar and just a touch of pepper from that. Knocked the ash off at 3/4 inch mark and burn line is pretty straight. Not much change in this cigar besides about midway the pepper picked up ever so slightly but it did always remain in the background and dropped back down shortly after. Towards the end the chocolate lost that bitterness for just a few minutes but then it came back. I would almost swear that this is a young Le Bijou but I know that it is not. Something is telling me that I have smoked one of these before but can't put my finger on what it is.

I could go a couple ways with this one as a local roll or midrange but I think I will go with midrange because it seems like with a little more rest this would be a good. Also if I were to guess on wrapper I would definitely think this is a mexican san andres maduro.

shaun341 wrote:


Hmmmmm........This game is getting interesting.......not going to give you any answers till you are done. BTW, it's just a maduro wrap, don't think it's San Andrean. I will have to check but pretty sure tobaccos in this are either Honduran, Nicaraguan, Ecudoran or some combination.
danmdevries
10 years ago
Centurion is a good smoke
bgz
  • bgz
  • Herf-A-Holic
10 years ago
Got Shaun's package, the 3 blind smokes, a couple very nice stragglers and a bottle of Hank Sauce that I look forward to trying later.

Probably let the smokes rest for a few days before I do a review.

Thanks Shaun!
namadio
10 years ago

Namadio, yours should go out Monday. Cigars and sauce picked, just need to get to the PO.

stinger88 wrote:



Hoping I can get to the PO this week. If not during the week definitely by Saturday!
dharbolt
10 years ago
Smoking #2 from bgz

Another box pressed robutso. Firm with a fairly loose draw nice smooth medium brown wrapper with minimal veins. Pre draw is of grass (barnyard) and pepper.

First couple puffs are light and airy with a nice creamyness and some pepper on the retro, though a bit of a bitter finish.

Into the first third the creamyness faded and was replaced with a peppery leather with a floral spicyness on the retro. Burn is perfect ash holding strong at about an inch.

At the half the leather and floral flavors have faded into leather and sweet tobacco. burn is still perfect and the body is building to a solid medium, med/full. draw is still a little loose but the vsu is a metric ****ton ash held on to about 1.5 inches

Into the final third the pepper and leather gave way to baking spices, graham crackers and an occasional licorice. floral hint returned to the retro. body never made it past medium or so. overall a really good smoke, I nubbed it untill i burned myself.

perfect burn throughout, really good construction though a bit loose, pretty fantastic flavor changes. I would have to say this is a top shelf smoke. If not I have found a new daily for sure 🙂

Thanks Ben for another really good smoke. We seem to share a similar taste. What was it?
bgz
  • bgz
  • Herf-A-Holic
10 years ago
Unfortunately you didn't find a new daily.

That was the top shelf, a Padron Family Reserve 85 year.

Glad you enjoyed it, and that was a great review!
bgz
  • bgz
  • Herf-A-Holic
10 years ago
Tried the "Hanks Sauce" hot sauce that Shaun sent on my standard for trying out new hot sauces... chips and cheese.

The sauce wasn't very spicy hot, but it did have a lot of flavor.

I don't think it will be a goto for chips and cheese, but I do think it would be good on a wide variety of other foods.

I can see doing something creative with it for one of those experimental steak rubs or something. I definitely think it would be excellent on an omelette or other type of breakfast scramble.

Some tasty stuff for sure.
danmdevries
10 years ago
Loving the reviews. Keep em coming
shaun341
10 years ago
Glad you enjoyed the hot sauce bgz, they have other flavors of hot sauce but that one is one of my favorites that the make.
chazbo
  • chazbo
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
10 years ago
Smoked #2 from dharbolt
Appearance; 5.5 x 44
Light color wrapper, smooth and triple cap. Very lite in the hand but firm with no soft spots.
Straight cut paired with H2O
First third of cigar needed minor touch up. Easy draw with a drier smoke.
Mild beginning. Flavor pretty much started out with hints of cedar and continued throughout.
Strength built up to medium by the half way mark.
After 50 minutes down to the final 1/4 of the cigar and started to get a little bitter.
Not bad for a morning smoke. My guess is Room101 Connecticut by Camacho.
bgz
  • bgz
  • Herf-A-Holic
10 years ago
Figured what the hell, 1 day is enough, lol.

Decided to smoke #3 from Shaun.

Had a nice medium brown wrapper on it, appeared to have a triple cap. It was a little veiny, the construction over all was pretty good, had a few soft spots in it.

Honestly, I was expecting this one to be the yard gar, as all 3 appeared to have pretty good construction.

I wasn't able to really catch much off the pre-light draw (I probably just don't pay attention to it a whole lot usually).

Anyway, right out of the gate, got a pretty big pepper blast. From the get go, I was thinking Nicaraguan. Had some burn issues in the first third, but the ash held incredibly long to about 2 inches. Finally tapped it for fear of it falling over me, it could have probably held on for a few more puffs. Got some notes of grahm cracker in there, but it maintained the pepper throughout the first 3rd.

After I tapped the ash, the pepper subsided, and mellowed out a bit to probably just a little north of medium. I kind of zone out and forgot to make any specific notes during the second third... my bad.

Going in to the end of the smoke, it ended up with a little sweeter profile for a little bit, then returned to spicy peppery towards the nub.

I enjoyed the smoke, It definitely had a very familiar profile, but when it doesn't have a label on it, it's very hard to put a brand to it.

Anyway, really enjoyed the flavor, but due to having to touch it up a few times, and some soft spots in the cigar... I'm going to have to guess this was the mid-range smoke. Like I said in the beginning, I thought it was Nicaraguan, though there were a couple points where I thought I caught some Dominican notes, but in the end, I was thinking Nicaraguan again (possible a mix blend I guess).

I compared it to some of the cigars I have with a similar wrapper color, pretty much came up empty in the attempt (I know, it's kind of cheating :)

So I'm curious, what was that smoke?
bgz
  • bgz
  • Herf-A-Holic
10 years ago
Oh, if I remember right, it was a robusto.
shaun341
10 years ago

Figured what the hell, 1 day is enough, lol.

Decided to smoke #3 from Shaun.

Had a nice medium brown wrapper on it, appeared to have a triple cap. It was a little veiny, the construction over all was pretty good, had a few soft spots in it.

Honestly, I was expecting this one to be the yard gar, as all 3 appeared to have pretty good construction.

I wasn't able to really catch much off the pre-light draw (I probably just don't pay attention to it a whole lot usually).

Anyway, right out of the gate, got a pretty big pepper blast. From the get go, I was thinking Nicaraguan. Had some burn issues in the first third, but the ash held incredibly long to about 2 inches. Finally tapped it for fear of it falling over me, it could have probably held on for a few more puffs. Got some notes of grahm cracker in there, but it maintained the pepper throughout the first 3rd.

After I tapped the ash, the pepper subsided, and mellowed out a bit to probably just a little north of medium. I kind of zone out and forgot to make any specific notes during the second third... my bad.

Going in to the end of the smoke, it ended up with a little sweeter profile for a little bit, then returned to spicy peppery towards the nub.

I enjoyed the smoke, It definitely had a very familiar profile, but when it doesn't have a label on it, it's very hard to put a brand to it.

Anyway, really enjoyed the flavor, but due to having to touch it up a few times, and some soft spots in the cigar... I'm going to have to guess this was the mid-range smoke. Like I said in the beginning, I thought it was Nicaraguan, though there were a couple points where I thought I caught some Dominican notes, but in the end, I was thinking Nicaraguan again (possible a mix blend I guess).

I compared it to some of the cigars I have with a similar wrapper color, pretty much came up empty in the attempt (I know, it's kind of cheating :)

So I'm curious, what was that smoke?

bgz wrote:




#3 was the top shelf smoke a Don Carlos Personal Reserve. I have only smoked 1 so far out of the box and I can't remember if I had a problem touching them up but I had a very similar experience taste wise as you.
Users browsing this topic