Results of a blind tasting I participated in on another site recently. These were all 5 1/8X42 PCs. There are 16 possible PC offerings currently available and I have had maybe 5-6 since this is not a vitola I smoke regularly. Each of 12 BOTL taking part made a short review and posted their guess for the 5 cigars:

A. HDM Coronation - my guess: RyJ Mille Fluers
B. H Upmann PC - my guess: Bolivar PC
C. RyJ Cedros #3 - my guess: HUPC (this was my favorite cigar of the five)
D. H Upmann Regalias - my guess: Rafeal Gonzales PC
E. Sancho Panza Non Plus - My guess: JLPC

Pretty embarrassing, but out of the 60 guesses there were only 3 who got the maker correct and none who actually guessed the exact cigar.

If you get a chance to do one of these, give it a shot, it's a lot of fun. You will learn something about your tastes.

DED

deadeyedick wrote:

So the moral of the story is just buy whatever is on sale?

euodias wrote:

The moral is find a profile you like and hope that a few of the cigars in the next box are similar.

deadeyedick wrote:

The moral is find a profile you like and hope that a few of the cigars in the next box are similar.

deadeyedick wrote:

The moral is find a profile you like and hope that a few of the cigars in the next box are similar.

deadeyedick wrote: