Did it live up to the hype?

shaun341 wrote:

Not sure about Jamie's opinion but I'd say yes......HELL YES!!! A great bottle of rye for $20...….not many of them out there like that.I drank some $80 rye that I thought was mediocre at best,Whistlepig.So even $40 for the OF would be a good deal.

I just picked up 2 more bottles last week...….so yea I like it....a lot

Whistlebritches wrote:

OGD 114 with (...I know Ron’s gonna cringe...) an ice sphere [gonzo]

At least it wasn’t with crushed ice! #-o

Palama wrote:

Henry McKenna BIB 10

Palama wrote:

Thoughts?

dkeage wrote:

Initially tried it neat and has a unique / different taste that I can’t put a finger on. Dropped a sphere in but it was still there. Fo’ I’m gonna need a couple more shots to come to some kind of conclusion but at this point in time, don’t think I would rush out to buy more. But, like anything subjective, ymmv.

Palama wrote:

Weller 12.

Speyside wrote: