Palama
6 years ago
^^^ Oh gosh, just feedin’ da Wombat 🤦 ^^^
Cigarlady7
6 years ago

How about sticking with the way it is, set up by the original poster.
Post your puts & takes yet?

kombat96 wrote:



How about sitting back and minding your business (once again) , unless your name is Stinger.

If you don't see any takes/puts listed.. That means I have not completed yet. I figured for someone to hate noops so much, you would at least be able to read. Even the playing field a little.
Cigarlady7
6 years ago
Takes:

Viaje TNT
Tatuaje TAA 14
Tatuaje Verite
Tatuaje T110
Ashton VSG

Puts:
Warped Corto
MF Le Bijou
A Fuente Don Carlos
Foundation Wise Man El Güegüense
Padron Anniversary 1964

Stinger, did you add an Ashton VSG?? I don't remember taking it out of stash and it wasn't listed on the original list. Somehow I ended up with one in the humi, so I assumed it was from this pass or another one I have done somewhere else. Anyways, IF that one was apart of this pass, that will also be a keep. Will be replacing with a Padron 64.
stinger88
6 years ago
There was an Ashton in there. I don’t have my original on me. Can check when I get home.
Cigarlady7
6 years ago

There was an Ashton in there. I don’t have my original on me. Can check when I get home.

stinger88 wrote:



Ok, so I revised list.

Box to next person today.
Palama
6 years ago

Ok, so I revised list.

Box to next person today.

Cigarlady7 wrote:



Your changes were approved by David? 🤔
Cigarlady7
6 years ago
David, tried to inbox you back. It won't go through. Your messages were full
kombat96
6 years ago

Takes:

Viaje TNT
Tatuaje TAA 14
Tatuaje Verite
Tatuaje T110
Ashton VSG

Puts:
Warped Corto
MF Le Bijou
A Fuente Don Carlos
Foundation Wise Man El Güegüense
Padron Anniversary 1964

Stinger, did you add an Ashton VSG?? I don't remember taking it out of stash and it wasn't listed on the original list. Somehow I ended up with one in the humi, so I assumed it was from this pass or another one I have done somewhere else. Anyways, IF that one was apart of this pass, that will also be a keep. Will be replacing with a Padron 64.

Cigarlady7 wrote:





This pass is our business. And that is definitely not a fair exchange. I think you noops need to do some google research on these cigars you are taking and what is considered elitist. Sorry Dave if I over step my boundaries, it is your pass, but this was my fear with the noops. Not bashing them, just they are still way green.
Cigarlady7
6 years ago
Cigarlady7
6 years ago
Apparently if he doesn't agree, he will let me know as to which ones. Not worried about other opinions guys.
stinger88
6 years ago
Bee,

The proposed takes/puts are pretty lopsided.

Warped Corto ..... sub $10 cigar
MF maybe $10
Don Carlos sub $10
Foundation maybe $10


Tat T110:::very rare cigar, probably not many around anymore, definitely not for sale at your local B&M
Tat TAA 2014:::limited production, won’t find any for sale
Tat Verite 2013::: limited production, might find a couple out there.
Viaje TNT 2010:::: only 3750 made that year. Have been rereleased but this is an OR.

The Padron 64 and the Ashton are relatively close.

So, either have another go at takes/ puts or do the PAM vs Ashton switchroo and enjoy the one I sent along too.

I have cleared out my messages if you want to bounce a few things around to me.

David
stinger88
6 years ago

This pass is our business. And that is definitely not a fair exchange. I think you noops need to do some google research on these cigars you are taking and what is considered elitist. Sorry Dave if I over step my boundaries, it is your pass, but this was my fear with the noops. Not bashing them, just they are still way green.

kombat96 wrote:




All good. I am not an expert on all cigars so it is nice having backup. And I agree whole-heartedly. All the participants have a say...ultimately, I will give the thumbs up or thumbs down but I do want people to voice their concerns. Publicly (if done constructively) or private.

David
Cigarlady7
6 years ago

Bee,

The proposed takes/puts are pretty lopsided.

Warped Corto ..... sub $10 cigar
MF maybe $10
Don Carlos sub $10
Foundation maybe $10


Tat T110:::very rare cigar, probably not many around anymore, definitely not for sale at your local B&M
Tat TAA 2014:::limited production, won’t find any for sale
Tat Verite 2013::: limited production, might find a couple out there.
Viaje TNT 2010:::: only 3750 made that year. Have been rereleased but this is an OR.

The Padron 64 and the Ashton are relatively close.

So, either have another go at takes/ puts or do the PAM vs Ashton switchroo and enjoy the one I sent along too.

I have cleared out my messages if you want to bounce a few things around to me.

David

stinger88 wrote:



David,

Ok. I have plenty, just throwing some out there at first.

Revise:

Padron 64
A Fuente Flor Fina Rosado 858
A Fuente Reserve Extra Viejo (Anejo 888)
A Fuente Don Carlos Eye of the Shark
Davidoff Late Hour
stinger88
6 years ago
Ok, here goes.

PAM vs Ashton ....good to go.
I would say the Davidoff(don’t know much about the cigar but the price point) could cut it for the Tat Verite.
If the 888 is from 2014/15 then that could work for the Viaje.

The T110 and the 2014 TAA are out of the league of the others.

Input from the peanut gallery is appreciated.

I would err to the side of overkill when looking to take/put. This pass should have you looking at those special cigars that you have and figuring out which ones you might want some other BOTL to enjoy ( because they would never be able to find one on their own at a B&M). Rule of thumb, if you can buy them at your local or order them from a big online company, they probably don’t belong in this pass.
Cigarlady7
6 years ago
Will revise again tonight when I get home. I have other limited releases to throw in.

stinger88
6 years ago
Sounds good.
Cigarlady7
6 years ago
Eye of shark is a limited one. They are available in some cases, but are limited in stock.

I do have Viaje Ghost Pepper, which is rare and hard to find... If you find them at all right now. Maybe that could work for one of them.

I don't mind putting the two Tatuaje back either and going with what we have so far. I was more interested in just the Ashton and Viaje but tried to choose 5, to make it worth the pass.

I'm content with the other ones, if that works.
stinger88
6 years ago
I am comfortable with the Tats going back in. Pretty sure there a couple folks on here hoping they will make it to them.



ClintCigar, after seeing the takes and puts, are you able to meet the requirements? I know you are new on here and I am not sure what your stockpile capabilities are. If you can’t hang, no problem. Just don’t want cigarlady to send to you if you can’t meet the box pass expectations.

David
stinger88
6 years ago
CL, forgot...did you respond to if the 888 is from 14/15 or is it a new one?
Users browsing this topic