izonfire
6 years ago

How similar or dissimilar is Ezra Brooks compared to Jack Daniels?

8trackdisco wrote:


Ezra has more of the sour mash flavor, not unlike Jim Beam, but with superior flavor.
BTW - Jim Beam Black is a remarkable emulation of JD. But that oak and maple charcoal flavor has been taken for granted by some. The ubiquitous state of the art from back in the day is now the shunned bastid stepchild.

Or maybe you can taste without any preconceptions...
Palama
6 years ago
Jim Beam Distiller’s Cut
USNGunner
6 years ago
Old Grand-Dad 114.
8trackdisco
6 years ago

Ezra has more of the sour mash flavor, not unlike Jim Beam, but with superior flavor.
BTW - Jim Beam Black is a remarkable emulation of JD. But that oak and maple charcoal flavor has been taken for granted by some. The ubiquitous state of the art from back in the day is now the shunned bastid stepchild.

Or maybe you can taste without any preconceptions...

izonfire wrote:



I don't taste any similarity between JBB & JD. Smoky tastes a lot different than burnt.
Whistlebritches
6 years ago

I don't taste any similarity between JBB & JD. Smoky tastes a lot different than burnt.

8trackdisco wrote:




Myself either......JBB is a nice value bourbon that meets all my requirements as a decent sipper.

JD has only one redeeming quality...…..if you like how it went down it taste exactly the same coming up.Although the burnt charcoal flavor does enhance the stomach bile to some degree.

BTW almost all if not all bourbon is made with sour mash.Sour mash just means that the mash from a previous batch, which still has live yeast, is added to the current one to start the fermentation process. Using the sour mash from a previous batch helps with consistency and prevents bacteria growth that could taint the bourbon.
MACS
6 years ago
A coworker got me a box set bottle of JD and a frosted JD glass.

I don't drink JD, I don't like JD... but the gesture was awesome and the glass is nice.
Palama
6 years ago

A coworker got me a box set bottle of JD and a frosted JD glass.

I don't drink JD, I don't like JD... but the gesture was awesome and the glass is nice.

MACS wrote:



+1

A couple years ago, I gave a co-worker who loves Jack and Coke, a JD tin that I bought back in the ‘70s or ‘80s and a green label bottle plus a couple of black label miniatures. He was SO happy! I was glad to clear some space as well as make someone’s day. 🍺
Whistlebritches
6 years ago

+1

A couple years ago, I gave a co-worker who loves Jack and Coke, a JD tin that I bought back in the ‘70s or ‘80s and a green label bottle plus a couple of black label miniatures. He was SO happy! I was glad to clear some space as well as make someone’s day. 🍺

Palama wrote:




Friends do not give JD to friends...…….unless said friends have the palate of a billy goat,then eze ok
Plowboy221
6 years ago
Bulleit (Was on clearance at a local grocery store for 14 bucks a bottle)
Palama
6 years ago

Friends do not give JD to friends...…….unless said friends have the palate of a billy goat,then eze ok

Whistlebritches wrote:



Well, “...Jack and Coke...” should tip you off. 🤦
Whistlebritches
6 years ago

Well, “...Jack and Coke...” should tip you off. 🤦

Palama wrote:




Yes I never got that.....if ya gotta mix it it's probably rotgut.Just like all those Corona beer drinkers that have to have their lime to disguise the ass taste.
USNGunner
6 years ago

Yes I never got that.....if ya gotta mix it it's probably rotgut.Just like all those Corona beer drinkers that have to have their lime to disguise the ass taste.

Whistlebritches wrote:



Or coffee. I get a coffe and they ask, "Would you like flavoring in that?"

"Why? Is it bad coffee?"[frypan]
MACS
6 years ago
Aberlour 16... of course.
Whistlebritches
6 years ago

Or coffee. I get a coffe and they ask, "Would you like flavoring in that?"

"Why? Is it bad coffee?"[frypan]

USNGunner wrote:




Ditto...….Black and bitter just like we drank it in the Navy
Whistlebritches
6 years ago
Old Forester Statesman
MACS
6 years ago

Ditto...….Black and bitter just like we drank it in the Navy

Whistlebritches wrote:



We? Fk that sh*t. I drank mine with cream and sugar. Could still stand a spoon in it.

I drink it black now, but it's better coffee and it's pressed.

(and I'm intermittent fasting and I can't use my favorite creamer)
Whistlebritches
6 years ago

We? Fk that sh*t. I drank mine with cream and sugar. Could still stand a spoon in it.

I drink it black now, but it's better coffee and it's pressed.

(and I'm intermittent fasting and I can't use my favorite creamer)

MACS wrote:




I learned to drink coffee from Chief Dix...…….if you even reached for sugar or creamer he might bite your arm off.I never gave it a second thought,I like my arm.Plus the respect I had for that man was second only to my Grandfather.
terrance.ski
6 years ago
Of the 3 Islays I sampled this weekend - Lagavulin 8 (sipping on a glass of it now) pleased my pallet the most - MACS (or anyone who has experience on the subject) what would you say the difference is between an 8 year and 16 year? Does the 16 mellow/smooth out? My thinking is to work through these 3 before moving up on the Islay shelf - at this point 16 year would likely be wasted on me. 🙂
MACS
6 years ago
Laphroiag 10 was horrible to me. 15 was pretty damn good.

Never tried anything other than Lagavulin 16, so I am no help there... but I liked the 16 better than the Laphroiag 15.

Taste is subjective, bro. You may not like what I like... but since I am not a big fan of the Islays, and I really like the Lagavulin 16... it stands to reason you will like it.
8trackdisco
6 years ago

Myself either......JBB is a nice value bourbon that meets all my requirements as a decent sipper.

JD has only one redeeming quality...…..if you like how it went down it taste exactly the same coming up.Although the burnt charcoal flavor does enhance the stomach bile to some degree.

BTW almost all if not all bourbon is made with sour mash.Sour mash just means that the mash from a previous batch, which still has live yeast, is added to the current one to start the fermentation process. Using the sour mash from a previous batch helps with consistency and prevents bacteria growth that could taint the bourbon.

Whistlebritches wrote:



Thank you for the sour mash education.
Users browsing this topic