MACS
Friday, August 5, 2005 7:44:00 AM
The question is really: Would you lie to save your own skin?

The answer for an overwhelming majority of us (if we're truthful with ourselves) is Hell yes!

1) Honey have you been cheating?

A: How could you even ask me that darling?

2) Sir, I clocked you at 88 in a 65 zone...

A: I was going along with the flow of traffic, officer...

3) Did you take steroids Mr. Palmeiro?

A: I have never... EVER... taken steroids in my life!

4) Do these pants make me look fat?

A: Not at all dear, not at all, you look beautiful.

5) Ewwwww... Was that you honey?

A: No, it must have been the dog.

MACS
Friday, August 5, 2005 7:45:00 AM
Oh, I almost forgot...

6) Did you have sexual relations with Ms. Lewinski, Mr. President?

A: I did NOT have sexual relations with that woman...

Buckwheat
Friday, August 5, 2005 7:54:00 AM
Yes, it is 1000% true that attorneys (at least the ones that I know) have very thick skin and take and give jabs at their profession. Just as the doctors, teachers, bus drivers, etc...that I know, do. It still doesn't mean that they don't take their profession or the defense of their client’s seriously. Judges rule the roost in the courts and they would slap a contempt of court on any attorney who blatantly lied in their court (particularly if they lied to the judge). JM2c's

Also, it is not what you swear on that makes it an oath; it is that you swear in a court of law. Legally, the court could care less what book it is (from a legal sense). Also, JM2c's.

RICKAMAVEN
Friday, August 5, 2005 8:33:00 AM
Buckwheat

yep. it is just a symbol.

8trackdisco
Friday, August 5, 2005 6:58:00 PM
'Judges rule the roost in the courts and they would slap a contempt of court on any attorney who blatantly lied in their court'

Buckwheat, that is part of my point. The word "blatantly" had to be thrown in as a qualifier.

How about a contempt charge for lying, Period? If he was sworn to tell the whole truth, you'd think that would preclude him from lying at all. Wouldn't that be better?

I don't want to get into some big thing in "Truth" and what truth is etc. etc.- I'm not that smart to play the role of a Greek Philosopher.

Neither side cares about the truth. Prosecutors prossecute, defenders defend. It seems like an inherent flaw in the system.

Ok, I'm with most of you with the 'provide the holy book of your choice' idea. But what do you do for Agnostics and Athiests? Make them swear on... nothing?

IMHO, this all started when the "it all depends on what the definition of 'is' is."

Tank- if they asked the guy to swear to tell the truth, and he says 'no', isn't he actually telling the truth and would therefore be more likely to be truthful, because he just gave an honest answer?

(I think I'm getting dizzy).

Mrs.Tank
Friday, August 5, 2005 7:15:00 PM
tank does that to people. I think he plans it that way.
8trackdisco
Friday, August 5, 2005 7:46:00 PM
Thanks Mrs. Tank, I thought it was all the smoke from his RP Edges.

;)

jimbarr
Friday, August 5, 2005 8:17:00 PM
I don't think many court rooms make you put your hand on the bible any more. That's gonzo these days. You do swear, therby incurring the penalty for lying - but no bible. Hey, here's a tidbit: One of the most famous people recently convicted of Purgery, at least in recent memory? Mark Furman - for saying he never uttered the n word. A felony. No firearms license, no police officer. Purgery matters - unless your last name is Clinton.
MACS
Friday, August 5, 2005 8:59:00 PM
Military Oath... I swear or AFFIRM... meaning you are giving your word, as a human being... that you will tell the truth.

I am a responsible person. If I tell you IO am going to pay the fuggin' mortgage... put the money in the bank... because it'll be there when I said it would.

A man has 2 things in this world... he has his word and he has his balls.

I don't break either of them for ANYONE.

MACS
Friday, August 5, 2005 9:01:00 PM
Yeah... I was paraphrasing some friggin' movie... I can't recall which, but the gist is quite accurate.
adroomi
Friday, August 5, 2005 9:31:00 PM
I think it was Rick in Casablanca, when he said, "I stick my neck out of nobody!"
adroomi
Friday, August 5, 2005 9:31:00 PM
....and FOR anybody as well!