jpkulp
5 years ago
AND THE REVEAL!

My Guesses
Rocky Patel ITC Bison Pyramid - Yard Gar
Brick House Maduro Mighty Mighty - Mid-range
Esteban Carreras Chupa Cabra - Premium

Actual Cigars (I believe this is the order)
Rocky Patel ITC Bison Pyramid - Yard Gar
Mark Twain Memoir - Mid-range
Victor Sinclair 15th Anniversary Bohemian - Premium

This was a lot of fun! I really enjoyed trying to figure out the order and guessing the sticks.
Thanks to Stinger for setting up and Smooth for sending me cigar.
Sunoverbeach
5 years ago
Wait a sec. You got all three ranges correct and the yard gar dead on? You're setting the bar awfully high here

Excellent work, JP =d>
ZRX1200
5 years ago
I’m concerned and confused that Victor Sinclair and “premium” were in the same sentence......
chazbo
5 years ago

I’m concerned and confused that Victor Sinclair and “premium” were in the same sentence......

ZRX1200 wrote:


Maybe a Victor after 15 years become smokable😜
jpkulp
5 years ago
Yeah, I not 100% on the ranges... the Mark Twain and Sinclair are pretty close if you go by actual sale price.

Smooth Light, what as the intended order?
jpkulp
5 years ago
Taste wise I definitely preferred the V. Sinclair tho! It was pretty d@mn good!
gummy jones
5 years ago
VS precuts are divine
stinger88
5 years ago

AND THE REVEAL!

Actual Cigars (I believe this is the order)
Rocky Patel ITC Bison Pyramid - Yard Gar
Mark Twain Memoir - Mid-range
Victor Sinclair 15th Anniversary Bohemian - Premium

jpkulp wrote:



Not sure how I would classify these either.
Smooth light
5 years ago
Excellent! JPKULP... the beach ones, are big cause they tell me it's time to leave, you had enough sun 😎🌞

Bohemian aged at least other 5+yrs, plus you don't have to use a cutter just twist the tail off.

The smaller ones just don't hold-up, always make me chain smoke. Plus
Makes me drink to much, the 35+yards to the house a challenge.

MARK TWAIN - the rest of their line smoke hot. Aged at least a year,#3(6.2-64)

PYRAMIDS - just like watching the shadows growing across the fields on GONZO FRIDAY.


Pettyfogger... are just cool, glad you liked it.
stinger88
5 years ago
jpkulp...great reviews.
ZRX1200
5 years ago
I agree nice reviews, was t throwing shade but reading and following rules makes or breaks a pass/blind review thread. Most 🌫 s don’t like problems and don’t like guys getting reps they don’t deserve. Everyone involved in this is in good standing AFAIK and I sure like to see it stay that way. Just remember sometimes guys being deeks isn’t to get someone to go away it’s to get them to STAY. Hope that clears my comment up.
jpkulp
5 years ago
Stinger - your inbox is full, can't PM until it's cleared out.
stinger88
5 years ago
Sorry about that. Cleared.
stinger88
5 years ago
ZRX....well said.
Jakethesnake86
5 years ago
Gummy I’m gonna burn number B tonight sir. I really enjoyed A. Reviews to come. I wrote my first one. Initial guess. Mid grade. I’ve gotta smoke the other two to come to a final thought
I’m the snake
gummy jones
5 years ago
LeeBot
5 years ago
And I mean to add that opel's review was pretty awesome. Laughed my @ss off.
Jakethesnake86
5 years ago
Cigar A
Thick cap at least a double cap might be a triple .
Pretty sloppy roll job , lots of veins couple thick ones packed good and tight

Cold draw perfect kinda sweet
1st lil black pepper on the half retro
Solid medium smooth pepper. As I’m not a pepper bomb.
At 1/2 inch burn is wonky so I set it in the ashtray to allow it to recover.
This works this time. now we have a slight cream and a leather with a nice ash
Touch of sweetness together with the rest now.
2nd cigar is smoking and burning perfect now
Flavors are pretty leathery now with the semi sweet cream coming and going. Still medium but seems to be building
Finish has become longer with more flavor subtitles than body
The ash has to be broken off it hangs on tough
3rd
After ashing the cigar tastes like bbq like if you ever smoked meat with real wood. After a quick touch up the nicotine seems to be building up.
1 1/2 left. I usually throw them out before this but this smoke is above average with interesting flavors
Not sweet like Honduran or even Dominican. Not what I think of when I think Nicaragua. Flavor of its own.

Initial guess. Mid range Cuban. Only mark against it is construction. Smoked pearl tasted great. Never had a Cuban to compare with but I may have smoked my first one. That said I have no idea name or manufacturer

That’s my guess.

50 minute burn time on a 4 1/2 by about 48 ish smoke

I’m the snake
Jakethesnake86
5 years ago
Cigar b
6x 45
Double cap pretty confident on that. Super tight seams nice tight pack. Perfect construction. Flawless

Preflight draw. Perfect

1st chcholate black pepper harsh pepper on the very beginning
A lot of cigars I tend to really enjoy start this way. Reminds me of a master blend 3. Sweetness comes in almost immediately
If it matters at all this ash is very white. Somewhere between smooth and harsh at this point. 1/4 inch in. Waaay more smoke than average. This reminds me of a drew estates more than a master blend at this point. It’s also round so not a master blend
1/2 in. Medium plus on both flavor and body

2nd a touch of nuttiness has stepped in Faint wood Pepper is gone
So far this is a superior roll job though I enjoyed the flavors of number A more
Stick is mellowing down to a standard medium
I enjoyed the first third much more at this point
This cigar will not need any burn corrections. Sharp as a razor blade
Flavors are leather and a hint of black pepper. With a long retro you’ll find the hint of pepper at the end

3rd
Nothing new to report medium on the button all around.
She fell flat on me
As a rule cigars tend to build in strength and body even finish. This one has done the polar opposite

Enjoyed this cigar
Initial guess
Dominican Super white ash. Semi sweet.
I think it’s a house blend Dominican.
Burned 1 hour 10 minutes
I’m the snake
gummy jones
5 years ago
Nice reviews
Users browsing this topic