J.Redleg,
I find your comments to be a bit ironic. On one hand, you blast retailers for setting their prices higher than MSRP, claiming it's gouging. On the other hand, you indicate that it's perfectly okay when the high prices on auctions for the same cigars on CBID go sky high. The auction prices on CBID for FFOX and Anejo ALWAYS go well above MSRP. Clearly, the "Market Price" for these cigars isn't MSRP, but rather much higher.
I've seen a few retailers take this to the extreme, (one in Dallas had all the hard to find Fuente's in stock, including BTL, Anejo, etc, for $40++, but he probably didn't have an Opus X account) and I too resent those establishments, but aren't most of them accomplishing effectively what CBID is doing? They're charging as much as the market will bear, except that with CBID, the mechanism is much more direct.
While I can't blame the retailers for making as much profit as they can, I won't necessarily give them my business either. There's a shop in Austin, TX that has had Anejo's in on a couple of occasions during the past year. I was thrilled to pick up #77s for $12 each, and 55s for $10, but you could only buy one of each per person per day. They could have made more money from me or someone else on those two cigars, but you can be sure I'll go out of my way to give them my business for other cigar purchases, all other things being equal.
Elrico