alr829
  • alr829
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Tuesday, October 11, 2005 5:45:00 AM
Thanks for all the replys on my question---it looks like a few took the original question a bit personal,as if someone was to challange thier choice of cigars--the reason is that i was gifted a unbanded cigar to try,after the smoke i was asked what i thought of construction and taste, to my suprise i was told it was a machine made---i found it very tasty but with a draw a little loose---so i wondered what a blind test would show----that,s all---
John hay Cigars
Tuesday, October 11, 2005 8:27:00 AM
You still have me thinking about this one. I'm going to have to see if I can set this up. It's a shame I didn't do it while I was in the factory yesterday.
Steve*R
Tuesday, October 11, 2005 8:40:00 AM
CWFoster wrote:"First, in order to get the filler packed right, either short filler, or a mixed filler is used, so dont expect them to hold an ash like a good handmade."

Sorry, CW, but there are very sophisticated machines today that can roll beautiful long filler cigars. Try a Cuban Fonseca Delicia. Only the wrapper is applied by hand and that's so they can be labeled hecho e mano.

CW also wrote:"Second, they aren't rolled as tight, as the machine can't adjust the tension or flick out some tobacco if it seems like it's going to be too tight."

Sorry, but that's not true either. The machine can be calibrated for a very specific compression factor. Mechanical draw testers then examine for optimum roll compression.

Friends, we live in a very high-tech age. Automobiles are built via robotic automation so that tolerances are kept within very defined parameters. Certainly, cigars can be rolled by machine just as consistently, if not more consistently, than torcedors.

Hand rolled=tradition. There's a certain beauty in the variances of a hand made product.

John hay Cigars
Tuesday, October 11, 2005 11:26:00 AM
Just like home made soup or Campbells?????

Home made has a lot of variences.