I love this thread. I am a chem major myself and learning about chemistry is fun for me. I love cigars and I store many cigars. I appreciate the post that both of you gave (Qrash and HKguns). I am not going to give you any chemistry but I will tell you from experiences that I have had with cigars. You should never exceed 72 degrees F. This will bring out the famous tobacco beetle. Tobacco is filled with eggs and they will hatch if you get them too warm. I also believe in the slow aging method which I like to keep my cigars around 60 F and 68% humidity. I have never had any swelling or cracking at this level. Some cigars (stronger ones) usually hold more moisture and age far better within these dynamics. I live in Michigan and believe it or not I prefer aging my cigars at home during the winter months as it is easy to maintain the parameters. On the flip side, I have kept my cigars for an extended time, using the 70/70, and I believe it was too much moisture for my smoking pleasure. Too much moisture hampers the aging and flavor of the cigar. If you were to research on how many of the old Cuban cigars were aged for many years you will find that they are close to the 60/68 that I mentioned. My advice to you is to try putting some cigars at 60/68 and some a little warmer with high RH and see which you like better. Granted I used no scientific method with this but I am a lover of cigars and I want to get the most out of my smoking experience.
The method used to check the hygrometers are fine. If I were to give you 10 hygrometers most of them will read very different. We are talking about mass produced cheap plastic ones that just aren’t going to be all that accurate. I have purchased some that are 30% off. If you keep your cigars in the range of 65-72% and with temps between 60 and 70F your cigars will be fine (IMHO) (I have never had a cigar dry out in this range). If you can keep your cigars separated between mild and strong then I would put the stronger ones at a lower humidity than the milder ones. I don’t know if there is scientific proof of this but I believe that Nicaraguan and Honduran ligero tend hold a little more moisture than most other tobacco. (Closer to Cuban strength) For some odd reason stronger cigars tend to age longer and I believe that if you want to age them longer then they must be at a lower temp 60/68 (this is a safe ratio). I know of many different people that differ in a few degrees and RH from this and none have ever had a problem. Experiment a little as this is not an exact science. The majority of smokers cannot keep everything at perfect conditions if there were some anyway.
For future arguments sake, everything that I have mentioned comes strictly from my experiences with tobacco/cigars.
Thank you again for the great replies
Jason