docrks
Sunday, March 19, 2006 12:43:00 PM
MACS(SW)

Couldn't agree with you more, Bro. Shawn..... One of the truly great things about this thing of ours is the journey of discovery and adventures we get to take in experiencing the different tastes and properties offered by smoking the various cigars in their respective vitolas.

What rates as a TOP 10 in my book may not even be on your list --and the beauty here is -- each point of view is 'correct' for us - because the experience here is so subjective...so it is the journey to finding these things out that is the great thing - not coming up with 'THE BEST CIGAR !!'

BTW Sr. Chief ---while I don't rate the JL No.2 as highly as you do ---the JL No.1 is, I believe, one of the great -and often overlooked -Habana cigars (which is great as the prices stay lower). I LOVE the No. 1s ----in fact ---smoke salute with one of these will be sent your way in about 10 minutes !!!!!

MACS
Sunday, March 19, 2006 12:51:00 PM
Roman - funny you should mention the #1!

echo4alpha, xibbumbero and myself were in the LCdH, Tijuana and I found a box in there from 1999.

I can't remember if Mike smoked one, but Andy and I sure did and they were out-fah-reakin'-standing!

andytv
Sunday, March 19, 2006 12:53:00 PM
ISO Oranges.
MACS
Sunday, March 19, 2006 12:55:00 PM
Oh... and there was a mega-smoke-salute sent your way on friday as I torched 3 of the cigars you sent.

All exceptional!

I have a lil' offering i'll be sending your way... just need to pick up the one ingredient I don't have on-hand.

I'll let you know when it goes out. 😉

emgjet
Sunday, March 19, 2006 1:55:00 PM
Nicely done if we will stay true to this thread about comparing VR Famosos to Cuban Robustos. I believe 'docrks' mention many of the popular robustos readily available. There seems to be a slight variation in taste profile from year to year with the Cohiba Robustos, but, as mentioned before, their deep complexity is excellent. In contrast to the PSD4's, which in my opinion is the best Habana robusto for the price, their flavor profile is the most consistent of all mentioned above.

Now if we compare the VR Famosos to other Hermoso no.4's, the VR's offer the most body and flavor when compared to : ERdM Choix Supreme, SLR Regios, H.Up. Cono #1, and the R&J Ex 4. Though the complexity of the RyJ Ex 4 had wonderful similarities to the RyJ Churchills which is fabulous smoke, the VR Famosos was a more consistent smoke. Many may say that the VR Famosos are one dimensional, and not very complex, but they are a consistent smoke and a great representation of the VR brand.

In comparing all these vitolas, it is appropriate to mention that all opinions are subjective. I would never dismiss a potential great smoke based on the opinions of others. The beauty of this pleasure is experiencing all these fine cigars and enjoying the various nuances of all of them which makes each one unique.

Ed

02hitler
Sunday, March 19, 2006 5:00:00 PM
Wow! Awesome posts!! You guys are good...real good!

I think I'll have to go with docrks advice. Try them all and judge for myself. My trigger finger has been itchin' lately. And I have to start somewhere. The Famosos seem to be just as good a place to start as anywhere else...

echo4alpha
Sunday, March 19, 2006 5:09:00 PM
Shawn, when ya pick up the "one little ingredient", LMK. I gotta pick up some "ingredients" of my own for a few bros out there. Too bad they found the tunnels.

:(

andytv
Sunday, March 19, 2006 5:11:00 PM
hey hitler......

I believe there would probably be enough interest over on the trade boards for a couple box splits.........I mean....if you are looking to try cubans, pick a few and get a few guys together.

02hitler
Monday, March 20, 2006 4:10:00 AM
Hmmmm....

I was thinking about purchasing a box just for myself (because I'm a selfish bastage).

Afterwards I could then maybe trade a couple 5-packs of these for 5-packs of other Hermoso #4s.

Whaddya think?